Buddhist Catholic Contemplative Evangelical General Christian Hindu Jewish Latter-day Saint Muslim New Visions Progressive Christian

Beliefs

Topics

Columnists

Resource Library

Research Tools

Video

Podcasts

Thought Readers

Faith In Media Tracker

Newsletters

Ad-Free & Subscriber Log-In Subscription Support

Follow Patheos

Home
Catholic
The Story of a Journey of Much More than Souls

The Story of a Journey of Much More than Souls

Last updated on: August 10, 2019 at 8:35 pm by Jack Hartjes

The Story of a Journey of Much More than Souls 2019-08-10T20:35:59-06:00 Jack Hartjes

LOGO Patheos Explore the world's faith through different perspectives on religion and spirituality! Patheos has the views of the prevalent religions and spiritualities of the world.

On Souls, Reincarnation, and Journey of Souls, Part 3

Hands holding a globe of the precious earth.

The earth is more than a place souls inhabit for a while on their way to a higher plane.

Christianity tells the story of a journey. So does Michael Newton in books like Journey of Souls, where he presents what he learns about souls from clients under hypnosis. The Christian story is a good one. I’ll explain in Part One what I mean by that and how the Journey of Souls story doesn’t measure up.

The Christian journey is through Earth’s time and space. This is a setting with its own journey and intrinsic value. Part Two will witness to my love for planet Earth, a love that I find wanting in Newton’s story. There we see a multitude of planets where souls live, but only one journey matters. That’s the souls’ journey. Planets have instrumental value only, and only until souls no longer need them.

There is, finally, the journey of God, or, the Source as Newton’s clients’ souls name it. And that raises the question, Do we even like this Source? Would we worship It? What’s the big deal about worship, anyway? That’s for Part Three.

Part One: Stories

A good story is as serious as life.

Good stories can be happy or sad, comic or tragic. They all are dead serious about one thing – the present moment. This moment matters, it has weight, it’s a tiny part but it makes a difference to the whole. Occasionally there is a special moment, a Kairos in Greek, a critical time on which everything depends. Jesus named such a moment:

This is the time of fulfillment. The Kingdom of God is at hand. Repent and believe in the gospel. (Mark 1:15)

I imagine God, in the story that Genesis tells, discovering that a Methuselah-like lifespan is not the best thing for humans. God does us a favor by limiting our days. They

shall comprise one hundred and twenty years. (Genesis 6:3)

If our days went on for hundreds and hundreds of years, it would be hard to make a good story of them. Each year, to say nothing of each day or each moment, would count so little toward the story’s resolution. To say nothing of heirs wondering when they were ever going to get an inheritance.

God has blessedly provided us with a number of limits. In God’s story we are fragments. To ask for more than that, to expect wholeness, getting all the loose ends securely tied, is to ask for curses, not blessings.

The careless soul’s witness

The problem of way too much time on one’s hands comes across clearly in the testimony that makes up “Case 21,” on Newton’s list of clients. This person is a bit of a goof-off, as are most of the souls in his learning group. A couple more dedicated members of the group have moved on and another will probably move on soon, this soul relates. Then he asserts confidently, “We will eventually catch up to them … but not for a while.”

This careless soul states what all the testimonies assume: We’ll all get to where we need to be “eventually.” The idea of a critical moment, a Kairos, where a decision makes all the difference, has no place in this long-term faith. There will always be more moments, but there will never be a really serious one. It’s a lousy story.

Good stories have evil and good, and surprising turns.

From people who toy with the idea of multiple lives, you hear a lot of talk about karma. Karma is the unbending rule about consequences of our actions. Souls in Newton’s research are familiar with karma. Good behavior always earns its reward, even if only in another life. Similarly, you pay for every mistake. Karma doesn’t forget either the good or the bad. Not that souls are ever really bad. In the classroom of the between-lives existence of souls, everyone is very understanding. You made some mistakes; that’s all. You get another chance.

In comparison to the Christian story, this one falls really flat. The Christian story doesn’t let us forget, or smooth over with excuses and explanations, one completely obvious thing: evil is real. Christians have interesting myths about evil that don’t really explain anything but do keep the reality before our minds. And the reality is simply this: The evil in which we more or less voluntarily participate is bigger than our individual selves.

