Patheos

BuddhistCatholicContemplativeEvangelicalGeneral ChristianHinduJewishLatter-day SaintMuslimNew VisionsProgressive Christian

Beliefs

Topics

Columnists

Resource Library

Research Tools

Video

Podcasts

Thought Readers

Faith In Media Tracker

Newsletters

Ad-Free & Subscriber Log-In Subscription Support

Patheos

Ad-Free & Subscriber Log-In Subscription Support

Follow Patheos Patheos on Facebook Patheos on YouTube

thespiritualhistorygeek

The Witch in the Hollow

Last updated on: September 16, 2026 at 9:18 am   by Heather Blankenship

0 Comments

The Witch in the Hollow 2026-09-16T09:18:56-04:00 Heather Blankenship

LOGO Patheos Explore the world's faith through different perspectives on religion and spirituality! Patheos has the views of the prevalent religions and spiritualities of the world.

Witch with night sky behind her

Witch or Wise Woman

Something Is Wrong With the Cow

It’s somewhere in the Appalachian Mountains, perhaps around the turn of the twentieth century.

The cow had been perfectly healthy.

Now she isn’t giving milk.

Or perhaps the milk is there—but no matter how long the woman churns, the butter will not come.

Then something else happens.

A horse comes back exhausted in the morning, its mane inexplicably tangled.

A child becomes sick without an obvious cause.

Someone remembers an argument with a neighbor.

And gradually somebody says the word everyone has been thinking:

Witch.

When we hear “Appalachian witch” today, we may imagine a Granny Woman gathering herbs beside her cabin, delivering babies and whispering healing charms over burns.

But historically, that isn’t necessarily who Appalachian people meant when they warned one another about witches.

Sometimes the Granny Woman was the person you went to because you thought a witch had gotten hold of you.

So What Was an Appalachian Witch?

First, there was no single Appalachian witch belief system. Appalachia is enormous, and folklore varied by family, locality, ethnic background, and period.

But collected folklore reveals some recurring themes.

A witch wasn’t necessarily someone practicing herbal medicine or folk healing.

In many stories, the witch was someone believed capable of causing harm through supernatural means—spoiling milk, preventing butter from forming, making livestock sick, causing mysterious illnesses, cursing neighbors, or attacking people at night.

Historical folklore research documents that “Granny Women” and “Granny Witches” sometimes appear positively as community helpers, while “witches” by themselves appear in accounts involving evil or mischief.

The woman who could cure your mysterious illness and the woman believed to have caused it occupied two very different places in the Appalachian imagination.

Woman churning butter

Woman churning butter

The Butter Won’t Come

This one is wonderfully strange and widely documented.

If the cow stopped producing milk, the milk spoiled, or butter refused to form in the churn, people could blame witchcraft.

A nineteenth-century account from the Alleghenies describes a woman whose cow wasn’t producing properly and whose milk wouldn’t “gather” into butter. A folk practitioner diagnosed the cow as bewitched. Another account from 1893 describes putting a heated horseshoe into the churn to break the supposed spell.

Virginia oral history recorded another countermeasure: pins and needles were placed in a cow’s milk and heated, intended to break the witch’s influence.

To understand why this was so serious, you need to understand just what a cow meant to a family.

A cow wasn’t a quaint piece of scenery.

Milk, butter, and livestock represented food and household security. Anything that interfered with the family’s cow could have serious economic consequences.

So the witch wasn’t merely frightening.

She threatened the household’s survival.

The Witch Who Rode You at Night

This one is extra creepy.

Appalachian folklore includes stories about witches “riding” people or animals at night.

Horses supposedly appeared exhausted the following morning with strangely tangled manes—sometimes interpreted as evidence that a witch had ridden them. Early twentieth-century North Carolina folklore records beliefs about witches riding horses at night and leaving tangled “stirrups” in their manes.

A person might wake exhausted, scratched, or feeling as though something had pressed upon them.

Some accounts of nighttime pressure sound strikingly similar to what we now call sleep paralysis.

Today, some experiences historically interpreted as supernatural nighttime attacks might be understood through phenomena such as sleep paralysis, which, if you have experienced it, you know how horrifying it is.

But knowing the modern explanation doesn’t make the historical experience any less terrifying.

Imagine waking unable to move, feeling pressure on your chest, in a culture that has already taught you that witches can ride people in their sleep.

You wouldn’t wake thinking about neurology.

You’d wonder who had ridden you.

Woman standing near log cabin smiling

Was she a witch?

The Witch Didn’t Always Look Like a Witch

Forget the Hollywood stereotypes.

Folklore sometimes gave witches the ability to assume animal forms.

North Carolina traditions included witches supposedly appearing as rabbits or black cats, while other regional stories feature various animal transformations.

