Were those who celebrated bin Laden's death like those who celebrated the 9/11 atrocity?

Last updated on: May 3, 2011 at 10:54 pm by Timothy Dalrymple

Were those who celebrated bin Laden's death like those who celebrated the 9/11 atrocity? 2011-05-03T22:54:25-04:00 Timothy Dalrymple

LOGO Patheos Explore the world's faith through different perspectives on religion and spirituality! Patheos has the views of the prevalent religions and spiritualities of the world.

Imagine that some righteous German, a man very much like Bonhoeffer, had managed to kill Adolf Hitler a few years earlier than he actually died, and thus prevented the death of millions of soldiers and innocents. Would that have been cause for celebration?

I am beginning a periodic series called With Distinction, in which I will make conceptual distinctions that can, I think, help folks navigate issues under debate in the public square right now. Please subscribe if you want to follow along. I want to take up the controversy that has erupted yesterday and today over whether it is wrong to celebrate the death of Osama bin Laden. No sooner had the news spread that Osama bin Laden had been killed in Abbottobad, Pakistan — or, really, no sooner had a bunch of hollering young people gathered outside the White House and Ground Zero and Harvard Yard (and doubtless many more places besides) to celebrate — than we began to hear a religious-political parallel to the NFL’s “Excessive Celebration” rule. See Kevin Eckstrom at the Religious News Service for background.

Celebration in Harvard Yard

The debate does not break down neatly on partisan lines. Many of the young folks in DC and New York City and Cambridge, as one might expect, were of the liberal persuasion. Some held pro-Obama posters. Those who condemned the celebrations were both (a) liberals and (b) Christians, including some conservative Christians like Joe Carter at First Things. Many (though not Joe) likened these celebrations to the celebrations one could see in Tehran or Palestine when the towers fell on 9/11.

In this first installment, I want to respond to an equivalency I’ve heard a handful of times today:

“The celebrations over the death of bin Laden were just like when terrorist sympathizers celebrated the 9/11 atrocity.”

Although this may sound like the attitude of a sophisticated world citizen, it is actually moral obtuseness on a staggering scale. Let’s set forth some of the more important distinctions:

To celebrate 9/11 is to celebrate the wanton mass-murder of nearly 3000 innocent men, women and children. To celebrate 5/2 is to celebrate the death of a single individual, and precisely the individual who was most responsible for the wanton mass-murder of nearly 3000 innocent men, women and children. There is a world of a difference between celebrating an atrocity and celebrating the death of the person who committed the atrocity. Some will say: You think it was just to kill bin Laden, but bin Laden thought it was just to kill 3000 Americans. To which we must respond: That may be so, but bin Laden was absolutely wrong in that belief. What bin Laden believed does not particularly matter; what he did was objectively and horrifically wrong.
The 5/2 killing was authorized by an authority that is democratically elected and ordained by God to bear the sword of law and justice. The 9/11 atrocity was carried out by a band of mad zealots who took upon themselves the right to determine the fate of 3000 ordinary citizens.
The 9/11 killing was calculated to kill as many citizens as possible, whereas the 5/2 mission aimed (at the cost of considerably more risk for the American soldiers) to minimize collateral damage.
Osama bin Laden could have surrendered in the midst of this operation, or at any time since 9/11, and gone before a court, or at least a military commission. He determined his own fate. I understand that bin Laden may not have been armed when he was shot; we are still learning the details. But on many occasions after 9/11 he could have given up the fight and surrendered. By contrast, the victims of the 9/11 attack were unarmed, they were not combatants, and they had no opportunity to appeal for justice.
9/11 was an attack upon a state and the opening of war. It was an attempt to destroy a nation, perhaps a civilization, and it was clear that many deaths of soldiers and citizens would follow. 5/2 removed a threat to peaceful civilizations, and over the long term it likely means fewer deaths for soldiers and civilians. 9/11 made the world more dangerous; 5/2 made the world safer. Some acts of violence are actually creative. It is unfortunate but true that taking the life of a person like Osama bin Laden actually makes the world a better place.

Unless we are going to abandon entirely our ability to make moral distinctions, or just to affirm the moral values that are affirmed in scripture, then we must be able to assert that killing 3000 innocent men, women and children is wrong and is the deepest possible perversion of justice. It is not a matter of perspective. To be clear, I have not yet said that celebrating bin Laden’s death was right. It’s more complex than that. But celebrating the 9/11 attacks, and celebrating the death of the individual most responsible for those attacks, are not remotely identical.