There’s another thing that Jesus won’t let us forget – forgiveness. Against all odds and against all karma, we do forgive each other, even if we have trouble saying the words. And to the same extent we have authorization to hope for God’s forgiveness. In the parable of the Prodigal Son and Prodigal Father, Jesus tells us that God isn’t interested in karma.

Forgiveness is the great surprise of the Christian story. It dissolves the laws of cause and effect, action and reaction. Something happens that wasn’t in the cards. History finds a path open where there was no path before. God says, “Behold, I am doing something new.” (Isaiah 43:19)

In Journey of Souls there is no stepping outside the laws of karma. Nobody begs forgiveness from God or anybody else, and nobody offers it. Everybody pays their debts eventually. Everybody works out their own entirely predictable salvation in their own time. Very dull!

We are thrown into our stories; thank God for that!

Existentialism gives us an image that captures the drama – the terror and the beauty – of life perfectly. We are thrown into existence; nobody chooses where he or she lands. We spend most of our lives trying to control things, but in the most fundamental ways we are not in control. This is another blessing.

In the accounts of Newton’s clients, souls get to choose the conditions of their reincarnations. Apparently, they make wise choices, usually, according to whatever they need to learn next or make up for. But there’s a surreal quality to it. It’s a nice idea, but nothing in my life prepares me to accept it could possibly be true. Very much convinces me it should not be true..

People by the millions and billions are born into poverty, famine, war, and other kinds of violence. They are born already addicted to drugs or subject to discrimination because of their color, ethnicity, or sex. Is that their choice? Or is it just plain evil? Am I supposed to think that my own “development” as a soul warrants my comfortable situation? Or that less fortunate souls are getting exactly what they need, or deserve, or chose?

Part Two: A place called Earth

Me and “my” body

There’s a lot of morality in the story that Newton and his clients tell. Way too much! Souls are forever (if that’s not too strong a word) trying to improve morally. Their lives between incarnations are learning experiences. Their classroom moves to a planet when they incarnate, and there they also show how well they have been paying attention. Souls aim to be more responsible, more loving, more good-for-something. They can stop to smell the roses on earth or to goof around in the spirit world. But that’s just a pause, a delay, in their real purpose. Eventually they’ll get back on track.

That track leads to abandoning material existence. A higher level soul already is at the point where it incarnates less often. At some point it stops incarnating. Its multiple bodies and the material world are no longer of any use to it. It has learned all it can from these merely material things. Sometime after this they unite with what souls call the Source.

Of all the things that Journey of Souls tried to teach me, this one disturbs me the most. Partly that’s because I’m fond of my own body. It can be frustrating and rebellious at times, but there’s a kind of closeness that never fades. This body is more than a possession that I happen to have. It expresses me and my relationships to others and to the world. And those relationships are the place where I begin to be a person.

The good earth

Besides my body, there’s the earth that I love. In the biblical story the material world is good—not morally good, not good for something, just good. This place is not a test or a mere tool for our advancement. Certainly not a place for us to use any we might want. It can be a valley of tears, but it’s also home. God certainly meant it that way.

Earth is God’s good creation. By contrast the so-called Source doesn’t create material things, leaving that job to higher level souls. By the way, that’s an idea that is suspiciously very close to what the ancient Greek philosopher Plotinus taught. The Source, or Plotinus’s One, is too high and mighty to be directly involved with anything as low as matter. That’s for souls to deal with until they advance beyond all that material stuff.

Part of the reason I love Christianity is that it never abandons the earth. We don’t, at least if we’re true to the Bible, imagine some far-off heaven for souls and God. We believe our bodies will be resurrected, glorified, gloriously different, but these same bodies. And Earth will be renewed—this same creation that is now “groaning in labor pains.” (Romans 8:22)

Part Three: Worship

A God who loves

I raised the question early on whether this Source and Newton’s hypnotized clients speak of is something a person would even like, much less worship. For most of Newton’s book, the Source seems to be a reality about which very little is known except that it seems to be all wrapped up in itself. It doesn’t get involved with matter at all. And it also shows no interest in the journeys that the various souls are undertaking.

