Buddhist Catholic Contemplative Evangelical General Christian Hindu Jewish Latter-day Saint Muslim New Visions Progressive Christian

Beliefs

Topics

Columnists

Resource Library

Research Tools

Video

Podcasts

Thought Readers

Faith In Media Tracker

Newsletters

Ad-Free & Subscriber Log-In Subscription Support

Follow Patheos

Home
Progressive Christian
History and Religion
Revelation: A Failed Prophecy That Finds New Life

Revelation: A Failed Prophecy That Finds New Life

Last updated on: July 6, 2024 at 6:25 pm by William T. Orr, Jr.

0 Comments

Revelation: A Failed Prophecy That Finds New Life 2024-07-06T18:25:18-04:00 William T. Orr, Jr.

LOGO Patheos Explore the world's faith through different perspectives on religion and spirituality! Patheos has the views of the prevalent religions and spiritualities of the world.

Some Christians, even today, some 200 years after it was written, believe that the Book of Revelation is a blueprint for the end of time, which they believe is now likely at hand. Let us examine that belief and see what we can make of it.

Failed Prophecy Gemini-generated Image by William T. Orr, Jr.

The book reports that it was written by God’s servant, John in the Greek island of Patmos. No one knows who John of Patmos was, where he came from, or why he addressed his book to the “seven churches of Asia.”

The author does not give any further information about himself. Biblical scholars have made speculations as to the identity of the author and whether he can be the author of the Gospel of John and the Johannine Letters.

Scholars now believe that the author of the Book of Revelation, the author of the Gospel of John and the author of the Johannine Letters are three separate and distinct people.

So who is this John of Patmos?

The best and simplest answer is that we simply do not know. (Oxford Companion to the Bible, p. 651 ff.) Over the years, early church fathers, theologians and scholars have variously posited that the author of the Book of Revelation is the same author that wrote the Gospel of John and what are known as the Johannine Epistles.

Due to theological differences, subject matter differences and most especially, significant differences in the style and level of sophistication of the Greek in which the book is written. It has been speculated that Greek is a second language for the author who seems to have been a native speaker of Hebrew or more probably Aramaic.

The differences in the Greek seem to be so significant that the author of the Book of Revelation was metaphorically “writing in crayon” compared to the author of the Gospel of John.

When and Why was the Book of Revelation written?

While we do not know much of anything at all about the author, we can use clues from the text to try to form an informed opinion about the book’s purpose.

There are many sources which can re-cap the book. That is not our purpose here. Excellent synopses can be found in the Oxford Companion to the Bible and in the Wikipedia entry which also provides an excellent selection of additional resources for additional study.

The Book of Revelation is an example of what is known as apocalyptic literature, a genre that became popular during the time in which the Book of Revelation is placed. This was a time when the convergence of Jewish and Christian theological traditions, mythologies from the surrounding cultures and the heavy yoke of the succession of empires had, in turn, subjugated Israel and the Jewish people, culminating with the expanding Roman Empire which was the immediate threat at the time the book was being written.

Other examples of apocalyptic literature in the Judeo-Christian tradition are the Hebrew Bible books of Isaiah, Ezekiel and Daniel and in re-telling the “history” of Israel 1 and 2 Chronicles.

Beginning with Irenaeus 9180 CE), scholars have placed the writing of the Book of Revelation during the latter part of the reign of the Emperor Domitian (81-96 CE). This makes it roughly contemporaneous with the Hebrew Bible book of Daniel. In fact, many of the images in the book of revelation recall images in the Book of Daniel as well as the books of Isaiah and Ezekiel and ancient Jewish literature, clearly influenced by neighboring cultures.

What is Apocalyptic Literature?

We are plagued here with an annoyance that scholars tolerate but which confuses issues in historical inquiry.

In our day, the term apocalyptic literature has come to mean something more specific than the words themselves would imply. Both words, apocalypse and revelation mean an uncovering, an exposition, an unveiling or an unfolding.

