Buddhist Catholic Contemplative Evangelical General Christian Hindu Jewish Latter-day Saint Muslim New Visions Progressive Christian

Beliefs

Topics

Columnists

Resource Library

Research Tools

Video

Podcasts

Thought Readers

Faith In Media Tracker

Newsletters

Ad-Free & Subscriber Log-In Subscription Support

Follow Patheos

Home
General Christian
Religion News
Stewardship or Earthly Riches? El Salvador Decides

Stewardship or Earthly Riches? El Salvador Decides

Last updated on: December 4, 2024 at 12:20 pm by Alice H. Murray

0 Comments

Stewardship or Earthly Riches? El Salvador Decides 2024-12-04T12:20:45-05:00 Alice H. Murray

LOGO Patheos Explore the world's faith through different perspectives on religion and spirituality! Patheos has the views of the prevalent religions and spiritualities of the world.

Gold bars stacked haphazardly on a flat surface

Whether to mine gold in El Salvador pits stewardship against earthly riches [Image by Steve Bidmead from Pixabay]

To dig or not to dig. That is the question facing El Salvador’s government. The country’s president proposes lifting the ban on gold mining which has been in place for several years. The lure of economic benefit from mining gold calls for utilizing the country’s resource to better itself. But the Catholic Church believes resulting environmental harm calls for leaving the current ban in place. Stewardship or earthly riches? El Salvador must decide.

El Salvador Basics

El Salvador is the smallest and most densely populated of the seven countries comprising Central America. Unlike the other six countries in the group, it has no coast on the Caribbean. Instead, the Pacific Ocean bounds it to the south. Thus, the country doesn’t entice tourists intent on lounging on a Caribbean beach.

A devastating civil war from the 1970s to the early 1990s destroyed the country’s economy. El Salvador remains saddled with international debt it cannot pay off and partially depends on foreign aid to operate.

Colored map of Central America

El Salvador is the smallest country in South America [Image from Wikimedia Commons]

Gold Mining In El Salvador

The mountainous areas of Central America, including El Salvador, contain large deposits of minerals. Mining in El Salvador began as an artisanal process or small scale mining where basic tools or one’s hands are utilized to extract minerals from the earth. This type of subsistence mining usually involves laborers working independently of mining companies and using their own resources. Later, mining in the country transformed into an industrial process when a US-based company, Commerce Group Corp., industrialized the previously artisanal San Sebastian Mine in the 1970s. Mining then became a significant economic activity in El Salvador.

In 2017, however, El Salvador became the first country in the world to ban metal mining. This cessation followed campaigns involving various groups, including activists, community organizations, and the Catholic Church to achieve that end. The threat to the local ecosystem and to human life served as the impetus for these campaigns. As evidence of this threat, the revocation of the permit to operate the San Sebastian Mine provided solid ground. The mine polluted the San Sebastian River with cyanide, arsenic, and mercury, contaminated drinking water supplies, and prevented agricultural activities. Testing showed 9 times the legal limit of cyanide in the water. Although the mine has been abandoned, pollution in the reiver remains.

Dust-covered African woman with green turban kneels down mining by hand

Woman in Guinea engages in artisanal mining [Image from Wikimedia Commons]

Is Gold Mining That Bad?

Gold mining raises two main issues—detriment to the natural environment as well as abuse of human rights. The cyanide method of extraction, developed in the late 1800s, remains the dominant process Cyanide compounds utilized contain high toxicity levels. Any leaks or spills threaten both human health and aquatic ecosystems. Gold mining also generates more waste than any other type of mining. Lead, mercury, cadmium, and arsenic found in the waste can contaminate both groundwater and the air.

In addition to negative health effects on a mine’s surrounding population, serious risk exists for mine workers. Ten to fifteen million workers engage in artisanal mining, with some 5 million of those workers being women and children. Major corporations may exploit them, with much of their work being done illegally. Working conditions in the mines are difficult with the possibility of tunnel collapses, explosions, and exposure to toxic chemicals used in processing. This exposure, especially in children, may lead to vision problems, hearing loss, and respiratory difficulties.

Headshot of smiling dark-haired man with a black beard and wearing a white-collared shirt and jacket

El Salvador’s President Nayib Bukele prefers earthly riches over environmental stewardship [Image from Wikimedia Commons]

The President And His Position

El Salvador’s current president, Nayib Bukele recently proposed lifting the total ban on gold mining in his country. The popular leader first took office in June 2019, becoming El Salvador’s youngest president at 37. In 2024, the country’s voters re-elected him for a second term. With his political opposition weak and his party controlling the Congress, resistance to Bukele’s proposal to lift the ban is unlikely.

Bukele’s background provides some insight into his position on the gold mining ban. A businessman, he founded his own advertising agency in 1999 prior to entering politics. Those in the business world, of course, focus on the bottom line and don’t like to see red in the financials. Restarting gold mining in El Salvador would allow a lucrative stream of revenue to stimulate and improve the country’s economic situation. Specifically, Bukele finds the ban “absurd” and states gold mining provides “wealth that could transform El Salvador.” Interestingly, he voiced support for the ban when running for president the first time.

Head shot of Roman Catholic religious official in religious garb

Archbishop Alas of El Salvador urgers stewardship over earthly riches [Image courtesy of Wikimedia Commons]

The Catholic Church Disagrees

Unsurprisingly, since it lobbied for the ban now in place, the Catholic Church opposes Bukele’s idea to lift the ban. This past Sunday, Archbishop José Luis Escobar Alas’ sermon expressly asked President Nayib Bukele not to take that action. His words echoed the position of various environmental and civic groups who feel restarting gold mining would “damage this country forever.”

But does the church possess the political clout to overcome Bukele’s proposal? With about half the population of El Salvador being Roman Catholic, including Bukele’s mother, the church holds the ear of a vast, and possibly influential, audience. Whether this audience accepts the characterization of gold mining by the church and acts on it remains to be seen.

Stewardship Or Earthly Riches?

While El Salvador is a small country, the issue facing it about gold mining looms large. Every country and its citizens will at some point have to consider what is most important in how their country operates. The bottom line requires prioritizing stewardship of the earth, mandated by God in the Bible, against earthly riches to better the citizens’ lives. El Salvador must answer that question now.

Religion News

Business, Finance and Religion

About Alice H Murray

After 35 years as a Florida adoption attorney, Alice H. Murray now pursues a different path as Operations Manager for End Game Press. With a passion for writing, she is constantly creating with words. Her work includes contributions to several Short And Sweet books, The Upper Room, Chicken Soup For The Soul, Abba’s Lessons (from CrossRiver Media), and the Northwest Florida Literary Review. Alice is a regular contributor to GO!, a quarterly Christian magazine in the Florida Panhandle, and she has three devotions a month published online by Dynamic Women in Missions. Her devotions have also appeared in compilation devotionals such as Ordinary People Extraordinary God (July 2023) and Guideposts’ Pray A Word A Day, Vol. 2 (June 2023) and pray a word for Hope (September 2023). Alice’s first book, The Secret of Chimneys, an annotated Agatha Christie mystery, was released in April 2023. She has an adoption devotional scheduled for publication in October 2025. On a weekly basis, Alice posts on her blog about current events with a humorous point of view at aliceinwonderingland.wordpress.com. You can read more about the author here.

Previous Post

November 26, 2024

Five Reasons For Giving Thanks For Adoption

Next Post

December 11, 2024 Five Reasons To Celebrate Advent

"Resist the devil, and he will _____."

Select your answer to see how you score.

Grudgingly Respect You Flee From You Pursue You Despise You