Imagine this:

Something moves along the fence line.

A rabbit.

Probably.

Except it stops.

And looks directly at you.

You wonder if that is a witch that has shapeshifted into an animal.

How Do You Know Who the Witch Is?

This is where things could take a dark turn.

People might interpret unexplained illness, livestock problems, bad luck or unusual behavior as evidence of witchcraft.

Then suspicion needed somewhere to land.

A quarrelsome neighbor.

Someone who had recently been refused something.

A socially isolated person.

A woman considered strange.

Someone who already possessed an unsettling reputation.

And that’s where folklore becomes social history.

Believing in witches wasn’t merely believing that supernatural evil existed.

It meant believing supernatural evil might have an address.

That changes everything.

Because now we’re no longer talking about imaginary creatures in the woods.

We’re talking about neighbors accusing neighbors.

Sadly, this wasn’t anything new.

How Do You Break a Witch’s Spell?

If you were dealing with a witch (or thought you were), you would look for counter-magic.

This is one of the most interesting contradictions in the whole subject.

People who would never have considered themselves witches could nevertheless use ritualized actions intended to defeat witchcraft.

Recorded countermeasures included things involving iron, horseshoes, heated objects, pins and needles, herbs, prayer and other protective practices, although customs varied dramatically by place. For example, one Appalachian collection records a horseshoe attached to a butter churn as protection against witches.

But then, here is the contradiction: If you perform a ritual to protect yourself from witchcraft, does that make you a practitioner of magic?

The people performing it might have said absolutely not.

They were protecting themselves from magic.

And we’re right back to the beginning…

Where does religion end, superstition begin and magic enter the picture?

The Silver Bullet

When you think of a silver bullet, your first thought is likely of a werewolf.

But silver bullets weren’t only for werewolves in later popular culture.

Regional Appalachian folklore also records the idea that witches or their animal forms could be harmed with silver bullets.

A North Carolina county history published in the early twentieth century recorded stories claiming that witch-rabbits and black cats could be killed using silver bullets.

Virginia folklore contains even darker stories in which silver coins were melted into ammunition intended to combat suspected witchcraft.

Long before Hollywood taught us that silver belonged in monster hunting kits, people in parts of Appalachia were already putting silver between themselves and things they believed walked the night.

Older woman holding herbs

The Granny Woman could help…

8. The Granny Woman Wasn’t Necessarily the Witch

Situations like these were when people went in search for their local Granny Woman.

She was among the fire talkers and blood stoppers.

She might know medicinal plants, deliver babies, and use Bible verses in healing;

Talk the fire out.

Stop blood.

Interpret signs and possess knowledge handed down through her family…

…and still consider herself a devout Christian who would be horrified if somebody called her a witch.

Smithsonian’s discussion of Appalachian folk practice notes that many practitioners did not identify with witchcraft at all, even when their practices look magical to modern observers.

But the modern internet loves the phrase “Appalachian Granny Witch.”

History is less cooperative.

Some healers may indeed have been called witches. Others absolutely were not.

And if I want to understand these women rather than simply turn them into characters who resemble me, I have to let them define themselves whenever the evidence allows it.

Christianity Didn’t Make Witch Belief Disappear

In many communities, Christianity and belief in witchcraft weren’t mutually exclusive.

Quite the opposite.

If you believed God, angels, miracles, and spiritual power were real, then believing harmful supernatural forces could also exist wasn’t necessarily inconsistent.

Demons, haints, witches and other creatures were definitely thought to exist.

This also explains why protection against supposed witchcraft could involve Christian prayer or scripture rather than something its practitioners understood as magic.

The same Bible could exist in a world containing:

prayer,

healing charms,

omens,

witches,

ghosts,

and divine intervention.

People didn’t necessarily experience those things as belonging to separate shelves.

So, who Got Called a Witch?

Witch accusations could have serious, if not deadly, consequences.

Folklore can reveal social tensions: suspicion toward outsiders, difficult neighbors, socially marginal people, and women who violated expectations.

This isn’t an “all accused witches were persecuted feminist healers,” because that’s another modern mythology.

Instead, I ask:

What made a community suspicious of someone?

And:

What happens when ordinary misfortune is given a human culprit?

There’s a fascinating recent scholarly example here: research into an 1891 Appalachian witchcraft accusation shows how stories about livestock, silver bullets and an alleged “white witch” could become attached to an identifiable woman and persist in print.

Appalachian Witchcraft Wasn’t One Tradition

As I’ve mentioned in previous articles, the Appalachian region contains influences and communities with European, African/African American, and Indigenous histories, among others.

Smithsonian’s overview describes folk traditions developing through cultural contact among these populations, while also emphasizing that practitioners themselves use many different names and identities.

