Buddhist Catholic Contemplative Evangelical General Christian Hindu Jewish Latter-day Saint Muslim New Visions Progressive Christian

Beliefs

Topics

Columnists

Resource Library

Research Tools

Video

Podcasts

Thought Readers

Faith In Media Tracker

Newsletters

Ad-Free & Subscriber Log-In Subscription Support

Follow Patheos

Seasons of Grace

Home
Catholic
With Charity and Grace: Hosanna-Tabor Pastor on the Supreme Court Case

With Charity and Grace: Hosanna-Tabor Pastor on the Supreme Court Case

Last updated on: September 30, 2016 at 4:00 pm by Kathy Schiffer

With Charity and Grace: Hosanna-Tabor Pastor on the Supreme Court Case 2016-09-30T16:00:17-05:00 Kathy Schiffer

LOGO Patheos Explore the world's faith through different perspectives on religion and spirituality! Patheos has the views of the prevalent religions and spiritualities of the world.

“We’re offering prayers of thanksgiving,” said Paul Undlin, senior pastor of Hosanna-Tabor Lutheran Church. “This whole thing has been a weight on my shoulders. It’s been a cloud over my ministry, over the whole church.”

He was referring, of course, to the case of Hosanna-Tabor Church and School v. EEOC, the Supreme Court’s “ministerial exception” case which was decided this week by a landmark 9-0 vote.

He accepted congratulations on the Supreme Court’s ruling in favor of the church; and he expressed his relief that his time could now be spent, not poring over lengthy legal briefs, but on the work of the gospel.

* * * * *

All eyes are focused this week on Hosanna-Tabor Lutheran Church in Redford, Michigan. Hosanna-Tabor Church and School v. EEOC is, by some estimations, the most important religious-freedom case to reach the Supreme Court in the history of our country; and the generosity and deeply Christian perspective of the ministry staff at Hosanna-Tabor was truly an inspiration.

Hosanna-Tabor Lutheran Church is a small community church affiliated with the Lutheran Church-Missouri Synod. According to Pastor Paul J. Undlin, there are about 250 members; and typically, 163 of them worship at the church each Sunday. Pastor Paul, as he prefers to be called, has been at the church for 3½ years (since June 2008), and so was not present at the time of Cheryl Perich’s employment, nor was he involved in her dismissal.

Still, Pastor Paul explains that the flurry of briefs that crossed his desk, and the calls that came whenever the story appeared in the news, took a good amount of his time. He wanted to be sure that he and his staff were well prepared—that their words would convey the “right” message of truth and grace.

He wanted to be sure, too, that they did not speak ill of the former teacher who had opposed them in the court fight. “She was ill used by the EEOC,” Pastor Paul explained. “She was taken advantage of by them. They have dragged her along on this seven-year journey, as well.”

He was grateful for the case’s resolution: The Obama Administration’s over-reaching was ruled unconstitutional by a unanimous 9-0 ruling by the Supreme Court of the United States. “How often,” Pastor Paul asked, “has the Supreme Court been unanimous?” He pointed out, though, that it was to be expected. “You don’t have to look far into the Constitution to see the ministerial exception!” he avered.

The first few words of the First Amendment would, in fact, seem to support his view:

Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof.

THE CASE AGAINST HOSANNA-TABOR CHURCH AND SCHOOL

Well, actually, make that simply “Hosanna-Tabor Lutheran Church.” The school actually closed three years ago—merging its elementary program with that of another school, and making the reinstatement of former fourth grade teacher Cheryl Perich a moot point.

Perich, according to court documents, began her employment at Hosanna-Tabor School in 2000 as a lay teacher; but upon completion of a program of theological study at Concordia College, she was invited to become a “called” teacher, a member of the ministry team. Perich accepted their call; as a member of the ministerial team, she taught classes, taught religion, and led worship services. She became ill, however, early in the 2004-2005 school year, eventually being diagnosed with narcolepsy; and the school contracted with a lay teacher to replace her for the year. When Ms. Perich announced in January that she was ready to return to the classroom, she was not welcomed back by the school, now under contract with another teacher.

Perich did not take the news well, even when the school offered to cover part of her health insurance costs. She threatened to sue—but the confrontation backfired and the parish, displeased with her attitude, rescinded her call and her employment was formally terminated on April 11, 2005.

