Patheos

BuddhistCatholicContemplativeEvangelicalGeneral ChristianHinduJewishLatter-day SaintMuslimNew VisionsProgressive Christian

Beliefs

Topics

Columnists

Resource Library

Research Tools

Video

Podcasts

Thought Readers

Faith In Media Tracker

Newsletters

Ad-Free & Subscriber Log-In Subscription Support

Patheos

Ad-Free & Subscriber Log-In Subscription Support

Follow Patheos Patheos on Facebook Patheos on YouTube

janetheactuary

The Violinist vs. the Castaway, and an attempt at a new abortion metaphor

Last updated on: December 27, 2022 at 9:08 pm   by Jane the Actuary

The Violinist vs. the Castaway, and an attempt at a new abortion metaphor 2022-12-27T21:08:57-06:00 Jane the Actuary

LOGO Patheos Explore the world's faith through different perspectives on religion and spirituality! Patheos has the views of the prevalent religions and spiritualities of the world.

https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Mcmaster_NICU_infant_6978.jpg; Peter K Burian [CC BY-SA 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0)]

Who recalls the metaphor of the violinist on life support?

This metaphor was created by Judith Thompson in 1971 to explain why abortion is wholly acceptable even if the unborn child is every bit as human and has the same moral status as a born person.  It is an argument of bodily integrity, and it goes like this:

“You wake up in the morning and find yourself back to back in bed with an unconscious violinist. A famous unconscious violinist. He has been found to have a fatal kidney ailment, and the Society of Music Lovers has canvassed all the available medical records and found that you alone have the right blood type to help. They have therefore kidnapped you, and last night the violinist’s circulatory system was plugged into yours, so that your kidneys can be used to extract poisons from his blood as well as your own. The director of the hospital now tells you, ‘Look, we’re sorry the Society of Music Lovers did this to you—we would never have permitted it if we had known. But still, they did it, and the violinist now is plugged into you. To unplug you would be to kill him. But never mind, it’s only for nine months. By then he will have recovered from his ailment, and can safely be unplugged from you’.

“Is it morally incumbent on you to accede to this situation? No doubt it would be very nice of you if you did, a great kindness. But do you have to accede to it? What if it were not nine months, but nine years? Or longer still? What if the director of the hospital says: ‘Tough luck, I agree, but you’ve now got to stay in bed, with the violinist plugged into you, for the rest of your life. Because remember this. All persons have a right to life, and violinists are persons. Granted you have a right to decide what happens in and to your body, but a person’s right to life outweighs your right to decide what happens in and to your body. So you cannot ever be unplugged from him.’ “I imagine you would regard this as outrageous . . .”

(See this Journal of Medical Ethics link for the above crux of her argument and a summary of arguments pro and con, and read what appears to be the full essay here.)

It seems to me that we are now hearing the cry for “bodily autonomy” more and more.  The focus on the “hard cases” is gone, as is the hardship women would face with unexpected pregnancies.  Instead we hear, “women should be able to access abortion at any time and for any reason for the simple reason that that to be prevented from doing so is the equivalent of a ‘forced pregnancy’ or ‘forced birth’ which is a violation of the fundamental right of all people to bodily autonomy.”

At the same time, consider an anecdote, reportedly of anthropologist Margaret Mead’s assessment of what constitutes the beginning of civilization in ancient culture:

Anthropologist Margaret Mead was asked by a student what she considered to be the first sign of civilization in a culture. Mead said that the first sign of civilization in an ancient culture was a femur (thighbone) that had been broken and then healed. Mead explained that in the animal kingdom, if you break your leg, you die. You cannot run from danger, get to the river for a drink or hunt for food. You are meat for prowling beasts. No animal survives a broken leg long enough for the bone to heal. Broken femur that has healed is evidence that someone has taken time to stay with the one who fell, has bound up the wound, has carried the person to safety and has tended the person through recovery. Helping someone else through difficulty is where civilization starts. We are at our best when we serve others. Be civilized.

This quote is almost as popular as her statement that we should “never doubt that a small group of committed people can change the world,” and both of them have something else in common:  there is no evidence that she actually said anything of the sort.  (See this 2020 blog post, which observes that “Both are things she could have said, given her personality, but neither is fully attributed and that “The quote has a bit of ‘truthiness’ to it.”  Another commentary observes that the first written source of this anecdote was a writer who had a practice of “remembering” anecdotes that would fit within his writings.)

But whether Mead said it or not, it resonates with us.  I wouldn’t even call this a matter of a definition of “civilization,” and in that respect the anecdote fails, because in reality scholars already distinguish that people lived together in small bands well before there was anything like “civilization” which, after all, has as its root word “city.”  It’s more fundamental — it’s a matter of “what does it mean to be human?”

Longtime readers with long memories will recall that back in my early blogging days, I wrote that what made humans exceptional was fundamentally, our morality, and that the Christian notion of “original sin” addresses this key turning point:  if a lion has taken over a pride of lionesses and killed the cubs so as to impregnate the lionesses, no one would consider this a heinous, immoral deed.  It’s just a part of the natural world.  A man who abuses the child of his live-in girlfriend, on the other hand?  We criminalize that behavior.  At whatever point, far back in evolution, our distant ancestors become intelligent enough to make moral choices and to be held responsible for them, is that point at which we could reasonably say that those ancestors were “human,” in a far more meaningful way than whether they used tools or controlled fire or the like — it’s just that we have no way to time-machine our way back and define when that point would be.

And here’s another analogy.

