Buddhist Catholic Contemplative Evangelical General Christian Hindu Jewish Latter-day Saint Muslim New Visions Progressive Christian

Beliefs

Topics

Columnists

Resource Library

Research Tools

Video

Podcasts

Thought Readers

Faith In Media Tracker

Newsletters

Ad-Free & Subscriber Log-In Subscription Support

Follow Patheos

Wrestling with God

Home
New Visions
“Go Set a Watchman” Meets Mother Emanuel

“Go Set a Watchman” Meets Mother Emanuel

Last updated on: July 15, 2015 at 12:02 am by Barbara Falconer Newhall

“Go Set a Watchman” Meets Mother Emanuel 2015-07-14T22:11:06-08:00 Barbara Falconer Newhall

LOGO Patheos Explore the world's faith through different perspectives on religion and spirituality! Patheos has the views of the prevalent religions and spiritualities of the world.

At the bookstore: my brand-new copy of “Watchman,” as yet unopened. Barbara Newhall photo

By Barbara Falconer Newhall

I haven’t cracked open my copy of Go Set a Watchman. But that doesn’t keep me from having opinions about it.

For months now, I’ve been looking forward to taking a look at the long-lost book that was the original version of Harper Lee’s famous, much-loved, much-read best-seller, To Kill a Mockingbird.

I wasn’t planning to rush out to buy it. Maybe I’d wait to get it at the library. But sooner or later I’d get my hands on a copy and study it for what it could tell me about this famous writer’s creative process.

I was wondering, what made Harper Lee put aside this original manuscript and rewrite it as To Kill a Mockingbird? Was the writing inferior in the original version? Was the plot not working? Did the characters not come alive? I assumed that the problem with Go Set a Watchman was a craft problem.

Turns out, if reviewers like Michiko Kakutani of the New York Times are correct, the problem with Go Set a Watchman was not a craft problem. It was a theme problem — a theme problem embodied in the character of Atticus Finch.

In Mockingbird, Finch is the heroic, sensitive, forward-looking attorney, adored by his young children, who comes to the defense of a black man standing trial for rape.

A sign outside A Great Good Place for Books bookstore in Oakland, California, advertises the first day of sales of “Go Set a Watchman.” Photo by Barbara Newhall

In Watchman, Atticus is a southern bigot who lets loose with hate speech. When his daughter, the grown-up Scout, comes home from New York, she is distressed to learn that her beloved father has attended a Klan meeting.

Kakutani asks: “How did a distressing narrative filled with characters spouting hate speech . . . mutate into a redemptive novel associated with the civil rights movement, hailed, in the words of the former civil rights activist and congressman Andrew Young, for giving us ‘a sense of emerging humanism and decency’”?

I ask: Why was a bigot transformed into a larger-than-life hero? Why did Watchman become an – idealized? – story about an idealistic man?

Maybe because a good, well written story with a heavy shot of idealism is what was needed in civil rights era 1960.

According to Times writer Jonathan Mahler, that idealistic story is the one that Harper Lee elected to tell under the guidance – influence? — of her motherly, strong-willed editor, Tay Hohoff.

But now maybe we – by we I mean the American zeitgeist – maybe we are ready for a different story.

I’m thinking about the families and church friends of the nine parishioners murdered at the Emanuel African Methodist Episcopal Church, aka Mother Emanuel, in South Carolina last month.

Miraculously, they found themselves capable of forgiving their loved ones’ murderer. Their open-heartedness set off a chain reaction of open-heartedness around the country – leading to President Obama’s June 26 eulogy at Emanuel AME and the South Carolina legislature’s decision to take down the Confederate battle flag.

It’s not 1960 anymore. It’s 2015. The events in South Carolina point out that perhaps we are ready to feel a heavy shot of compassion for the pain and fear that the “bigots” in our midst are feeling.

Kakutani puts it this way: “‘Mockingbird’ suggested that we should have compassion for outsiders like Boo and Tom Robinson, while ‘Watchman’ asks us to have understanding for a bigot named Atticus.”

Copies of “Go Set a Watchman” were stacked high at A Great Good Place for Books. Photo by Barbara Newhall

But wait, I’m not done here. I’ve got one more preconceived idea – question – about Watchman to put out there: Under a different editor, with different proclivities, might Watchman have become a different story entirely, maybe an even better one?

In the process of cleaning up the Atticus character and making him presentable – and, yes, inspiring — to high school English classes everywhere, wasn’t another, equally poignant (but possibly more nuanced) story lost: The painful story of a young woman who goes home to her beloved father to find he has feet of clay?

Let’s see what happens when I actually read the book. No doubt some more opinions will rear their feisty heads.

A version of this post appeared originally on BarbaraFalconerNewhall.com, where Barbara writes about the view from the second half of life. If you enjoyed this post, you might like “Do Books Have Rights? This One Didn’t. I Threw It in the Trash.” Learn more about her new book from Patheos Press at WrestlingWithGodBook.com.

south carolina church murders

Previous Post

July 14, 2015

A Persistent Seeker Takes on the Hard Questions

Next Post

July 21, 2015 Religion in America? There's a Whole Lot of Wrestling Going On

Browse Our Archives

Select a Category Uncategorized

Select a Month January 2017 December 2016 November 2016 September 2016 July 2016 June 2016 May 2016 April 2016 March 2016 February 2016 January 2016 December 2015 November 2015 October 2015 September 2015 August 2015 July 2015 June 2015 May 2015 April 2015 March 2015 February 2015 January 2015 December 2014

TAKE THE

Religious Wisdom Quiz

What did Isaiah see in his vision in Isaiah 6?

Select your answer to see how you score.

The Lord seated on His throne A chariot of fire A burning bush A ladder to heaven