In the case, she had not sought to be reinstated; since the school no longer exists, that was never an option. She did, though, hope to receive back wages, punitive damages and other benefits.

A small church like Hosanna-Tabor Lutheran had little hope of raising the funds necessary, had the Court ruled in favor of the plaintiff. Pastor Paul admitted that had they lost, the church would have been forced to close. The ministry would have simply disappeared.

THE OBAMA ADMINISTRATION’S RECORD OF OBSTRUCTING RELIGIOUS LIBERTY

Since the start of the Obama Administration, the federal government has been pushing, demanding, inserting itself into the private affairs of the churches.

Bishop William Lori, testifying before the House Judiciary Committee in October 2011, cited recent examples of government usurpation of the rights of religious institutions:

In August, the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services issued regulations to mandate coverage of contraception (including abortifacients) and sterilization as “preventive services” in almost all private health insurance plans. There was an exception for certain religious organizations; but the exemption was so narrow that few would qualify—and the exception does nothing to protect the conscience rights of insurers or individuals.
In May 2011, HHS added a new requirement to its cooperative agreements and government contracts for services to victims of human trafficking and to refugees who are unaccompanied minors. Under the new policy, highly qualified service providers (such as the USCCB’s Migration and Refugee Services) were barred from participation in the program because they could not in conscience provide the “full range” of contraceptive services—namely, abortion and contraception.
The State Department’s U.S. Aid for International Development (USAID) is increasingly requiring contractors, such as Catholic Relief Services, to provide comprehensive HIV prevention activities (including condom distribution), as well as full integration of its programs with reproductive health activities (including provision of artificial contraception) as part of their international relief and development programs. Under this new requirement, some of the most effective providers helping to prevent AIDS inAfrica and other developing nations will be excluded.
The federal Department of Justice (DoJ) has ratcheted up its attack on the Defense of Marriage Act (DOMA), which was passed during the Clinton Administration in 1996, by mischaracterizing it as “bigotry.” In March 2011, the DoJ stopped defending DOMA against constitutional challenges; and in July, the Department began filing briefs attacking DOMA’s constitutionality, claiming that supporters of the law could only have been motivated by bias and prejudice.
The Department of Justice also sought to undermine religious liberty in the critically important “ministerial exception” case, Hosanna-Tabor v. EEOC. The Department of Justice could have taken the position that the “ministerial exception,” though generally providing strong protection for the right of religious groups to choose their ministers without government intrusion, didn’t apply in the case before the court. Instead, the DoJ attacked the very existence of the exception, in opposition to a vast coalition of religious groups urging its preservation through their amicus curiae briefs.

Religious liberty has been in the crosshairs at the local level, too, with the redefinition of marriage.

In New York, county clerks faced legal action for refusing to participate in same-sex unions, and gay rights advocates boast how little religious freedom protection individuals and groups will enjoy under the new law.
In Illinois, Catholic Charities has been driven out of the foster care business because it recognizes the unique value of man-woman marriage for the well-being of children.

