Buddhist Catholic Contemplative Evangelical General Christian Hindu Jewish Latter-day Saint Muslim New Visions Progressive Christian

Beliefs

Topics

Columnists

Resource Library

Research Tools

Video

Podcasts

Thought Readers

Faith In Media Tracker

Newsletters

Ad-Free & Subscriber Log-In Subscription Support

Follow Patheos

Home
General Christian
Family, Parenting and Religion
When Christians Won’t Let You Outlive Your Past

When Christians Won’t Let You Outlive Your Past

Last updated on: August 10, 2026 at 10:05 am by Kurt W. Bubna

0 Comments

When Christians Won’t Let You Outlive Your Past 2026-08-10T10:05:01-07:00 Kurt W. Bubna

LOGO Patheos Explore the world's faith through different perspectives on religion and spirituality! Patheos has the views of the prevalent religions and spiritualities of the world.

There are days when I still feel like an outcast.

I wish I could tell you that after enough time passes, enough counseling, enough repentance, enough apologies, and enough healing, rejection doesn’t hurt anymore.

It still does.

There are people I once laughed with, prayed with, served alongside, and deeply loved who haven’t spoken to me in years since my divorce. Some have literally turned around and walked the other way when they saw me coming.

No confrontation. No angry words. Just someone who once knew and loved me deciding they don’t want to be near me anymore.

And I’ve stood there wondering what I’m supposed to do with that.

Part of me wants to scream, “You know I’m not denying what I did, right? You know I’ve spent years owning this? You know I’m not the same man I was in my worst moment?”

But usually, I don’t say anything.

I just feel it.

And yes, it hurts.

For nearly forty years, I was a pastor. I preached about grace, forgiveness, restoration, mercy, and the God of second chances. I sat across from broken people and told them Jesus wasn’t finished with them.

Then my own life fell apart, and suddenly grace wasn’t a sermon topic anymore.

I needed it to breathe.

My marriage of nearly five decades ended. I failed people I loved. I sinned. I broke trust and caused real pain. I found myself standing in the rubble of a life and reputation that had taken decades to build.

There is no clever theological sentence that makes any of that disappear, and there shouldn’t be.

I Am Not the Victim in My Story

This is important.

I’m not writing any of this to make myself the victim.

I made choices that hurt people. I have owned those choices publicly and privately more times than I can count. I don’t excuse what I did, minimize it, or blame someone else for my failures.

And some consequences don’t disappear simply because you’ve repented.

I’ve learned that the hard way, too.

Some relationships still haven’t been restored. There are people I love who are no longer part of my life, and there are days when that grief catches me off guard.

Sometimes I’m sad.

Sometimes I’m angry.

Sometimes I replay conversations in my head and imagine saying everything I wish I could say.

Sometimes I wonder, “How long do I have to pay for this?”

But eventually, I come back to something I know is true: I cannot control another person’s willingness to forgive me, trust me, reconcile with me, or see the man I’m becoming rather than only the man who failed.

I can keep my heart open. I can own what is mine to own. I can make amends wherever possible. I can stay humble and keep growing, but I cannot force reconciliation.

And I can’t spend the rest of my life trying to convince someone to give me what only God can ultimately give me: an identity rooted in grace.

I Refuse to Believe the Cross Wasn’t Enough

This is where I’ve planted my feet. I refuse to believe that the cross wasn’t enough.

Jesus didn’t forgive me halfway. He didn’t set me free from guilt only to leave me chained to shame for the rest of my life.

He didn’t say, “It is finished…except for Kurt. He’s got another twenty or thirty years of groveling to do.”

He forgave me completely.

So, here’s the question I can’t seem to shake: Why do we sometimes demand that people keep paying for something Jesus has already paid for?

Why do we ghost repentant people? Why do we treat someone who has genuinely confessed, repented, and changed as if they must remain a permanent pariah?

I’ve spent most of my life in the church, and I still love the church. At her best, she is one of the most beautiful expressions of Jesus on this planet.

But Christians can sometimes be remarkably good at remembering sins God has chosen to remove.

We know the verses about grace. We sing about amazing grace. We preach salvation by grace.

Then somebody needs a scandalous amount of it, and suddenly we get nervous.

Accountability matters. Repentance matters. Holiness matters. Consequences matter. Protecting people from someone who remains abusive, deceptive, manipulative, or unrepentant matters enormously.

But surely restoration matters too.

Mercy matters too.

And if there is no pathway forward for someone who has genuinely repented, then I must wonder whether we’re practicing the gospel we preach.

Grace Doesn’t Require Amnesia

Psalm 103 contains some words I’ve returned to repeatedly:

“The LORD is compassionate and gracious, slow to anger, abounding in love…as far as the east is from the west, so far has he removed our transgressions from us” (Psalm 103:8, 12).

I love that.

Apparently, God doesn’t keep forgiven sin nearby in a file just in case He needs ammunition later.

People sometimes do. And, frankly, sometimes I do it to myself.

That’s one of the harder things I’ve discovered.

I wish knowing the theology of grace meant I never felt shame anymore. It doesn’t.

There are mornings when an old memory gets to me before my feet hit the floor. Something triggers a regret, a name crosses my mind, or I remember someone I miss, and suddenly I’m back there again.

There are moments when somebody’s rejection still gets under my skin.

