BuddhistCatholicContemplativeEvangelicalGeneral ChristianHinduJewishLatter-day SaintMuslimNew VisionsProgressive Christian
Beliefs
- Buddhist
- Catholic
- Contemplative
- Evangelical
- General Christian
- Hindu
- Jewish
- Latter-day Saint
- More Voices
- Muslim
- New Visions
- Pagan
- Progressive Christian
Topics
- Religion News
- Food and Religion
- Sports and Religion
- Religious Art
- Religious Music and Entertainment
- Religious Events
- History and Religion
- Style and Religion
- Politics and Religion
- Women in Religion
- Recreation Outdoors and Religion
- Business Finance and Religion
- Careers Workplace and Religion
- Education and Religion
- Family Parenting and Religion
- Health Fitness and Religion
- Home and Religion
- Relationships and Religion
- Technology and Religion
- Travel and Religion
Columnists
- Buddhist Columnists
- Business Finance and Religion Columnists
- Careers Workplace and Religion Columnists
- Catholic Columnists
- Contemplative Columnists
- Education and Religion Columnists
- Evangelists Columnists
- Family Parenting and Religion Columnists
- General Christian Columnists
- Health Fitness and Religion Columnists
- Hindu Columnists
- History and Religion Columnists
- Home and Religion Columnists
- Jewish Columnists
- More Voices Columnists
- Latter Day Columnists
- Muslim Columnists
- New Visions Columnists
- Nonreligious Columnists
- Pagan Columnists
- Politics and Religion Columnists
- Progressive Columnists
- Recreation Outdoors and Religion Columnists
- Relationships and Religion Columnists
- Religion News Columnists
- Religious Art Columnists
- Religious Events Columnists
- Religious Music and Entertainment Columnists
- Sports and Religion Columnists
- Style and Religion Columnists
- Technology and Religion Columnists
- Travel and Religion Columnists
- Women in Religion Columnists
Resource Library
- 2026 Calendar
- Library of World Religions
- The 100 Most Holy Places on Earth
- Patheos Answers
- Podcasts
- Videos
- Faith Leaders Database
- Anglican Episcopalian
- Bahai
- Baptist
- Buddhism
- Christianity
- Confucianism
- Eastern Orthodoxy
- Hinduism
- Holiness and Pentecostal
- ISKCON
- Islam
- Judaism
- Lutheran
- Methodist
- The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints
- New Age
- Paganism
- Presbytarian and Reformed
- Protestantism
- Religion Behind the Scenes
- Roman Catholic
- Scientology
- Shia Islam
- Sikhism
- Sufism
- Sunni Islam
- Taoism
- Zen
- See all religions
Research Tools
Ad-Free & Subscriber Log-In Subscription Support
Ad-Free & Subscriber Log-In Subscription Support
- Trending:
- Forgiveness
- |
- Marriage
- |
- Consciousness
- |
- Death Penalty
- |
- Election
- |
- Halloween
Messy Inspirations
- Home
- Catholic
- Historical or True?—Jesus Birth Stories
Historical or True?—Jesus Birth Stories
Last updated on: December 6, 2019 at 10:44 am by Fellow Dying Inmate
Historical or True?—Jesus Birth Stories 2019-12-06T10:44:04-04:00 Fellow Dying Inmate
Patheos Explore the world's faith through different perspectives on religion and spirituality! Patheos has the views of the prevalent religions and spiritualities of the world.