The Source is on its own journey, and it needs souls to help it along, just as souls need matter to complete their journeys. I suppose it’s a good feeling to know that one is so important to the ultimate reality. But I might think that I was being used.

One of the really mysterious doctrines of Christianity is that God didn’t need to create the world. God was perfectly happy in a dynamic union of Father, Son, and Spirit and might not ever have made a world. Creation is God’s free act, and only because it was free could it be an act of love.

To worship God

Creation’s value derives from God’s love, not from what creation can do for God. Since we start out good, all of our strivings, our efforts at self-improvement, though important, are secondary. The first act of any creature is simply to be what God made it. In the natural world, that is worship. In the human world, where creation has become self-aware, that worship is thanksgiving. By this free act, serving no human purpose, we imitate the divine freedom of the creation.

It never occurs to any of the souls we hear about in Journey of Souls to worship anything. I don’t recall any of these souls, speaking through the hypnosis of their hosts, expressing thankfulness for anything. Perhaps that’s just an oversight, and maybe Newton, the hypnotist, didn’t ever ask, “What are you thankful for.” But maybe, as I suppose, thankfulness doesn’t fit well with a regimen of self-improvement.

Conclusion

I believe that all cases of memories of past lives and past experiences between lives have natural, and not paranormal, explanations. I do not have familiarity with this sort of paranormal research to justify this belief. What I have tried to do instead is indicate some reasons why reincarnation is contrary to Christian belief and common human experience.

It doesn’t fit with the Christian belief in the resurrection of the body or the importance of the one unique, particular, unrepeatable life of Jesus of Nazareth in the flesh. If reincarnation were correct and compatible with Christianity, depicting the crucified body of Jesus in images and on crosses wouldn’t make any sense. We should be receiving “the soul of Christ,” but not “the body of Christ” in Communion. The Body of Christ wouldn’t be an appropriate image for the Church. Abortion wouldn’t be nearly so bad, and neither would starving children and rape.

But with these last examples I’m getting into common, not specifically Christian, experience. We are just naturally concerned and angry about unjust suffering of human beings (and animals) because bodies are more than just shells or instruments for souls. We care for the earth because the material world is more than a temporary stage for souls on their way to a higher plane. And we know in some way, even though it’s contrary to the American religion of optimism and progress, that we are simultaneously sinners and loved as we are.

For some of us that last knowledge leads to some convictions about salvation, namely, that it comes as a free gift, that we haven’t earned it, and so we fall on our knees in grateful worship and rise to pass on the love that has filled us.

Image credit: University of Canterbury via Google Images

Reincarnation

Souls

Previous Post

August 2, 2019

Real Presence, or When is Jesus’ Presence Ever Not Real?

Next Post

August 9, 2019 Hiroshima and Nagasaki: Lamentation, Repentance, and Amendment

Browse Our Archives

Select a Category Advent Christmas Amazon Synod Angels Being Consumed Bible Catholic Modern Creed Ecology Economics Elizabeth Johnson Eucharist Fragments and Filaments Gender and Sex Gospel of Mark Herzog Historical Jesus Liturgy Luke Opening Scriptures on Way to Emmaus Ordinary radicals Parables Pro-Life Reincarnation Rosary Sacraments science Social Justice Souls Stories of Jesus The Creed Torture and Eucharist Tracy Uncategorized War and Peace

Select a Month October 2026 June 2025 April 2025 March 2025 February 2025 January 2025 November 2024 July 2024 March 2024 December 2023 October 2023 September 2023 August 2023 May 2023 April 2023 March 2023 February 2023 January 2023 December 2022 November 2022 October 2022 September 2022 August 2022 July 2022 June 2022 April 2022 March 2022 February 2022 January 2022 December 2021 November 2021 October 2021 August 2021 July 2021 June 2021 April 2021 March 2021 February 2021 December 2020 November 2020 October 2020 August 2020 July 2020 June 2020 May 2020 April 2020 March 2020 February 2020 January 2020 December 2019 November 2019 October 2019 September 2019 August 2019 July 2019 June 2019 May 2019 April 2019 March 2019 February 2019 January 2019 December 2018 November 2018 October 2018 September 2018 August 2018 July 2018 June 2018 May 2018

TAKE THE

Religious Wisdom Quiz