A Bad Use of Orthodoxy

Last updated on: June 28, 2014 at 5:35 pm by David Mills

A Bad Use of Orthodoxy 2014-06-28T17:35:08-04:00 David Mills

LOGO Patheos Explore the world's faith through different perspectives on religion and spirituality! Patheos has the views of the prevalent religions and spiritualities of the world.

“Well, the Orthodox allow second and third marriages” is an argument made by some Catholics for loosening the Catholic Church’s teaching on marriage, which seems harsh and rigid and legalistic in comparison with Orthodoxy’s pastoral oikonomia. Orthodoxy does go farther than the Catholic Church teaches Scripture allows, but the rules aren’t nearly so lax as these advocates of liberalizing marriage claim. Nicola Bux, a professor of theology, explains in the always useful Chiesa that the Orthodox Church gives

a second opportunity in some particular cases (typically cases of ongoing adultery, but also by extension certain cases in which the marriage bond has become a pretense). A third marriage is also possible, although it is highly discouraged. Moreover, the possibility of entering a second marriage in the case of dissolution is granted only to the innocent spouse. Second and third marriages, unlike the first marriage, are celebrated among the Orthodox with a special rite, referred to as “penitential.”

This rite has been “de-sacramentalized” and made into what Latin theology calls a “sacramental,” quoting the American Orthodox theologian Alexander Schmemann’s explanation that the removal of the celebration of the Eucharist from the rite for second and third marriages “demonstrates the desacramentalization of the marriage, which is reduced to a natural form of happiness.”

This is not what Catholic advocates of changing the teaching on marriage want. I suppose they’d say that it’s the principle of oikonomia to which they’re really appealing, not Orthodoxy’s application of the principle in this case, but even if so, oikonomia does not justify the blanket approval of remarriage after divorce that they propose. Concessions require conditions and the conditions will necessarily be stringent and limit the number of people to whom the concession is made.

Catholicism & public life

Previous Post

May 27, 2014

Pope & Prime Minister Don't Argue, Which is Better News Than You Thought

Next Post

May 30, 2014 A Misunderstood Meal

Browse Our Archives

Select a Category Abortion & life American Life Anglican Affairs Apologetics Art and artistry Beer Capitalism's downside Catholic converts Catholic issues Catholicism & public life Catholicism in general Christianity & culture Christianity & the Jews Conservatism Conservative problems Death Do unto others Dogs Ecumenical friendship Evangelicalism Evil in the world Family Friendship Heroes How we should live Islam It's a funny old world Jews Judaism Israel Judaism justice Liberalism Life issues Marriage Mary Mass Media Modern culture good & bad Modern life as it is lived Modern Religion Mormonism People Personal reflections Politicians Protestantism Race Rand & Randiansm Secularisms Sexualities Society justice equality freedom The papacy & the pope Uncategorized Worship Writing & Language

Select a Month January 2015 December 2014 November 2014 October 2014 September 2014 August 2014 July 2014 June 2014 May 2014

TAKE THE

Religious Wisdom Quiz

What's the main theme of the Book of Job?

Select your answer to see how you score.

Genealogies Building a wall Why good people suffer Exile and return