Faithful Challenge – Lectionary Commentary – October 5, 2025

Last updated on: September 28, 2025 at 6:35 pm by Bruce Epperly

0 Comments

Faithful Challenge – Lectionary Commentary – October 5, 2025 2025-09-28T18:35:46-04:00 Bruce Epperly

LOGO Patheos Explore the world's faith through different perspectives on religion and spirituality! Patheos has the views of the prevalent religions and spiritualities of the world.

The Adventurous Lectionary – Seventeenth Sunday after Pentecost – October 5, 2025 Lamentations 1:1-6, Lamentations 3:19-26, Psalm 137, 2 Timothy 1:1-14, Luke 17:5-10

In these troubled times in which the future seems uncertain and the norms we’ve lived by are being undermined by our nation’s leaders, we need to look beyond the present crisis to the deeper realities that undergird the historical process. Our help in ages past is our hope in years to come.

At the heart of this Sunday’s readings is the affirmation from Lamentations 3: “God’s mercies never come to an end; they are new every morning; great is God’s faithfulness.” According to the unknown author of Lamentations, God is faithful despite life’s challenges and the uncertainty of the nation’s future. While today, many people want experiential religion and instant mysticism through micro doses of psychedelics and other spiritual technologies – and this can be life-changing – experiential religion emerges from and needs to be balanced by a vision of divine faithfulness to get us through rough times. Spirituality and theology require one another in a whole person faith. The ground of spiritual experience is an ever-present, faithful, and creative God who is present in every moment of life. Theo-spirituality, the interplay of mysticism and intellectual reflection, gives us courage to face today’s challenge and insight to become change agents in the world.

In a challenging time, a time of upheaval, when the city has become a wasteland and the future of the nation is in doubt, the author of Lamentations 3 remembers God’s ever-present creativity. In the scripture that inspired the hymn “Great is Thy Faithfulness,” the author proclaims that despite his difficulties, he has hope: “The steadfast love of the LORD never ceases, God’s mercies never come to an end; they are new every morning; great is your faithfulness.” God is moving through history, globally and intimately, doing new things, creative and life-giving. The moral and spiritual arcs of God lure us forward. God’s faithfulness joins the interplay of steadiness and change. God is always faithful; yet the shape of God’s fidelity varies with our needs. The author assumes God’s intimate knowledge of us, such that God not only does new things globally but also personally as a result of God’s responses to our decisions. In hard times, if we are attentive, “morning by morning new mercies we see…”

The author of Lamentations 3 counsels us to wait on God, to be patient, and to seek God. This is a matter of contemplative prayer. God is present in the long haul as well the moment-by-moment aspects of life. We need to pause and reflect, meditate and visualize possibilities. We need, as Psalm 46 asserts, to be still and know that God is with us. In seeking the divine, we will find traces of divine providence. The moral arc is often slow, the evolution of justice, is often gradual; yet God is faithful. Or, as Jesus says, ask, seek, and knock, and you will receive what you are looking for.

Lamentations 3 proclaims that God has the final word, not the oppressor or the oppressive situation. But we need to pause and listen – perhaps we need to deepen our prayer lives – to fully share in God’s ever-new mercies. (A good background book for the preacher is Renita Weems’ “Listening for God.” For more on process theology, evident in an early form in Lamentations 3, see Epperly, “Process Theology: A Guide for the Perplexed” and “Process Theology: Embracing Adventure with God.”)

Psalm 137 is challenging to preacher and congregation alike. But, if you read it, you have to talk about it, especially its violence. Its high point is the question “how shall we sing God’s song in a strange land?” This is an important question: when everything is turned upside down and our previous experiences of God are found wanting, what shall we do now? This is the question asked by refugees, cancer patients, downsized workers, homeless persons, and bereaved spouses. This is the question congregations are asking in a post-COVID world. Progressives ask this question in the Time of Trump in which we have no place at the table, experiencing the alienation of the intentionally marginalized. We live in a strange land – state sponsored violence against immigrants, glaciers collapsing, presidential hate speech, escalating violence, and Christians defending dishonest leaders and denying climate change. No clear outcome is evident.

The Psalmist’s query ends with thoughts of vengeance and homicide. He wants to wreak vengeance on his enemies and the enemies of his nation. He wants to kill the children – or have God kill the children – of those who have harmed him and threatened his way of life. We are not without our anger – even what we perceive righteous indignation – at false patriotism and cruelty of our leaders. We would love, in our worst moments, to annihilate perpetrators of conspiracy theories, racism, and false facts. Violence against persons protesting ICE and Charlie Kirk are symptoms of the nation’s troubled soul. But, while we cannot act on these impulses, we must admit we have them and confess our own inner turmoil and violence.