These generic definitions have been honed over the centuries to mean:

Apocalyptic literature is a genre of prophetical writing that developed in post-Exilic Jewish culture and was popular among millennialist early Christians. Apocalypse is a Greek word meaning “revelation”, “an unveiling or unfolding of things not previously known and which could not be known apart from the unveiling”

Today, when we speak of apocalyptic literature, we refer to the genre of specifically Jewish and Christian writings that ostensibly predicted the end of the world as it was known at the time and the ushering in of a new universal Kingdom of the Creator god YHWH(Adonai) and administered by a figure known as the Son of Man, a figure who has been associated with the Christian Messiah, Yeshua ben Josef.

What was the need for apocalyptic literature?

The first century CE, that is the first century after the death and reported resurrection of the Christian Messiah, was a dangerous time in the area of the world controlled by Rome and its vassal states. Rome had expanded its empire well into northern Europe and all of the area surrounding the Mediterranean Sea from Iberia east to the Levant and from there, across North Africa.

Rome’s wide reach caused two things, the development of vassal states (Herod’s kingdom of Judea, for example) for administrative simplicity and a brutal and unforgiving control of its possessions.

Rome was known to allow religious flexibility as long as the Emperor was worshipped as a god and as long as the taxes were paid. The Emperors did not much care how these taxes were collected as long as the Empire received its allotted amount. This led, inevitably, to horrible abuses by vassal kings and rulers.

Revelation is Failed Prophecy Gemini-generated Image by William T. Orr, Jr.

By this time in their history, the Jewish people had suffered a succession of invasions and conquests. The small kingdoms of Israel and Judah were constantly threatened by neighboring kingdoms like Edom, Moab and Philistia.

In 722 BCE, the northern kingdom of Israel was overrun and destroyed by the Assyrian Empire who made the southern kingdom of Judah a vassal state.

Then in 586 BCE, the neo-Babylonian empire invaded Judah, destroying its capital, Jerusalem, and the Temple, the central place of worship of the Jewish people.

Babylon removed Judah’s elite (the rich, the educated, the priests and scribes) to Babylon where they were held until the neo-Babylonian Empire fell to the Persian Empire in 538 BCE.

The Persians, in turn, fell to Alexander’s army and finally, the entire area was subjugated by Rome.

By this time, the literature, and in fact the character of the Jewish people reflected a history and a culture of defeat and survival.

What changed in the first century CE?

Israel and the Jews were YHWH’s people since Abraham’s covenant and Moses’s Exodus. The Hebrew Bible is a record (and a fabricated history) of the Jewish people and the nation/people Israel. The Hebrew Bible tells the stories of how Israel disappointed its God time and time again and how its God punished it each time, usually by having Israel invaded by a neighboring kingdom.

The scriptures seemed to promise a means of salvation and there was an expectation of a Savior or Messiah.

This expectation grew over time and as the Roman governors and vassal kings strangled the people more tightly, messiah claimants appeared, preaching in the street and in homes.

The most famous of these, was of course, Yeshua ben Josef, who was given, in the scriptures of the New Testament, no less an identification as the Only Son of God.

The Jewish people were ready, but the Temple priesthood saw a threat to their power and the Roman governor, possibly with their consent, executed Yeshua.

First failed prophecy.

Yeshua, who was reported to have miraculous powers and who was born into a rich Jewish tradition of Messianic expectation, failed, by his death to deliver the Jews once again, from bondage. A few groups of Jews began to think of the past scriptures in different terms and of their failed Messiah in a new light. Perhaps the deliverance was not so much physical, but more spiritual. The salvation might be something that could be looked for in a near future, a near future in which the Kingdom of Heaven would be ushered in on the Earth and in which the Son of Man would reign forever at the right hand of YHWH.

These prophecies, a part of the literature of the Jewish people were built on the stories and symbolisms of the Covenant, the Exodus and the many wars and conquests of the Jews and their neighbors over centuries.