Photo by Greyson Joralemon on Unsplash
Historical or truthful?—there are reasons for thinking that the biblical stories of Jesus’ birth are not historical in many details.
Historical? Or true? Aren’t they one and the same? Alas, 21st century Americans have a hard time making distinctions between truth and facts. We are so science-obsessed, so fact-precise, we mistake truth and facts constantly. The West is the only culture that cannot distinguish truth and facts.
All facts are true but not all truths are facts. Thus truth is not reducible to historical truth. As far as the “historical” goes, not all cultures tell “history” with obsession for “just the facts” as we Americans do. Our Bible is Mediterranean, not American. Therefore the Scriptures are all true and some of it actually happened. That applies just as much for the Gospels and their Infancy Narratives.
What Are You Saying??
I can anticipate what many reading this are thinking. Wait! Are you saying that the stories of Jesus’ birth found in “Matthew” and “Luke” are not historical?
Well maybe in addition to being true they also present some historical truth. But if that is so, in what way and to what extent are they historical?
It is reasonable to consider that these two stories, from whence the core of our Christmas traditions come, are historical in some way. But we American Christians should be cautious here. Even in the way they present some historical truth, that does not mean the Infancy Narratives are historical in how 21st century Americans think and do “history.”
The way a scholar like Raymond E. Brown would phrase the issue is that there are reasons for thinking that the birth stories, which are found in the first two chapters of “Matthew” and the first two chapters of “Luke,” are not historical in many details.
Two facts should be kept in mind in relation to that judgment.
Fundamentalistic Obsessions
First, a growing number of Catholics assume that questioning the historicity of the birth narratives means questioning official Church Teaching. The claim is made by Catholic fundamentalists that the ancient and traditional Teaching of the Church was that the Scriptures were dictated by God and therefore completely inerrant. Many wrongly think that the Church from 33 AD onward believed that unless they obviously present metaphors, biblical passages must be interpreted as reporting something literally factual or historical. Hence, Matthew 1—2 and Luke 1—2 present narratives of historical facts.
That is not true—there is no official church statement in force that the birth narratives are literally historical. Fundamentalism, Catholic or otherwise, is recent—it is a reaction to modernity. Christian fundamentalism wasn’t born until the early 20th century United States, mothered by late 19th century American Protestant reactions to Charles Darwin and higher criticism of the Scriptures. Biblical literalism is older, having roots mainly in the third generation of the Reformers who stressed plenary inspiration. Consequently, Biblical literalism is just three centuries old. Think about that.
Concerning Catholic Teaching and the historicity of the Gospels, the Pontifical Biblical Commission explains matters in their 1964 document, “The Historical Truth of the Gospels.” Fascinating insights are presented there. But that document very clearly deals only with what the disciples heard and saw of Jesus during his public ministry.
Sometime after, an attempt was mounted to have the Commission issue a statement on the historicity of the birth narratives. This was abandoned in the late 1960s. Why? Raymond E. Brown explained that it was probably because any such statement would have been overly complicated and nuanced.
No Apostolic Witness
Brown gives a second fact for regarding Matthew 1—2 and Luke 1—2 as unhistorical in many details. To get to it, Brown asks why do we possess a tradition about what Jesus did and said in the first place? Isn’t it because people who had accompanied Jesus were capable of reporting his deeds and sayings? We are talking, of course, about the Twelve and the other followers who made up the Jesus Movement in the late 20s, first century CE.
But were any of those people present at Jesus’ birth? No way. Therefore Brown says that we cannot claim that we have apostolic witness to the events surrounding Jesus’ birth. Matthew 1—2 and Luke 1—2 being inspired does not change that, folks.
Journey through Christmas
Beginning today, and every day throughout December and into the New Year, this blog, Messy Inspirations, is going to journey with you through Advent and Christmas. We will be presenting a serious look at the Infancy Narratives of Matthew 1—2 and Luke 1—2.
An invitation: familiarize yourselves with these separate and very different stories. Let’s set our Rosaries down, turn off our favorite Christmas-time Jesus-movies, and read each narrative by itself. We should keep a notepad and pen handy and jot down details particular to each. We might just be surprised what we find!
Previous Post

November 30, 2019
Knowing Jesus
Next Post

December 3, 2019 Magisterial Documents and Jesus’ Birth
Browse Our Archives
Select a Category Uncategorized
Select a Month August 2021 July 2021 June 2021 May 2021 April 2021 March 2021 February 2021 January 2021 December 2020 November 2020 October 2020 September 2020 August 2020 July 2020 June 2020 May 2020 April 2020 March 2020 February 2020 January 2020 December 2019 November 2019 October 2019 September 2019 August 2019
Follow Us!
TAKE THE
Religious Wisdom Quiz
Where was Jesus' first miracle performed?
Select your answer to see how you score.
Jerusalem Cana Nazareth Capernaum
Support this
Column

Related posts from Messy Inspirations
Understanding Apocalypse & Its Creatures
TRENDING AT PATHEOS Catholic
“If you love me, you will keep my commandments” (Jn. 14:15 RSV)....
Children, Refugees, And The Politics of Cruelty
Actions speak louder than words. That's why I take Trump’s elevation of...
A Catholic Critique of Biblical Unitarianism
If the statistics are to be believed, Unitarianism is rising worldwide. Although...
Is Catholicism The Fulfillment Of The Old Testament?
Catholicism makes sense only when wedded to the Old Testament. Put differently,...
How Grandma Tourism Helps Grandparents Live Their Vocation
Grandma, The New Travel Influencer What started as a nostalgia-inspired social media...
Hope for the World: Thoughts on ‘Credo: A...
This essay begins a series of meditations on “Credo: A Story of...
view all Catholic blogs
Ad-Free & Subscriber Log-In Subscription Support
- About Us
- 2026 Calendar
- Videos
- Podcasts
- Library of World Religions
- Faith In Media Tracker
- Advertise With Us
- Write for Us
- Privacy Policy
- Terms of Service
- Do Not Sell My Data
- Contact Us
- Radiant Digital
- Manage Newsletter Subscriptions
- Unsubscribe From Notifications
- Sitemap
Copyright 2008-2026, Patheos. All rights reserved.
Subscription Support Ad-Free & Subscriber Log-In