Religious Liberty

Supreme Court

Bishop William Lori

Hosanna-Tabor Lutheran Church

Pastor Paul Undlin

Religious Liberty

Supreme Court

Previous Post

January 12, 2012

The Pope and the Crocodile

Next Post

January 15, 2012 The Tebow Phenomenon: Two Kinds of Prejudice

Browse Our Archives

Select a Category #Synod14 Abortion Abstinence Abuse Addiction Adoption Advent Adventure Advertising Aging Agnosticism All Saints Day All Souls Day Amish Anathema Angels Anglican Animals Annulment Annunciation Apocalypse Apologetics Apostles Apostleship of the Sea Apparitions Archangels Archbishop Cordileone Archbishop Dolan Archbishop Vigneron Archeology Architecture Art Art Buchwald Ash Wednesday Assisted Suicide Astronauts Atheism Athletes Babies Baptism Beatification Beauty Bible Biochemistry Bioethics Birds Bishop Lori Bishops Blasphemy Books Canon Law Canonization Capital Punishment Cardinal Burke Cardinal Dolan Cardinal George Caritas Catechesis Catechism of the Catholic Church Catholic Catholic Education Catholic Higher Education Catholic Social Teaching Celibacy Cemeteries Character Charity Chastity Cheapskate Christian Unity Christmas Churches Civil Rights Cloning Comedy Communion of Saints Community Kitchens Confession Confirmation Conscience Consequences Consistory Constitution Contraception Conversion Cooking Councils of the Church Creativity Criminal Justice Cristero War Crucifixion Crystal Cathedral Culture Death Death and Dying Death Penalty Department of Health and Human Services Diaconate Dictatorship of Relativism Dignity Disability Discrimination Dissidence Divorce Doctors of the Church Early Church Fathers Easter Economics Ecumenism Education Encyclicals Environmentalism Episcopal Church Eucharist Euthanasia Evangelism Evangelists Evangelization Evolution Excuses Facebook Faith Families Family Fashion Fasting Fatherhood Federal Government Feminism Fiction Film First Amendment First Communion For Greater Glory Forgiveness Free Speech Friends Friendship Gender Discrimination Germany Gnosticism Good Friday Government Grace Greed Gregorian Calendar Happiness Health Heaven Heresy History Holidays Holiness Hollywood Holy Land Holy Saturday Holy Spirit Holy Week Holy Year Home Sweet Home Homosexuality Hope Humanism Humility Humor Imagination Immaculate Conception Immigration Impulsivity In Vitro Fertilization Incarnation Indulgences Infallibility Internet Islam Italy Jerusalem Jesus Judaism Justice Kathleen Sebelius Labor Movement LCWR Lent Life Literature Liturgy Lourdes Love Magi Marketing Marriage Martyrdom Martyrs Mary Mass Media Medical Ethics Mexico Michigan Miracles Missionaries Modernism Modesty Monks Monothelitism Motherhood Movies Mushrooms Music Muslim Mystery Mysticism Mythology Nativity Natural Law Nature New Evangelization New Media New Year New Year's Resolutions Nostalgia Obscenity Occult Old Testament Origen Orthodox Orvieto Pallium Papacy Parenting Patience Patriarch Bartholomew Patriotism Peace Peace and Justice Penitence Pentecost People Persecution Philosophy Poetry Political activism Political Correctness Politics Polls Pop Culture Pope Benedict XVI Pope Francis Pope John Paul II Pope John XXIII Pope Paul VI Pope St. Pius X Pope Urban VII Population Prayer Preaching Prejudice Pride Priesthood Pro-Life Protestantism Psychology Purgatory Queenship of Mary Racism Rape Real Presence Reconciliation Reformation Relics Religious Religious Liberty Reliquary Renewal Reproductive Technology Resurrection Rights Romance Rome Royalty Sacraments Sacred Heart Saints Satanism Science Science Fiction Scripture Seal of Confession Secularism Seniors September 11 Seventy Times Seven Sexuality Sharks Sin Smoking Social Communications Social Justice Social Networking Social Sciences Space Exploration Spirituality Sports St. Luke St. Patrick's Day St. Paul St. Peter St. Teresa of Avila Stations of the Cross Steve Jobs Superstition Supreme Court Symbolism Synod Technology Teen Rebellion Television Terrorism Thankfulness Thanksgiving Theology Think This, Not That Tobit Toilets Toys Tradition Traditions Transplants Travel Trinity Twitter U.S. Air Force Uncategorized United Nations USCCB Valentine Vatican Vatican Archives Vatican Blogfest Virtue Vocations Where We Pray White Heart Women World Day of Social Communications World Meeting of Families World News World Youth Day Worship Writing Year of Consecrated Life Year of Faith Year of Mercy Youth

Select a Month December 2015 November 2015 October 2015 September 2015 August 2015 July 2015 June 2015 May 2015 April 2015 March 2015 February 2015 January 2015 December 2014 November 2014 October 2014 September 2014 August 2014 July 2014 June 2014 May 2014 April 2014 March 2014 February 2014 January 2014 December 2013 November 2013 October 2013 September 2013 August 2013 July 2013 June 2013 May 2013 April 2013 March 2013 February 2013 January 2013 December 2012 November 2012 October 2012 September 2012 August 2012 July 2012 June 2012 May 2012 April 2012 March 2012 February 2012 January 2012 December 2011 November 2011 October 2011 September 2011 August 2011 July 2011 June 2011 May 2011 April 2011 March 2011 February 2011 January 2011 December 2010 November 2010 October 2010

TAKE THE

Religious Wisdom Quiz

I am patient and kind. I do not envy or boast. I never fail and endure all things. What am I?

Select your answer to see how you score.

Hope Grace Love Faith