In the second installment, tomorrow, I’ll address another parallel that’s being suggested: “People keep saying that Osama got what he deserved. But God didn’t give us what we deserve, did he?” In the third installment, also tomorrow, I’ll ask the overarching question: Is it wrong to celebrate bin Laden’s death? Or what is permissible to celebrate here, and what is wrong to celebrate? Please subscribe to read the rest. I intend to ramp up the blog and I hope you’ll come along for the ride.

Americolatry

Death

Peace Between Religions

Uncategorized

With Distinction

Previous Post

April 29, 2011

Royal Wedding Theology

Next Post

May 4, 2011 Now It's Getting Ugly: Was Obama Essentially Sidelined on the Osama bin Laden Raid? - UPDATED

Browse Our Archives

Select a Category Abortion Abortion adoption Africa Aging AIDS America Worship American history Americolatry An Open Letter to a College Freshman animals Apologetics art Atheism Authors Barack Obama Bible Biblical Scholarship Billy Graham Blogging Bono Book Review Books That Change Lives Breakfast Links Bulletin Board Business Children Christian Approach to Politics Christian Media Christian Right Derangement Syndrome Christianity and Homosexuality Christians in Government Christmas Chuck Colson CLS v Martinez Comic Creation Creativity and the Arts Cross Examinations Cross Investigations Daily Fragment Daily Trinity Death debt Deep Thoughts on Fatherhood depression economy education Election 2012 entertainment Environment Epistemology Erik Campano Euthanasia Evangelicalism Evangelicals and Gays Everyday Transcendence evil evolution Facebook Jesus faith Faith and Politics Faith and Politics Faith and Politics Faith and Politics Faith and Politics Faith and Politics Faith and Politics faith and reason family Feminism foreign affairs Franklin Graham Future of Evangelicalism Galen D. gay marriage George W. Bush Guest Posts Guns Gymnastics Harold Camping Heaven Hell Holidays Hollywood Homosexuality iam2.org Illegal Immigration immigration Immigration Reform Injustice Inspiration Interviews Islam Jeremy Lin Jesus jesus christ John Mark Reynolds Johnnie Moore Judgment Day Just War Theory Killing Osama Link of the Day Lists of the Week Mark Goldblatt Marriage Military Missions Mitt Romney Modern Western Thought Monastic wisdom Mormonism Morning Hash Morning Report Motherhood Movies Obamacare Old Testament Orphan Care Palin Parenting Pastoral Resources Patheos Peace Between Religions PEPFAR Persecution Peter Wehner Peter Wehner Philosophy Political Quotes of the Day politics Politics and Economics Pornography Prejudice Prisoner Rape Question of the Week Race Radical Faith Rapture Ravi Zacharias Rick Santorum Russia Salvation Sarah Palin Scandals Science Science and Faith Separation of Church and State Series sex sex slavery social justice Social Justice Ministry Spiritual Disciplines sports Steven Tyler Suffering Suicide Sunday Funnies T. Dalrymple Tea Party Technology terrorism The Christian Media Files The Daily Trinity The Electorate The Ethics of Rhetoric The Future of Seminary Education The Middle East The Obama Presidency theological Theological Renewal Theology Uncategorized Understanding Evangelicalism Vocation war War and Peace With Distinction Word to the Wise Writers

Select a Month October 2015 June 2015 May 2015 March 2015 December 2014 September 2014 August 2014 July 2014 June 2014 May 2014 April 2014 March 2014 February 2014 January 2014 December 2013 November 2013 October 2013 September 2013 August 2013 July 2013 June 2013 May 2013 April 2013 March 2013 February 2013 January 2013 December 2012 November 2012 October 2012 September 2012 August 2012 July 2012 June 2012 May 2012 April 2012 March 2012 February 2012 January 2012 December 2011 November 2011 October 2011 September 2011 August 2011 July 2011 June 2011 May 2011 April 2011 March 2011 February 2011 January 2011 December 2010 November 2010 October 2010 September 2010 August 2010 July 2010 June 2010 May 2010 April 2010 March 2010 October 2009 September 2009 August 2009 July 2009 June 2009

TAKE THE

Religious Wisdom Quiz