Faint Praise for PEPFAR

Last updated on: July 7, 2014 at 5:39 pm by Guest Contributor

Faint Praise for PEPFAR 2014-07-07T17:39:50-04:00 Guest Contributor

LOGO Patheos Explore the world's faith through different perspectives on religion and spirituality! Patheos has the views of the prevalent religions and spiritualities of the world.

Editors’ Note: This article is part of the Public Square 2014 Summer Series: Conversations on Religious Trends. Read other perspectives from the Evangelical community here.

By Warren Cole Smith

We have passed the 10-year mark for PEPFAR – the President’s Emergency Plan for AIDS Relief. The effort has so far spent more than $15-billion to help reduce AIDS, and given the size of the program, it is easy to point to specific examples of success. Rob Smith, who has worked with orphans in Africa for years as part of the Christian ministries Pilgrim and The Agathos Foundation, recently told me how PEPFAR helped Nkule, a little boy who was HIV positive. Before PEPFAR, Smith said, “The cocktail of anti-retroviral drugs he needed was simply out of reach for us to treat him. After PEPFAR paid for a local clinic, run by a Christian doctor, we could afford to get him the meds needed. Nkule became strong and healthy.”

I do not deny the reality of such stories, nor do I discount the value of even a single life saved. But I think it’s important to ask whether such individual stories, no matter how heart-wrenching, tell the whole story of PEPFAR. Advocates say yes. They claim Nkule was just one of the more than 1-million lives were saved by PEPFAR. They say PEPFAR enhanced America’s standing in Africa. But do these claims hold up under scrutiny?

I also think it is worth asking broader philosophical questions: Did PEPFAR perpetuate a culture of dependency in the African countries that received PEPFAR funds? Did PEPFAR contribute to a false understanding of what caused AIDS, and what slowed its spread? Did the “feel good” stories of PEPFAR provide cover for those Republicans and Democrats who have ballooned our federal debt from $6-trillion in the year Congress authorized PEPFAR to the current level of just short of $18-trillion, a level that now poses a serious threat to our national well-being, and our ability to exert a positive influence in the world.

My concern for these questions began when I made a reporting trip to India in 2003, the same year PEPFAR legislation became law, to write about the AIDS crisis there. Conventional wisdom then was that if the AIDS rate in India increased beyond the current level, it would pass a “tipping point” and there would be no stopping it. Uganda and other countries had faced infection rates that threatened their very existence. That fear was, in fact, a major impetus for PEPFAR. Because India is a much larger country, and a much more significant trading partner with the rest of the world, if what happened in Uganda happened to India, the fear was that AIDS could become a global pandemic.

I will condense a lot of history and say that while AIDS in Uganda and many other countries in Africa diminished significantly, it is important to note that AIDS in India dialed back by a similarly impressive amount – and without one dime of PEPFAR money. India accomplished a dramatic reduction in new AIDS cases and AIDS deaths because of a three-legged stool of free enterprise (the private sector development of new drugs, funded by market demand and venture capital), charity, and the responsibility the government of India took for its own people.

When you compare India to Uganda, one of the key recipients of PEPFAR funds, you see some surprising differences – and some surprising similarities. Uganda was devastated by AIDS in the 1980s. Millions of people died, and by 1991 nearly 15 percent of the country’s adult population was HIV-positive. Uganda shared with India this: that long before PEPFAR came along, Uganda was solving its own problems. In Uganda, Christian ministries, Uganda’s indigenous Christian church, and the leadership of Janet Museveni – the evangelical Christian wife of the country’s president – made the difference. The country pioneered an ABC program (Abstinence, Be faithful, and Condoms) that pushed down AIDS rates. By the time PEPFAR money started coming into Uganda, AIDS prevalence was already less than half of 1990 levels.

In fact, Dr. Edward Green, an anthropologist at Harvard University, said changes in sexual behavior – specifically, sexual fidelity to one’s husband or wife, and abstinence among the unmarried – were the two most important factors in the decline of AIDS in Uganda. A 2004 study published in the journal Science arrived at similar conclusions: abstinence and monogamy led to the dramatic decline of AIDS in Uganda.

In fact, since 2003 and the advent of PEPFAR, AIDS rates in Uganda have leveled off and have even begun to rise a bit from their lowest levels. It’s too early to know why, or even if the rise is just an outlier in a continuing downward trend, but it’s possible that the drugs PEPFAR bought, and which have without doubt extended the lives of people with AIDS, have also created a sense that AIDS is not as dangerous as it was in the 1980s and 90s, and that sense may be causing sexual promiscuity to creep back into the Ugandan culture. The leveling out of AIDS rates in PEPFAR countries – countries that before PEPFAR saw significant declines – suggests that PEPFAR may in fact be playing a role in causing us to forget just how we got in this mess in the first place.

