Buddhist Catholic Contemplative Evangelical General Christian Hindu Jewish Latter-day Saint Muslim New Visions Progressive Christian

Beliefs

Topics

Columnists

Resource Library

Research Tools

Video

Podcasts

Thought Readers

Faith In Media Tracker

Newsletters

Ad-Free & Subscriber Log-In Subscription Support

Follow Patheos

Seasons of Grace

Home
Catholic
Cardinal Burke: “Cardinal Kasper’s Synod Proposal Involves Disobedience to the Words of Our Lord Himself”

Cardinal Burke: “Cardinal Kasper’s Synod Proposal Involves Disobedience to the Words of Our Lord Himself”

Last updated on: December 28, 2014 at 4:23 pm by Kathy Schiffer

Cardinal Burke: “Cardinal Kasper’s Synod Proposal Involves Disobedience to the Words of Our Lord Himself” 2014-12-28T16:23:36-05:00 Kathy Schiffer

LOGO Patheos Explore the world's faith through different perspectives on religion and spirituality! Patheos has the views of the prevalent religions and spiritualities of the world.

The impending conflict among participants at this week’s Synod is evident:

Cardinal Kasper urges a reconsideration of communion for divorced and remarried Catholics.
Cardinal Burke says no, that could never be.

And the people in the pews line up behind one voice or the other–waiting, wondering, now in the countdown to the Synod on the Family which begins Sunday, October 5, in Rome.

Disagreement is nothing new to the Church, said Cardinal Raymond L. Burke, prefect of the Supreme Court of the Apostolic Signatura. Speaking to reporters September 30 in a Tele-press Conference Call organized by Ignatius Press, Cardinal Burke said,

“In the whole history of the church, in the early centuries, the church had to fight to honor the truth that our Lord Jesus Christ is God and man…”

He looked back to the Arian heresy, and noted that even among prelates, there is disagreement which must be addressed and resolved. But when asked about his reaction to Cardinal Kasper’s proposal, Cardinal Burke was adamant in his opposition:

“Well, I certainly have serious difficulties with what Cardinal Kasper was proposing. In proposing it, he was urging a direction which in the whole history of the church has never taken, a direction which would in some way involve either a disobedience to or at least a non-full adherence to the words of our Lord Himself and no one questions the words of our Lord in chapter 19 of the Gospel According to Matthew.”

The issue is not, as some seem to think, that the Church doesn’t welcome divorced persons. Even those who are in a second marriage are encouraged to attend the Sunday liturgy and to join in worshipping with their fellow Catholics. They are, however, unable to receive the Eucharist.

In fact, the whole issue has two distinct parts: (1) What is marriage? and (2) Who may receive the Eucharist.

THE INDISSOLUBILITY OF MARRIAGE

But Sometimes a Marriage Doesn’t Work Out. Why Does the Church Refuse to Recognize Divorce?

Marriage, in the eyes of the Catholic Church, is indissoluble. The Church respects the admonition of Jesus in Mark 10:9,

“What therefore God has joined together, let no man separate.”

Paragraph 1664 of the Catechism of the Catholic Church explains this indissoluble one-flesh union of two persons into one:

The love of the spouses requires, of its very nature, the unity and indissolubility of the spouses’ community of persons, which embraces their entire life: “so they are no longer two, but one flesh.” They “are called to grow continually in their communion through day-to-day fidelity to their marriage promise of total mutual self-giving.” This human communion is confirmed, purified, and completed by communion in Jesus Christ, given through the sacrament of Matrimony. It is deepened by lives of the common faith and by the Eucharist received together.

So unless a couple obtains an annulment, the Church presumes that the husband is still married to his first wife; hence, any future relationships would be adulterous. In the annulment process, the couple works with Church officials and canon lawyers to investigate whether, for one reason or another, the marriage was never a valid marriage under God.

Even if there were children born to the couple during the years they were married, the marriage may be deemed invalid if certain conditions were not met: If, for example, one spouse was already married to someone else, or one had no intention to remain faithful, or if one or both had no intent to welcome children.

But apart from a serious preexisting problem which prevents a valid marriage, the Church assumes that the couple are married, and that that marriage cannot be dissolved. The Catechism explains:

A valid marriage, even one marked by serious difficulties, could not be considered invalid without doing violence to the truth and undermining thereby the only solid foundation which can support personal, marital and social life. A judge, therefore, must always be on guard against the risk of misplaced compassion, which would degenerate into sentimentality, itself only pastoral in appearance. The roads leading away from justice and truth end up in serving to distance people from God, thus yielding the opposite result from that which was sought in good faith.

