God Doesn't Give Us What We Deserve – So Should We Be Glad bin Laden "Got What He Deserved"?

Last updated on: May 9, 2011 at 12:04 pm by Timothy Dalrymple

God Doesn't Give Us What We Deserve – So Should We Be Glad bin Laden "Got What He Deserved"? 2011-05-09T12:04:19-04:00 Timothy Dalrymple

LOGO Patheos Explore the world's faith through different perspectives on religion and spirituality! Patheos has the views of the prevalent religions and spiritualities of the world.

Last week I began a series of three posts responding to the death of Osama bin Laden — and to the discomfort many felt at the way in which that death was celebrated by Americans, including many American Christians. The first post considered the claim, “The people celebrating the death of bin Laden are like the people who celebrated in the ‘Angry Arab Street’ when the towers fell on 9/11.” The second post asked “What ought we to celebrate, and what ought we not to celebrate, about bin Laden’s death?” This third post responds to what some other folks were saying: “We shouldn’t celebrate that Osama bin Laden ‘got what he deserves,’ because God doesn’t give us what we deserve.”

It’s difficult to know where to start with this.

FIRST, at least according to traditional Christian theologies, God does give what is deserved to people who do not repent and take refuge in grace. To those who refuse the love and the grace of their Creator, God gives them over to death and to an eternity apart from him. In fact, there is a very real sense in which God gives what is deserved even to those who take refuge in him. The righteousness of Christ is graciously imputed to them, so that (through the work of Christ, not through their own work) they actually deserve the favor of God and the inheritance of God’s children.

SECOND, even if we grant that God gives out mercy and not justice — that is, that God does not give people what they deserve — does it follow that we should not? Should we not give people what they deserve? What about the oppressed, who deserve justice in a different sense? What about those who are wronged, who deserve restitution? What about the poor, who deserve care? What exactly is being suggested here? Are we only supposed to give what is deserved when a person deserves good things, and not when a person deserves bad things? So, were we not supposed to give bin Laden the worst of punishments?

One might object by pointing to the Parable of the Unforgiving Servant, in which a king forgives a servant but revokes that forgiveness when he discovers that the servant did not extend the same forgiveness to a person in need. So, should we have forgiven Osama bin Laden? Radically enough, if bin Laden had repented and sought our forgiveness, then yes, we should have forgiven him. But (a) there’s no evidence that Osama bin Laden repented, (b) forgiveness does not mean that there are no consequences, in the same way that a parent might forgive a child and yet discipline the child for disobedience, and (c) while it’s clear that God calls for individuals to forgive one another, and while God clearly calls for rulers to be merciful, God does not ask the state to forgive a horrendous lawbreaker to the point of never bringing justice upon him. We should always be careful when we assume that God would require the same thing of the state as he requires of the individual. The state, for instance, is not called to “turn the other cheek” when attacked. Any state that did so would not last for long, as it would ill serve its citizens and would be exploited by others.

THIRD, there’s a difference between eternal and temporal justice. Since God is ultimately the one who is wronged by sin, he is fully within his rights to grant forgiveness and to spare us from the fate we deserve. And individuals may choose to give mercy to those who wronged them, and not to demand justice. The state, however, is charged by God to defend its citizens and authorized to carry out justice on their behalf. In this case, if the state had failed to bring death to bin Laden then it would have failed in its obligations to its citizens, and especially in its obligations to those who lost loved ones on 9/11.

FOURTH and finally, and here we enter deeper theological waters, we can trust God to make the right decisions in what God “gives” (justice or mercy) to people, in this life or the next, because God (a) knows the hearts of all people and (b) foreknows what the effects if his justice or mercy will be. God’s intent is that all should be saved, and God knows precisely when to give mercy and when to give a person over to what he deserves. The state is not in such a position. The state must act on the basis of what it knows, but the state is not omniscient, so it must act according to principles of justice. Just as the state cannot say, “I’m not going to give justice (restitution — let’s say a financial compensation) to this person who has been wronged, because I know that this reward will make the person arrogant, or the person will use the money to buy alcohol,” so the state cannot say “I’m not going to give justice (punishment) to this person who did wrong, because I know that if I give him mercy it will lead to a change of heart and he will become a better man.” To be sure, individuals can do so, and justices are given some space for discernment and can exercise that discernment to a limited extent on the basis of what they do know, but the state writ large has to operate according to certain principles of justice.