But that’s not the only unintended consequence of PEPFAR. As I said earlier, one of the greatest threats to our country is the massive debt the federal government is piling up. Before the election of George W. Bush, social conservatives often joined hands with fiscal conservatives to fight the ever-expanding federal government. But the “big government conservatism” of George W. Bush, perhaps no better exemplified than by PEPFAR, had the effect of buying off social conservatives. Because social conservatives were, under Bush, able to feed at the federal trough, our voices were muted as the national debt doubled during the Bush Administration. PEPFAR became the bone thrown to social conservatives that turned many of us from watchdogs into lapdogs. It is popular to say PEPFAR saved a million lives. It is impossible to say how many lives it cost by throwing a spanner in the works of the greatest poverty and disease eradication machine known to man: a freely functioning entrepreneurial economy. The assertion of a million lives saved looks only at the credits, not the debits. PEPFAR’s credits are real, but they are now almost fully counted, while the debits continue to pour in.

It is impossible to say PEPFAR did no good. The story we started with, of Nkule, makes that plain. But Rob Smith – the man who told me that story – also said the cause of Nkule’s return to health “was not just PEPFAR,” but the advent of generic versions of AIDS drugs, a development which owed nothing to PEPFAR. So let’s give PEPFAR credit for its modest – though costly — benefits, but we should be clear-eyed about cause and effect, and not cloud the truth by giving extra credit where no credit is due.

Warren Cole Smith is Vice President of WORLD News Group, the publisher of WORLD Magazine.

conservative politics

PEPFAR

Previous Post

June 30, 2014

The American Church and Global AIDS over the Last Decade: An Untold Story

Next Post

July 16, 2014 Michael Gerson: Looking Back on a Decade of PEPFAR

Browse Our Archives

Select a Category Abortion Abortion adoption Africa Aging AIDS America Worship American history Americolatry An Open Letter to a College Freshman animals Apologetics art Atheism Authors Barack Obama Bible Biblical Scholarship Billy Graham Blogging Bono Book Review Books That Change Lives Breakfast Links Bulletin Board Business Children Christian Approach to Politics Christian Media Christian Right Derangement Syndrome Christianity and Homosexuality Christians in Government Christmas Chuck Colson CLS v Martinez Comic Creation Creativity and the Arts Cross Examinations Cross Investigations Daily Fragment Daily Trinity Death debt Deep Thoughts on Fatherhood depression economy education Election 2012 entertainment Environment Epistemology Erik Campano Euthanasia Evangelicalism Evangelicals and Gays Everyday Transcendence evil evolution Facebook Jesus faith Faith and Politics Faith and Politics Faith and Politics Faith and Politics Faith and Politics Faith and Politics Faith and Politics faith and reason family Feminism foreign affairs Franklin Graham Future of Evangelicalism Galen D. gay marriage George W. Bush Guest Posts Guns Gymnastics Harold Camping Heaven Hell Holidays Hollywood Homosexuality iam2.org Illegal Immigration immigration Immigration Reform Injustice Inspiration Interviews Islam Jeremy Lin Jesus jesus christ John Mark Reynolds Johnnie Moore Judgment Day Just War Theory Killing Osama Link of the Day Lists of the Week Mark Goldblatt Marriage Military Missions Mitt Romney Modern Western Thought Monastic wisdom Mormonism Morning Hash Morning Report Motherhood Movies Obamacare Old Testament Orphan Care Palin Parenting Pastoral Resources Patheos Peace Between Religions PEPFAR Persecution Peter Wehner Peter Wehner Philosophy Political Quotes of the Day politics Politics and Economics Pornography Prejudice Prisoner Rape Question of the Week Race Radical Faith Rapture Ravi Zacharias Rick Santorum Russia Salvation Sarah Palin Scandals Science Science and Faith Separation of Church and State Series sex sex slavery social justice Social Justice Ministry Spiritual Disciplines sports Steven Tyler Suffering Suicide Sunday Funnies T. Dalrymple Tea Party Technology terrorism The Christian Media Files The Daily Trinity The Electorate The Ethics of Rhetoric The Future of Seminary Education The Middle East The Obama Presidency theological Theological Renewal Theology Uncategorized Understanding Evangelicalism Vocation war War and Peace With Distinction Word to the Wise Writers

Select a Month October 2015 June 2015 May 2015 March 2015 December 2014 September 2014 August 2014 July 2014 June 2014 May 2014 April 2014 March 2014 February 2014 January 2014 December 2013 November 2013 October 2013 September 2013 August 2013 July 2013 June 2013 May 2013 April 2013 March 2013 February 2013 January 2013 December 2012 November 2012 October 2012 September 2012 August 2012 July 2012 June 2012 May 2012 April 2012 March 2012 February 2012 January 2012 December 2011 November 2011 October 2011 September 2011 August 2011 July 2011 June 2011 May 2011 April 2011 March 2011 February 2011 January 2011 December 2010 November 2010 October 2010 September 2010 August 2010 July 2010 June 2010 May 2010 April 2010 March 2010 October 2009 September 2009 August 2009 July 2009 June 2009

TAKE THE

Religious Wisdom Quiz