WHO MAY RECEIVE THE EUCHARIST?

So the Church is telling you–Divorced and Remarried Man or Woman–that you cannot receive Christ’s Body and Blood in the Eucharist? How dare they? Paraphrasing the oft-misunderstood words of Pope Francis, “Who are we to judge?”

Well, it’s like this: Paul, in his First Letter to the Corinthians, warned in Chapter 11:29 that we must never eat and drink the Body and Blood of Christ unworthily, lest we face damnation. He writes:

For he who eats and drinks, eats and drinks judgment to himself if he does not judge the body rightly.

A person must be in a state of grace before he takes into his body the pure Body of Christ. Of course, we are all sinners–and we acknowledge our weakness just before receiving the Eucharist, when we pray the words of the centurion from Matthew 8:8,

“Oh Lord, I am not worthy that you should come under my roof, but only say the word and my soul shall be healed.”

But some of us–including those who persist in grave sin such as adultery–should not approach the altar, for fear of God’s judgment and in respect for the holiness of the sacrament. Louise Mensch, a divorced and remarried Catholic, wrote a frank response to Cardinal Kasper in the October 4 issue of The Spectator. “Accept liberal arguments for the convenience of people like me,” she argues, “and you threaten the foundations of the Church.” Mensch writes:

What Cardinal Kasper appears to want to do is to tempt a generation of people into weekly mortal sin. How is that merciful? How is that helping? Is it impossible for liberal theologians to combine their reforming fervour with actual logic? Allow a divorced and remarried person to receive Holy Communion and you are saying one of two things: either that it is not adulterous to have sex outside the marital bond, or that one may harmlessly receive the Most Holy Eucharist while in an ongoing state of mortal sin — a sin one firmly intends to commit again as soon as convenient.

Mensch’s column is excellent. You can read the rest of it here.

* * * * *

Of course, participants at the Synod on the Family will discuss other important issues, as well. While no formal agenda has been released, we expect that the Synod will address the matters of same-sex relationships, grandparents and the extended family, single motherhood, the challenge of promoting monogamy in polygamous cultures, and more. As the Synod gets underway this weekend, let us join with Cardinal Burke in the prayer which he offers at the conclusion of his essay in Remaining in the Truth of Christ:

May God grant that the coming meeting of the Synod of Bishops lead to a new commitment to “justice and truth” that is the indispensable foundation of a deeper love of God and of one’s neighbor in the family and, from the family, in the whole Church.

* * * * *

Ignatius Press, sponsor of the Tele-press Conference on September 30, has published four books which are of special interest to those who want to understand the Synod’s emphasis on the family. The books, each of which was featured in Tuesday’s Tele-press Conference, are:

The Gospel of the Family by Father Juan José Pérez-Soba
The Hope of the Family: A Dialogue with Cardinal Gerhard Müller
Of Human Life -Humanae Vitae (Encyclical Letter of Paul VI)
Remaining in the Truth of Christ: Marriage and Communion in the Catholic Church edited by Robert Dodaro, O.S.A.

Previous Post

October 3, 2014

This Time, It's Atheist Scalfari Who Surprises--He Asks Pope Francis for a Blessing

Next Post

October 4, 2014 R.I.P. Father Groeschel, Good and Faithful Servant (UPDATED)

