Buddhist Catholic Contemplative Evangelical General Christian Hindu Jewish Latter-day Saint Muslim New Visions Progressive Christian

Beliefs

Topics

Columnists

Resource Library

Research Tools

Video

Podcasts

Thought Readers

Faith In Media Tracker

Newsletters

Ad-Free & Subscriber Log-In Subscription Support

Follow Patheos

Home
Evangelical
Taking Every Thought Captive: Learning Gratitude

Taking Every Thought Captive: Learning Gratitude

Last updated on: July 28, 2026 at 10:10 pm by Jeff McLain

0 Comments

Taking Every Thought Captive: Learning Gratitude 2026-07-28T22:10:24-04:00 Jeff McLain

LOGO Patheos Explore the world's faith through different perspectives on religion and spirituality! Patheos has the views of the prevalent religions and spiritualities of the world.

Taking Every Thought Captive: Learning Gratitude. Photo by Jeff McLain with Chat GPT.

Taking Every Thought Captive: Learning Gratitude. Photo by Jeff McLain with ChatGPT.

What does it really mean to take every thought captive? Perhaps it begins not merely by identifying our thoughts, but by surrendering them to Christ until they become worship.

Paul exhorts believers to “take every thought captive to obey Christ” (2 Corinthians 10:5, NASB 2020). That command is often reduced to simply becoming aware of our thoughts or recognizing unhealthy patterns. It is about how our lives can develop patterns that create idols, arguments, and pretensions that set themselves up in the center of our lives, and against the knowledge and good of God. Awareness of these thoughts is certainly important, but Paul is calling us to something much deeper.

Paul isn’t merely talking about private thoughts. He’s speaking about every pattern of thinking, every argument, every pretension, and every idol that exalts itself against the knowledge of God. Those strongholds don’t merely exist “out there.” They often become internal ways of seeing ourselves, others, and God.

The phrase take every thought captive is military language. It describes leading a prisoner into submission. Our thoughts are not meant to rule us. Our impulses, ambitions, fears, appetites, and longing for affirmation are not the masters of our lives. In fact, we are demolishing these things. The desires fueled by “the lust of the flesh and the lust of the eyes and the boastful pride of life” are not meant to steer the ship (1 John 2:16, NASB 2020). It is these things that we must take captive and demolish before they can steer the ship. Left unchecked, left to roam and reign, they have the power to steer the ship, to take authority over our lives and bring ruin.

Instead, though, those who belong to Christ have been given something greater.

This is why we can take these things captive.

The same Holy Spirit who raised Jesus from the dead now dwells within us (Romans 8:11, NASB 2020). Through the Holy Spirit’s power, our minds can be renewed, our hearts transformed, and even our thoughts brought under the gracious authority of Christ. We are no longer slaves to our old nature. Though we were once enemies of God, we have been reconciled through Christ and are being transformed into His likeness (Romans 5:10; Romans 12:2, NASB 2020). Often, because we don’t remind ourselves or remember such realities, we live with a domesticated sense of the Holy Spirit. We live as though our old slave drivers still hold authority over us rather than walking in the power of the Spirit who now dwells within us.

Taking every thought captive, then, is not simply naming what is happening inside us. It is bringing every thought into the presence of Jesus until it becomes obedient to Him. It is about remembering who reigns in us so that nothing else will.

Gratitude Is One Way We Obey Christ

One of the remarkable patterns throughout Paul’s letters is gratitude. I think Paul does this intentionally but even naturally. Surely he is rooting them in the gratitude he has for them, but he is also modeling gratitude. Even more, he is doing what has become natural to him because of his own transformation. In the midst of the trials, circumstances, and tough moments, he is doing what he has already trained himself to do well. Each moment is not full of the circumstances and context but of what he sees to be grateful for.

Paul begins many of his epistles by thanking God for the churches he serves. He expresses appreciation for fellow workers, faithful friends, and believers he has only heard about from afar. Gratitude was not an occasional emotion for Paul. It was a way of life.

Paul also repeatedly calls the church to “give thanks in all circumstances; for this is the will of God for you in Christ Jesus” (1 Thessalonians 5:18, NASB 2020).

Perhaps one of the most practical ways we take our thoughts captive is by transforming them into thanksgiving. Paul does this naturally out of his own transformation. When entitlement rises within us, gratitude reminds us that everything we have is a gift.

When anxiety takes hold, gratitude reminds us of God’s faithfulness.

When comparison begins to grow, gratitude teaches us to rejoice in what God has already given.

Gratitude becomes an act of obedience.

The Subtle Danger of Entitlement

Recently I found myself in a conversation where we were made aware of some entitlement that had surfaced in a situation. As I listened, I was surprised by how easily people could become dissatisfied with gifts they had freely received. At first, I even found myself judging what I heard.

Then, as I walked away, the Holy Spirit gently turned the mirror toward me. I realized that I am often no different. How often do I stop and think, I have been given so much? How often do I truly believe that what I already have is enough? I can tell you I lose this battle more than I win.

Like Israel in the wilderness, it is easy to grumble even while surrounded by God’s daily provision (Exodus 16:2–3, NASB 2020). We become so focused on what we lack that we lose sight of the abundance already sitting in front of us.

We begin believing that happiness is always one more purchase away.

One more vacation.

One bigger house.

One better opportunity.

One larger paycheck.