I can know exactly what Romans 8 says and still not feel particularly “uncondemned.”

Maybe that’s part of what faith actually is. Faith isn’t always feeling free. Sometimes it’s choosing to believe what God says about me while something inside me is whispering something very different.

Guilt and Shame Are Not the Same Thing

This distinction has become deeply important to me.

Guilt says, “I did something wrong.” (And I did.)

Healthy guilt can lead us toward confession, repentance, restitution, and change. We shouldn’t run from that kind of conviction. It’s one of the ways God gets our attention and brings us home.

Shame says something different, however.

Shame says, “What you did is who you are.”

That’s a lie I’ve had to confront repeatedly.

Shame takes your worst chapter and writes the title of your entire story with it.

Adulterer.

Divorced.

Failure.

Disqualified.

Hypocrite.

Unworthy.

Beyond repair.

I’ve heard some of those labels from others. I’ve heard many more inside my own head. But grace refuses to let our past become our permanent identity.

That’s one of the central things I’ve been wrestling with as I’ve written my latest book, Unshamed. Healing doesn’t come from pretending the worst parts of our story never happened. I don’t want to rewrite my history to make myself look better.

Freedom comes when we can finally look honestly at what we’ve done, own it without excuses, learn from it, and still believe what God says about us now.

My past certainly explains some things about me, and I’d be a fool to pretend otherwise. I’ve been humbled, and sometimes humiliated, by my failures.

But strangely enough, there has been a gift buried somewhere beneath all that pain.

I know myself better now. More importantly, I know grace differently now.

My Sin Cost Me a Lot

My sin cost me friendships, relationships, trust, respect, opportunities, and a reputation that took decades to build.

It cost me sleepless nights and more tears than I care to remember. There are relational losses I still grieve. There are consequences I continue to live with today.

I don’t say any of that dramatically. It’s simply true.

Sin leaves a trail of brokenness. But here’s something else that is true: My sin cost Jesus infinitely more than it cost me.

At the cross, Jesus willingly paid a debt I could never repay. He didn’t excuse my sin. He absorbed its penalty.

That’s why “sinner” doesn’t get to be the defining word over my life anymore.

Have I sinned? Of course.

Do I still fall short? Ask my wife. She can probably provide documentation.

Do I still need to grow? More than I’d like to admit.

But because I am in Christ, my failures don’t get the final word about who I am.

I am a son.

Not because I’ve earned that title, but because He gave it to me.

Paul wrote, “Therefore, if anyone is in Christ, he is a new creation. The old has passed away; behold, the new has come” (2 Corinthians 5:17).

Paul doesn’t say the old never happened; it happened! But he says something new has happened that is even more powerful.

Grace Has Made Honesty Safer

For years, I worried that talking too much about grace might cause people to take sin less seriously. I don’t believe that anymore. In fact, grace has actually made it easier for me to tell the truth about myself.

When my standing with God depends on maintaining the illusion that I’m a good guy who rarely screws up, I’ll hide. I’ll defend myself. I’ll explain away my failures, blame someone else, and work very hard to protect my image.

But when I know I am already fully known and deeply loved by God, I don’t have to pretend.

I can say, “I did that.”

“I was wrong.”

“I hurt people.”

“I desperately needed mercy.”

And then, by God’s grace, I can get up and keep following Jesus.

That’s not cheap grace. Cheap grace says sin doesn’t matter.

Real grace looks directly at the ugliness of sin and then points to a cross where Jesus said, “I’ll take that.”

Henri Nouwen wrote about the great spiritual task of accepting the truth that we are radically loved by God and that nothing we do can change that love.

I’m still learning to live there. Some days I’m better at it than others.

Maybe You’re the Outcast

I’m not writing this for pity or sympathy. I’m certainly not writing it to excuse my choices or the pain I’ve caused. I’m writing because I wonder how many people quietly carry this same ache.

Maybe you’re the person others avoid now.

Maybe your divorce became the adjective attached to your name.

Maybe you failed morally, financially, relationally, or spiritually. You’ve confessed it. You’ve repented. You’ve changed. You’ve tried to make things right. But somebody in your life seems determined to keep you standing in the rubble forever.

If that’s you, I wish I could promise that everyone will eventually see the new you.

They may not, and that’s one of the hardest things I’ve had to accept.

Can’t Force It

You can’t make someone forgive you. You can’t force reconciliation. You can’t demand trust. And you can’t make someone stop defining you by the worst thing you’ve ever done. But you don’t have to surrender your identity to their opinion of you either.

People may remember your worst chapter. God knows the entire story.

So, own what you’ve done. Make amends wherever you can. Accept the consequences you cannot change. Stay humble. Keep growing. Keep your heart soft, even toward people who have hardened theirs toward you.

And when shame comes knocking tomorrow morning again, don’t be surprised. Just don’t invite it in to hang out.

You are not required to spend the rest of your life trying to pay a debt Jesus already paid in full.

My sin cost me a lot. It cost Jesus everything. And because He paid for it all, shame doesn’t get to write the ending of my story.

Grace does.

I’m learning to believe that.

Some days, I’m even learning to live like it’s true.

This article draws from themes in my upcoming book, Unshamed, about failure, divorce, shame, healing, and the sometimes messy journey of learning to live as someone fully known, forgiven, and free.