Browse Our Archives

Select a Category #Synod14 Abortion Abstinence Abuse Addiction Adoption Advent Adventure Advertising Aging Agnosticism All Saints Day All Souls Day Amish Anathema Angels Anglican Animals Annulment Annunciation Apocalypse Apologetics Apostles Apostleship of the Sea Apparitions Archangels Archbishop Cordileone Archbishop Dolan Archbishop Vigneron Archeology Architecture Art Art Buchwald Ash Wednesday Assisted Suicide Astronauts Atheism Athletes Babies Baptism Beatification Beauty Bible Biochemistry Bioethics Birds Bishop Lori Bishops Blasphemy Books Canon Law Canonization Capital Punishment Cardinal Burke Cardinal Dolan Cardinal George Caritas Catechesis Catechism of the Catholic Church Catholic Catholic Education Catholic Higher Education Catholic Social Teaching Celibacy Cemeteries Character Charity Chastity Cheapskate Christian Unity Christmas Churches Civil Rights Cloning Comedy Communion of Saints Community Kitchens Confession Confirmation Conscience Consequences Consistory Constitution Contraception Conversion Cooking Councils of the Church Creativity Criminal Justice Cristero War Crucifixion Crystal Cathedral Culture Death Death and Dying Death Penalty Department of Health and Human Services Diaconate Dictatorship of Relativism Dignity Disability Discrimination Dissidence Divorce Doctors of the Church Early Church Fathers Easter Economics Ecumenism Education Encyclicals Environmentalism Episcopal Church Eucharist Euthanasia Evangelism Evangelists Evangelization Evolution Excuses Facebook Faith Families Family Fashion Fasting Fatherhood Federal Government Feminism Fiction Film First Amendment First Communion For Greater Glory Forgiveness Free Speech Friends Friendship Gender Discrimination Germany Gnosticism Good Friday Government Grace Greed Gregorian Calendar Happiness Health Heaven Heresy History Holidays Holiness Hollywood Holy Land Holy Saturday Holy Spirit Holy Week Holy Year Home Sweet Home Homosexuality Hope Humanism Humility Humor Imagination Immaculate Conception Immigration Impulsivity In Vitro Fertilization Incarnation Indulgences Infallibility Internet Islam Italy Jerusalem Jesus Judaism Justice Kathleen Sebelius Labor Movement LCWR Lent Life Literature Liturgy Lourdes Love Magi Marketing Marriage Martyrdom Martyrs Mary Mass Media Medical Ethics Mexico Michigan Miracles Missionaries Modernism Modesty Monks Monothelitism Motherhood Movies Mushrooms Music Muslim Mystery Mysticism Mythology Nativity Natural Law Nature New Evangelization New Media New Year New Year's Resolutions Nostalgia Obscenity Occult Old Testament Origen Orthodox Orvieto Pallium Papacy Parenting Patience Patriarch Bartholomew Patriotism Peace Peace and Justice Penitence Pentecost People Persecution Philosophy Poetry Political activism Political Correctness Politics Polls Pop Culture Pope Benedict XVI Pope Francis Pope John Paul II Pope John XXIII Pope Paul VI Pope St. Pius X Pope Urban VII Population Prayer Preaching Prejudice Pride Priesthood Pro-Life Protestantism Psychology Purgatory Queenship of Mary Racism Rape Real Presence Reconciliation Reformation Relics Religious Religious Liberty Reliquary Renewal Reproductive Technology Resurrection Rights Romance Rome Royalty Sacraments Sacred Heart Saints Satanism Science Science Fiction Scripture Seal of Confession Secularism Seniors September 11 Seventy Times Seven Sexuality Sharks Sin Smoking Social Communications Social Justice Social Networking Social Sciences Space Exploration Spirituality Sports St. Luke St. Patrick's Day St. Paul St. Peter St. Teresa of Avila Stations of the Cross Steve Jobs Superstition Supreme Court Symbolism Synod Technology Teen Rebellion Television Terrorism Thankfulness Thanksgiving Theology Think This, Not That Tobit Toilets Toys Tradition Traditions Transplants Travel Trinity Twitter U.S. Air Force Uncategorized United Nations USCCB Valentine Vatican Vatican Archives Vatican Blogfest Virtue Vocations Where We Pray White Heart Women World Day of Social Communications World Meeting of Families World News World Youth Day Worship Writing Year of Consecrated Life Year of Faith Year of Mercy Youth

Select a Month December 2015 November 2015 October 2015 September 2015 August 2015 July 2015 June 2015 May 2015 April 2015 March 2015 February 2015 January 2015 December 2014 November 2014 October 2014 September 2014 August 2014 July 2014 June 2014 May 2014 April 2014 March 2014 February 2014 January 2014 December 2013 November 2013 October 2013 September 2013 August 2013 July 2013 June 2013 May 2013 April 2013 March 2013 February 2013 January 2013 December 2012 November 2012 October 2012 September 2012 August 2012 July 2012 June 2012 May 2012 April 2012 March 2012 February 2012 January 2012 December 2011 November 2011 October 2011 September 2011 August 2011 July 2011 June 2011 May 2011 April 2011 March 2011 February 2011 January 2011 December 2010 November 2010 October 2010

TAKE THE

Religious Wisdom Quiz

What Christian group believes in "Anabaptism"?

Select your answer to see how you score.

Mennonites Presbyterians Anglicans Lutherans