Horoscopes from Camelot

Last updated on: December 13, 2014 at 2:32 pm by David Mills

Horoscopes from Camelot 2014-12-13T14:32:59-04:00 David Mills

LOGO Patheos Explore the world's faith through different perspectives on religion and spirituality! Patheos has the views of the prevalent religions and spiritualities of the world.

An @woofboy responding to a friend’s Twitter comment pointed us both to this editorial from Theology Today in 1982: Meyers-Briggs and Other Modern Astrologies.” As described by the writer, Thomas G. Long, it began (this is my summary) in a utopian hope combined with a modern American faith in technology and desire for the easily applied and painlessly effective technique. Plus the experts say it’s not actually very helpful. Plus it gives people an excuse for being jerks, as Long suggests without saying (“This makes MBTI-styled talk vaguely deterministic: ‘This is my personality; it’s just the way I am, probably always will be’,” he notes.)

Why, asks Long, have Christians fallen for it so hard? It helps supply a sense of identity, he argues.

Add to this Isabel Myers’ tendency to describe each personality type in unfailingly optimistic terms and the possibilities for self-flattery abound. For example, ESFPs are, she tells us, “outgoing, easygoing, accepting, friendly, enjoy everything and make things more fun for others. . . ” while ISTJs are “practical, orderly, matter-of-fact, logical, realistic, and dependable.” Nowhere do we encounter the harder truth about ourselves and others, namely the possibility that our personalities include not-so-admirable traits like greed, envy, selfishness, or a propensity toward violence. Myers was aware, of course, that personality formation can go awry, that “bad type development” does happen, but even here she tended to speak in the meekest of terms, admitting that certain personality types may “fail to finish anything,” “neglect their feeling values,” “become too sensitive and vulnerable,” or “burden themselves with a sense of inadequacy.”

In short, the MBTI profiles read like horoscopes from Camelot.

The result is a tool seductively attractive and easy to use but that gives us information more likely to be misleading than helpful. “It is far more fruitful to think of a ‘personality’ in relational terms, as the way one tends to behave with certain other people and under certain conditions,” Long concludes.

Some aspects of a personality persist from setting to setting, but a relational view opens up the possibility of true complexity, unexpected change, repentance, even conversion. . . . Thus, whatever use it may wish to make of instruments like the MBTI, the Christian church needs to make some protest as well, to refuse to accept that people can be known in any serious way through a pencil and paper questionnaire dashed off in a few moments, to insist upon knowing people in the only way they can genuinely be known-in costly and messy relationships that endure

Modern life as it is lived

Previous Post

December 10, 2014

The Tale of Princess Kaguya

Next Post

December 11, 2014 Catholics Moving Right and Left

Browse Our Archives

Select a Category Abortion & life American Life Anglican Affairs Apologetics Art and artistry Beer Capitalism's downside Catholic converts Catholic issues Catholicism & public life Catholicism in general Christianity & culture Christianity & the Jews Conservatism Conservative problems Death Do unto others Dogs Ecumenical friendship Evangelicalism Evil in the world Family Friendship Heroes How we should live Islam It's a funny old world Jews Judaism Israel Judaism justice Liberalism Life issues Marriage Mary Mass Media Modern culture good & bad Modern life as it is lived Modern Religion Mormonism People Personal reflections Politicians Protestantism Race Rand & Randiansm Secularisms Sexualities Society justice equality freedom The papacy & the pope Uncategorized Worship Writing & Language

Select a Month January 2015 December 2014 November 2014 October 2014 September 2014 August 2014 July 2014 June 2014 May 2014

TAKE THE

Religious Wisdom Quiz

What book contains the shortest chapter in the Bible?

Select your answer to see how you score.

Obadiah Proverbs Psalms Haggai