By the time Rome has subjugated Judea, no salvation, no second deliverance had occurred.

Where did the story go from there?

During and immediately following the period of the Babylonian captivity (586BCE – 538 BCE), Jewish scribes, prophets and priests realized that in order for the Jewish people to emerge as a people, a cohesive story of their history had to be written and edited. When the next succession of rulers came and went and Judea finally came under Roman control, prophets like Isaiah, Ezekiel and finally Daniel, began to report visions of the end times, visions which incorporated ancient images and creatures from Israel’s earliest mythology and the mythologies of surrounding countries.

Over time, a general understanding of the end times was adopted by some of the first century CE groups of people who had come to be known as Christians.

So, in the first century CE, Christian and Jewish apocalyptic prophets were writing about the end times that were going to occur within their lifetimes.

Yeshua, himself, according to the Gospels, had believed that the Kingdom of God would come within the lifetimes of his contemporaries.

The Book of Revelation tells terrifying stories of the end times.

Images in Revelation are frightening Gemini Generated Image by William T. Orr, Jr.

Clearly, this did not occur.

Once the prophecy of Salvation failed, it was up to the Christian communities to explain this to the people.

A new, revised theology was developed, fought over and adopted in many forms in the following centuries.

Each community, each denomination, each sect, each specific orthodoxy explained things in different ways but the final arrangement allowed core beliefs with infinite varieties.

Where did it all land?

In general, Christians today believe that a person can overcome his “sinful nature” by following the teachings of Yeshua, as interpreted by people who have special knowledge and abilities. These are the priests and ministers of Christian churches. The simple faith of the early Christians has been made complicated and complex by the priestly class, somewhat akin to the machinations of the Levites in the Hebrew Bible.

Churches will tell you exactly how one is to follow Yeshua, but their leaders will not honestly engage you in a dialogue about what they learned in seminary and are withholding from their flock..

A few will even tell you that the events in the Book of Revelation are happening today and will recount events from recent history to “prove” their case.

I would recommend that you look into the scriptures and the many books written to help with understanding and make up your own mind.

I have two final thoughts on the Book of Revelation.

If you are looking for events in recent history to “fulfill” the prophecy of Revelation, you will be disappointed. The turmoil of the first century CE was a very different time and while human nature does not change, circumstances do. If you encounter Christians or anyone else who says he or she can “prove” anything in the Bible, be wary. Religion deals in faith, not proof.
The Book of Revelation was written about the Roman Empire and its subjugation of Israel. It was not written about Russia, China, Iran, Saudi-Arabia, modern Israel or the United States. It was not written about Donald Trump, Joe Biden, Vladimir Putin or Kim Jong Un. It was written about Rome and probably Nero.

I know that not everyone will agree with my interpretations. I am a public student of Biblical Scholarship, trying to learn as much as I can in the time I have left. Please join me on this quest. Leave a comment and let me know you are there and thinking.

Progressive Christian

General Christian

Education and Religion

About Willoiam T. Orr, Jr.

William T. Orr, Jr. is a retired educator, most recently the principal of a high school named in the Top 10 in the nation by Newsweek magazine. His school was also named to the Newsweek Top 100 each year while he was principal. Orr has been a teacher, a counselor, and a school administrator. He was influential in working in the district and state to lobby for more equitable pay for educators, and has long been a vocal advocate for more academic freedom for educators. Orr has a B.A. in English Language and Literature, a M.Ed. in Education Administration and Supervision, and an Ed.D. in Education leadership. He’s also completed Postdoctoral study at Yale Divinity School and Dallas Theological Seminary. Shortly after retirement, Orr began to study Abrahamic religions with a focus on why and how small religious sects among an often conquered people became what evolved into three of the most dominant and influential religions in the world today. You can read more about the author here.

Previous Post

June 26, 2024

Do You Know Or Do You Believe?