Whether any person deserves death is another question for another time. But I don’t find much weight to this argument that we should not celebrate that Osama received what he deserved, when we have received grace instead.

Killing Osama

Uncategorized

Previous Post

May 6, 2011

Tiger Moms and Black Swans

Next Post

May 12, 2011 The Trapeze Swinger from Iron and Wine: Everyday Transcendence #1

Browse Our Archives

Select a Category Abortion Abortion adoption Africa Aging AIDS America Worship American history Americolatry An Open Letter to a College Freshman animals Apologetics art Atheism Authors Barack Obama Bible Biblical Scholarship Billy Graham Blogging Bono Book Review Books That Change Lives Breakfast Links Bulletin Board Business Children Christian Approach to Politics Christian Media Christian Right Derangement Syndrome Christianity and Homosexuality Christians in Government Christmas Chuck Colson CLS v Martinez Comic Creation Creativity and the Arts Cross Examinations Cross Investigations Daily Fragment Daily Trinity Death debt Deep Thoughts on Fatherhood depression economy education Election 2012 entertainment Environment Epistemology Erik Campano Euthanasia Evangelicalism Evangelicals and Gays Everyday Transcendence evil evolution Facebook Jesus faith Faith and Politics Faith and Politics Faith and Politics Faith and Politics Faith and Politics Faith and Politics Faith and Politics faith and reason family Feminism foreign affairs Franklin Graham Future of Evangelicalism Galen D. gay marriage George W. Bush Guest Posts Guns Gymnastics Harold Camping Heaven Hell Holidays Hollywood Homosexuality iam2.org Illegal Immigration immigration Immigration Reform Injustice Inspiration Interviews Islam Jeremy Lin Jesus jesus christ John Mark Reynolds Johnnie Moore Judgment Day Just War Theory Killing Osama Link of the Day Lists of the Week Mark Goldblatt Marriage Military Missions Mitt Romney Modern Western Thought Monastic wisdom Mormonism Morning Hash Morning Report Motherhood Movies Obamacare Old Testament Orphan Care Palin Parenting Pastoral Resources Patheos Peace Between Religions PEPFAR Persecution Peter Wehner Peter Wehner Philosophy Political Quotes of the Day politics Politics and Economics Pornography Prejudice Prisoner Rape Question of the Week Race Radical Faith Rapture Ravi Zacharias Rick Santorum Russia Salvation Sarah Palin Scandals Science Science and Faith Separation of Church and State Series sex sex slavery social justice Social Justice Ministry Spiritual Disciplines sports Steven Tyler Suffering Suicide Sunday Funnies T. Dalrymple Tea Party Technology terrorism The Christian Media Files The Daily Trinity The Electorate The Ethics of Rhetoric The Future of Seminary Education The Middle East The Obama Presidency theological Theological Renewal Theology Uncategorized Understanding Evangelicalism Vocation war War and Peace With Distinction Word to the Wise Writers

Select a Month October 2015 June 2015 May 2015 March 2015 December 2014 September 2014 August 2014 July 2014 June 2014 May 2014 April 2014 March 2014 February 2014 January 2014 December 2013 November 2013 October 2013 September 2013 August 2013 July 2013 June 2013 May 2013 April 2013 March 2013 February 2013 January 2013 December 2012 November 2012 October 2012 September 2012 August 2012 July 2012 June 2012 May 2012 April 2012 March 2012 February 2012 January 2012 December 2011 November 2011 October 2011 September 2011 August 2011 July 2011 June 2011 May 2011 April 2011 March 2011 February 2011 January 2011 December 2010 November 2010 October 2010 September 2010 August 2010 July 2010 June 2010 May 2010 April 2010 March 2010 October 2009 September 2009 August 2009 July 2009 June 2009

TAKE THE

Religious Wisdom Quiz