Imagine that there are two survivors of a plane crash, or a boat marooned on a deserted island, Gilligan’s Island style.  Think Tom Hanks in Castaway, but two — in particular, an adult and a child.  Unrelated, mind you.  Strangers.  Imagine that the Adult Castaway, let’s call him AC, proclaims that she, or he, is a free person, and has no obligation to anyone.  It’s hard enough to gather enough food and find fresh water for one person.  It requires travelling all across the island, and the child is small, perhaps not even able to walk or at least not for long distances, and at the same time, the child can’t be left alone.  Caring for that child is not impossible, but AC decides it is just not something that something he wants to do.  The kid is whiny, wants his mom, etc.

But surely we would all agree that as a human being, AC has an obligation to care for that child, however much he would prefer not to be in that situation.  There is no alternative caregiver and he cannot let the child die by failing to provide that care.  Whether it is illegal or not is irrelevant because there is no legal system, but the simple fact of being a human being creates this obligation.

And so, too, is the case with pregnancy.  The fact that there is a human being uniquely dependent on me creates the obligation to provide this care, because I am a human being.

************

Are you persuaded?

To be honest, I drafted this post several months ago, and am now engaged in an effort to delete old tabs (among which are the links I used for this draft), but I never clicked “publish” at the time because the reality is that a distressingly large portion of the population is on board with abortion because they simply don’t believe any of it — that is, they don’t believe we have any moral obligations, that the law and social norms exist to ensure we have a relatively harmonious and functioning society, in a utilitarian sort of way.  Yet at the same time, there is a considerable overlap between people who support abortion, at any time and for any reason, and those who advocate for social justice and decry oppression of every sort, and I can’t make too much sense of any of it.  So there you have it — but I’m going to click “publish” and close out of those tabs and move on to the next draft until I have everything cleared out.

Uncategorized

abortion

Previous Post



December 27, 2022

The end of "boys who wear dresses"?

Next Post



July 8, 2023 Trans Kids and Data Analysis: Understanding the "Gender Affirming Care is Lifesaving" Claim


Browse Our Archives

Select a Category Actuarial/Retirement Issues Politics Uncategorized

Select a Month October 2026 September 2026 August 2026 July 2026 June 2026 April 2026 March 2026 February 2026 January 2026 December 2025 November 2025 October 2025 July 2025 June 2025 May 2025 April 2025 March 2025 February 2025 January 2025 December 2024 November 2024 October 2024 September 2024 August 2024 July 2024 June 2024 May 2024 April 2024 March 2024 February 2024 December 2023 November 2023 October 2023 September 2023 August 2023 July 2023 December 2022 September 2022 August 2022 July 2022 June 2022 May 2022 February 2022 January 2022 December 2021 August 2021 June 2021 April 2021 February 2021 January 2021 December 2020 November 2020 October 2020 September 2020 August 2020 July 2020 June 2020 May 2020 April 2020 March 2020 February 2020 January 2020 December 2019 November 2019 October 2019 September 2019 August 2019 July 2019 June 2019 May 2019 April 2019 March 2019 February 2019 January 2019 December 2018 November 2018 October 2018 September 2018 August 2018 July 2018 June 2018 May 2018 April 2018 March 2018 February 2018 January 2018 December 2017 November 2017 October 2017 September 2017 August 2017 July 2017 June 2017 May 2017 April 2017 March 2017 February 2017 January 2017 December 2016 November 2016 October 2016 September 2016 August 2016 July 2016 June 2016 May 2016 April 2016 March 2016 February 2016 January 2016 December 2015 November 2015 October 2015 September 2015 August 2015 July 2015 June 2015 May 2015 April 2015 March 2015 February 2015 January 2015 December 2014 November 2014 October 2014 September 2014 August 2014 July 2014 June 2014 May 2014 April 2014 March 2014 February 2014 January 2014 December 2013 November 2013 October 2013 September 2013 August 2013 July 2013


Follow Us!

Follow Us on Facebook Follow Us on Twitter



TAKE THE

Religious Wisdom Quiz

What prophet was taken up to heaven in a chariot of fire?

Select your answer to see how you score.

Elijah Jeremiah Isaiah Elisha

Related posts from Jane the Actuary

Family

The ERA of 1972 no longer exists in...

Jane the Actuary

Family

What's A Pro-Life Illinoisan To do?

Jane the Actuary

Family

On the end of Roe, and why I'm...

Jane the Actuary

Family

An Imaginary Speech from Amy Klobuchar

Jane the Actuary

TRENDING AT PATHEOS Catholic

Salisbury Cathedral (the windows)-- Part Three

There are a wide variety of sorts of stained glass windows in...

The Apostle Paul: Jewish Double Agent?

Was the Apostle Paul a Jewish double agent? Rome may have crucified...

Postured: Resources for Revering Christ in Our Heart

In my previous blog post, Postured: Revere Christ (1 Peter 3:8-17), we...

Taylor Swift Says 'Toy Story 5' Song Heals...

For nearly three decades, Pixar's "Toy Story" franchise has entertained audiences with...

Why I Struggle with "Inerrancy" Part 2

  This essay follows directly on the heels of a recent one...

"Living on Sacred Land"

  Brant A. Gardner has published a new article in Interpreter: A...

view all Catholic blogs

Patheos on Facebook Patheos on YouTube

Ad-Free & Subscriber Log-In Subscription Support

Copyright 2008-2026, Patheos. All rights reserved.

Subscription Support Ad-Free & Subscriber Log-In

Follow Patheos Patheos on Facebook Patheos on YouTube