Yet Scripture reminds us that “Every good thing given and every perfect gift is from above, coming down from the Father of lights” (James 1:17, NASB 2020).

Everything good is grace.

Yet, far too often we don’t receive it as such.

Gratitude: Learning to Notice Again

A few years ago, Pete Greig of the Prayer 24-7 Movement shared a story about stopping during a prayer walk simply to thank God for the beauty of a tree.

That image has stayed with me.

At first, it almost seems childish.

Then you realize how rarely most of us actually notice the world around us.

This evening I was taking a walk after a line of storms had passed through. The sky glowed with shades of orange and pink as the sun settled beyond the horizon. Trees swayed gently in the breeze. Lightning bugs began appearing all around me. Birds filled the evening air with song. I watched bats dance in the dusk sky.

As I slowed down, something inside me slowed down too. The beauty around me seemed to loosen the rust that had accumulated not only in my body but also in my thoughts.

I found myself simply thanking God.

Not for anything extraordinary…

Just for the evening.
For the trees.
For the breeze.
For the birds.
For another day.

It then began to train me to look at other areas of my life with gratitude. Gratitude was contagious. As I gave over to one act of gratitude, I became more content.

I am realizing that gratitude can teach me how to see. Once I thanked God for the beauty around me, I noticed the birds. Then the breeze. Then the evening sky. Eventually I found myself looking at my own life and what I have differently. Gratitude had become contagious.

Discernment Begins with Contentment

This season of my life includes a great deal of discernment.

There are decisions to make and opportunities to weigh.

Yet one question keeps returning to me: Am I okay if this is all God chooses to give me?

That question exposes motives quickly.

Am I pursuing God’s will, or simply chasing something bigger?

Am I discerning from gratitude or from discontent?

The question isn’t always easy to answer because our motives are often mixed and our hearts can deceive us (Jeremiah 17:9, NASB 2020). Emotions are confusing and complicated.

However, contentment does not come from, nor does it develop, complacency. Scripture encourages us to work faithfully and steward opportunities well. Contentment frees us from believing that our joy depends upon receiving something more.

Paul learned this lesson through hardship. He wrote, “I have learned to be content in whatever circumstances I am” (Philippians 4:11, NASB 2020).

Contentment is learned. It is part of the transformation when we pull on the authority God has extended to us through Jesus and has given us to overcome the slave drivers reigning in our lives.

Contentment is learned through the learning of gratitude. Gratitude is the school in which contentment is learned.

A Quiet Life of Gratitude & Worship

Perhaps this is one of the simplest ways we practice taking every thought captive.

We notice.
We surrender.
We give thanks.
We allow ordinary moments to become worship.

The Spirit who lives within us empowers us to bring every thought under the authority of Christ. As we do, criticism slowly gives way to gratitude, entitlement yields to contentment, and worship begins to shape our everyday lives.

I suspect gratitude is just as contagious as criticism.

An entitled spirit spreads quickly through families, churches, and workplaces.

But so can gratitude and thanksgiving.

When people encounter someone who genuinely delights in God’s goodness, notices God’s gifts, and speaks with gratitude, it changes the atmosphere around them.

Perhaps this is part of what it means to live “a quiet life” (1 Thessalonians 4:11, NASB 2020). To live in a still, present, and patient moment with God. It is in such a life that we do not withdraw from the world, but quietly bear witness to a generous Father who gives good gifts to His children.

Taking every thought captive is less about winning an argument in our minds and more about redirecting our hearts toward worship. Every act of genuine gratitude is a declaration that God is enough. Every “thank you” weakens entitlement and strengthens contentment. Every ordinary moment received as grace becomes another thought made obedient to Christ.

Maybe it all begins with two simple words:

Thank You.

A Quiet Life of Worship

This isn’t the first time I’ve written about gratitude. I’ve explored it in play through Ecclesiastes, in the wilderness through praise, and in the workplace through Daniel. The more I reflect on Scripture, the more convinced I become that gratitude is not simply another spiritual discipline. It is one of the primary ways God reshapes our hearts.

So before you move on with your day, pause for just a moment.

Look around the room.

Notice one ordinary thing you’ve overlooked.

Thank God for it.

Then ask yourself:

What thought am I carrying today that needs to become gratitude?

I’d love to hear from you in the comments.

What ordinary gift are you thankful for today?
Where is gratitude coming easily right now?
Where are you struggling to see God’s goodness?

If this post resonated, subscribe for future reflections, share it with a friend, or leave a comment. You can learn more about his journey to recover a rooted Christian way of life through the Lord’s Prayer, ancient habits, leading a quiet life, and simple Jesus communities online at JeffMcLain.com, the Lead a Quiet Life blog on Patheos, or the Discovering God Podcast.

General Christian

About Jeff McLain

Jeff McLain is a Doctor of Ministry Student on the Lord’s Prayer at Kairos University, Director of Pastoral Ministries at Water Street Mission, and a pastor at River Corner Church. Mobilized by 1 Thessalonians 4:11-12, Jeff blogs about recovering a rooted Christian way of life through the Lord’s Prayer, ancient habits, leading a quiet life, and simple Jesus communities. You can read more about the author here.

Previous Post

July 25, 2026

Introducing the Story of Corrie Ten Boom to a New Generation

Next Post

August 5, 2026 When Psalm 23 Began Reading Me

Who said, "Here I am, send me!"?

Select your answer to see how you score.

Moses Peter Isaiah Elijah