But avoid the internet formula:

“Scots-Irish magic + Cherokee magic + African magic = Appalachian witchcraft.”

Real cultural exchange isn’t a recipe.

And especially with Cherokee traditions, don’t casually take a Cherokee belief, call it “Appalachian witchcraft,” and present it as universally available folk practice.

Appalachia is a place where cultures met, but “influence” does not mean every tradition became communal property.

Would They Have Called Me a Witch?

I have often wondered about this one.

As a modern Pagan studying Appalachian folk traditions, I sometimes wonder what one of my nineteenth-century Appalachian ancestors would make of me.

Pagan. Tarot cards. An interest in herbs, folk magic, and old spiritual traditions. I live alone with one fur monster of the feline persuasion.

I’m reasonably certain someone would eventually have a few questions.

Blonde woman sitting amongst her herbs with the mountains in the background

Me as an Appalachian woman…or witch?

The word witch means something very different to you than it may have meant to them.

For many modern practitioners, witch can mean spiritual identity, empowerment, nature spirituality or magical practice.

For someone in an Appalachian hollow generations ago, witch might mean:

the person who made your cow go dry.

Those are not interchangeable identities.

The Witch Across the Hollow

The butter still won’t come.

The horse is exhausted.

Someone is sick.

Across the hollow lives the woman somebody suspects.

Maybe she did nothing.

Almost certainly, whatever was happening had an ordinary explanation we would recognize today.

But after sunset, you see a black animal moving along the tree line.

And suddenly every story you’ve ever heard comes rushing back.

Did a witch do this?

I don’t know whether there were witches hiding in Appalachian hollows.

But I know people believed there were.

And perhaps that is the more interesting history.

Because folklore isn’t only about the monsters people imagined.

It’s about what people feared enough to call monstrous.

The Appalachian witch wasn’t always the wise herbalist standing beside a bubbling pot.

Sometimes she was the neighbor across the hollow.

The woman everyone whispered about.

The explanation for the milk that spoiled, the horse that woke exhausted, the illness nobody could explain.

And when something scratched against the cabin wall after midnight, nobody was particularly interested in asking whether the distinction between folklore and reality was historically accurate.

They just wanted to know one thing.

Was the witch outside?

Pagan

Uncategorized

Appalachian Folk Magic

Folk Healing

Granny Women

Paganism

superstitions

Witch

About Heather Blankenship

Heather is a writer, amateur historian, polyglot and aspiring digital nomad. She hopes to share her various experiences from two very different faiths and the richness of both. She is passionate about animal rights and is owned by a furry feline overlord. Chocolate and coffee are her life blood. You can read more about the author here.

Previous Post



September 15, 2026

When an Owl Calls Your Name: Appalachian Folklore

Next Post



September 19, 2026 Something Followed Me Home: The Dead Who Wouldn't Leave

Recent Comments

0 | Leave a Comment


Browse Our Archives

Select a Category Uncategorized

Select a Month October 2026 September 2026 May 2025 March 2025 February 2025 November 2023 June 2023




TAKE THE

Religious Wisdom Quiz

Who said: "The reason the Son of God appeared was to destroy the devil's work"?

Select your answer to see how you score.

John Paul Jesus Peter

Related posts from The Spiritual History Geek

History and Religion

The Dead Man’s Hand: Appalachian Graveyard Magic

The Spiritual History Geek

History and Religion

Angel Crowns: An Eerie Appalachian Death Tradition

The Spiritual History Geek

History and Religion

Haint Blue: How a Color Protected Appalachian People

The Spiritual History Geek

History and Religion

Appalachian Tales of Meeting Satan in Disguise

The Spiritual History Geek

TRENDING AT PATHEOS History and Religion

The Dead Man’s Hand: Appalachian Graveyard Magic

When the Mountains Go Dark: Appalachian Folklore for Spooky Season Installment 3...

Angel Crowns: An Eerie Appalachian Death Tradition

When the Mountains Go Dark: Appalachian Folklore for Spooky Season Angel Crowns:...

Is 'Separation of Church and State' Really a...

Beware the Religious Liberty Commission Recently, President Trump's Religious Liberty Commission issued...

Is Zen really Daoism?

There has long been a popular belief that Zen Buddhism is as...

Is Our Spirituality Communal or Individual?

Here, I take swings at sacred cows. I suspect that more sacred...

How Could Christianity be Different?

Christians can no longer plead ignorance. And Christians' reluctance to listen will...

view all History and Religion blogs

What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment

Patheos on Facebook Patheos on YouTube

Ad-Free & Subscriber Log-In Subscription Support

Copyright 2008-2026, Patheos. All rights reserved.

Subscription Support Ad-Free & Subscriber Log-In

Follow Patheos Patheos on Facebook Patheos on YouTube