Perhaps, we can see this Psalm as an example of bringing everything to God in prayer. We can only hope that the Psalmist was cured of his violence in the course of his praying! Perhaps, he will discover that God even cares for his enemies as did an equally angry biblical character, Jonah. Still, we dare not read this passage in church – in our own time of violence on city streets and bullying in the political realm – without challenging such blood thirsty imprecations. Even as we see God’s presence in those who seek to silence us and those perpetrating injustice, we must recognize our fallibility and ask for God’s peace to descend on us and the nation. (For more on Jonah, see Bruce Epperly, “Jonah: When God Changes,” Energion Publications)

The words of 2 Timothy speak of lived tradition. Timothy’s mother and grandmother have nurtured him in the faith, and now this young man must claim the faith as his own. His faith must be kindled and become fiery, and it also must be based on good theology, or sound teaching. Our faith is grounded in the faith of others, and the graceful interdependence of life. He must now claim his faith.

Christian growth involves, especially in a pluralistic age, experiences of God tied to beliefs about God, what I describe as “theospirituality.” Vision and experience inspire and strengthen one another in the life of faith. To churches today, the counsel of Timothy is to teach Christian practices but also present healthy and life-giving visions of God and God’s work in the world.

The Gospel reading starts well but then slips into some apparently problematic theology. I am tempted to simply read Luke 17:5-6. The plea for God to “increase our faith” touches every believer. When we see our vacillating faith, our half-heartedness, the ease in which we conform to society, we need God’s grace and power to move us forward in greater companionship with God. We need, as 2 Timothy 1:8, asserts to rely on the power of God when our power and confidence – our fortitude – is waning. Like the author of Lamentations, we need to wait hopefully for God’s faithful presence.

Luke 5:7-10 interjects, at first glance, hierarchical, classist, and works righteousness thinking. Yes, we depend on God, but are our efforts simply what we should do, no more, no less, or does God appreciate our attempts and give us credit for our efforts? It is not uncommon for mystics to emphasize their sin and distance from God in hyperbolic ways. Perhaps, this passage is also hyperbole and should not be understood literally. On the one hand, we are not fully responsible for our good works, but live by grace. On the other hand, we are performing these works and putting our efforts toward being the best we can. God is not a demanding parent, but a loving power fully aware of our finitude and struggle. No good and loving parent would be as demanding – or exacting – as God is portrayed in this passage.

This Sunday’s passages require both affirmation and critique. Thoughts of homicide and unworthiness make sense if we trust God’s faithfulness and creative novelty. Only if these passages are understood in terms of a loving, creative, and steadfast God can we read them in ways that heal and not harm. God knows us, and loves us. God is out to heal us and not hurt us. In knowing this, we are liberated from prophetic vengeance and invited to promote strong prophetic healing. Thanks be to God!

++++

+++

Bruce Epperly is Theologian in Residence at Westmoreland Congregational United Church of Christ, Bethesda, MD (https://www.westmorelanducc.org/) and a professor in theology and spirituality at Wesley Theological Seminary. He is the author of over 80 books including: “Homegrown Mystics: Restoring the Soul of Our Nation through the Healing Wisdom of America’s Mystics” (Amazon.com: Homegrown Mystics: Restoring Our Nation with the Healing Wisdom of America’s Visionaries: 9781625249142: Epperly, Bruce: Books) “Jesus: Mystic, Healer, and Prophet “(Jesus: Mystic, Healer, and Prophet: Epperly, Bruce: 9781625248732: Amazon.com: Books Bruce Epperly is Theologian in Residence at Westmoreland Congregational United Church of Christ, Bethesda, MD (https://www.westmorelanducc.org/) and a professor in theology and spirituality at Wesley Theological Seminary. He is the author of over 80 books including: “Homegrown Mystics: Restoring the Soul of Our Nation through the Healing Wisdom of America’s Mystics” (Amazon.com: Homegrown Mystics: Restoring Our Nation with the Healing Wisdom of America’s Visionaries: 9781625249142: Epperly, Bruce: Books) “Jesus: Mystic, Healer, and Prophet “(Jesus: Mystic, Healer, and Prophet: Epperly, Bruce: 9781625248732: Amazon.com: Books. His latest book is “Healing the World: Whitehead, Francis, Clare, and Bonaventure on Spirituality and Planetary Transformation” (Healing the World: Whitehead, Francis, Clare, and Bonaventure on Spiritual and Planetary Transformation: Epperly, Bruce G: 9781631999468: Amazon.com: Books)