Patheos

BuddhistCatholicContemplativeEvangelicalGeneral ChristianHinduJewishLatter-day SaintMuslimNew VisionsProgressive Christian

Beliefs

Topics

Columnists

Resource Library

Research Tools

Video

Podcasts

Thought Readers

Faith In Media Tracker

Newsletters

Ad-Free & Subscriber Log-In Subscription Support

Patheos

Ad-Free & Subscriber Log-In Subscription Support

Follow Patheos Patheos on Facebook Patheos on YouTube

davearmstrong

No Hell? Dialogue on Conditional Immortality, Pt. 3

Last updated on: September 30, 2026 at 8:46 pm   by Dave Armstrong

0 Comments

No Hell? Dialogue on Conditional Immortality, Pt. 3 2026-09-30T20:46:16-04:00 Dave Armstrong

LOGO Patheos Explore the world's faith through different perspectives on religion and spirituality! Patheos has the views of the prevalent religions and spiritualities of the world.

Photo credit: copyright 2026 by Catholic Bible Highlights.

See Part 1 and Part 2

This was underneath our video where we defended an eternal hell. My opponent was Matthew Flynn, an Adventist. His words will be in blue. I use RSV for Bible citations. The numbers here will correspond to Matthew’s original objection numbers in the first dialogue. This is the second part of the second round, and in the case of a few sections, there is also a round three back-and-forth. He replied to my original responses and I counter-replied to his.

*****

#10 I think that is a fair answer to the basic form of my question. The fact that a fate could resemble what Satan would desire does not by itself prove that God could not justly allow or impose it. So I’ll give you that point. I would only push back on a couple of things around it.

First, I’m not trying to “blame God” for human rebellion. The question is about the character of the judgment God ultimately gives, not who is responsible for the sin that led to judgment.

Second, I don’t think it is fair to suggest that conditionalists find ECT emotionally revolting and therefore go looking for biblical support for annihilationism. That may be true of some people, but it certainly isn’t an argument against the view, and it cuts both ways: prior theological commitments can influence how anyone reads difficult texts.

And to be fair, this particular question (#10) was more theological and philosophical than any of my others, so I can’t fault you for answering it on that level. My only objection is to the speculation about why conditionalists reject ECT. I may have invited a broader theological response with the way I framed the question, but I didn’t intend to suggest that my own conclusion is being driven by emotional revulsion rather than the biblical case I’m trying to make. So on the central point here, I think your answer is pretty solid. Thank you.

If you are asking questions about the character of God’s judgment, then it seems that you do have certain opinions about it before you get to the Bible, no? And if so, that clearly influences how you exegete the relevant passages, and it could have a bearing on your view of the Bible overall (as to its inspiration and inerrancy)

Yes; everyone is biased and we all have prior commitments. That’s a given. I merely asked you two questions two or three answers back that only require a simple yes or no answer. I don’t think that’s out of line. You just conceded that we all (or many of us, at least) have prior theological commitments. So I asked you if you do in two different respects. That doesn’t determine the outcome of our discussion (I agree), but it’s a relevant factor and not a complete non-issue.

Thanks for the compliments in your first and last paragraphs.

[he did adequately reply to these questions at the end of #8 in Part 2]

#11 I don’t think your answer to #9 quite answers what I was asking here. Your response there explains why you believe punishment is necessary, but #11 is a bit narrower about when justice is completed. And I don’t think that question rests on an arbitrary assumption that justice ought to have an endpoint. Scripture repeatedly portrays God’s final judgment as moving toward an accomplished result.

Paul says, “then comes the end,” when Christ brings every opposing rule, authority, and power to nothing, with death itself as the last enemy to be destroyed, so that ultimately “God may be all in all” (1 Corinthians 15:24–28). Revelation likewise moves through the final judgment and the lake of fire into the new creation, where “death shall be no more, neither shall there be mourning, nor crying, nor pain anymore,” followed by God’s declaration, “It is done” (Revelation 20:11–21:6).

So there really is biblical reason behind my question here. Scripture presents judgment, wrath, enemies, death, pain, and the whole conflict as moving toward a final resolution. Under ECT, however, the punishment of the wicked never reaches such a conclusion. A thousand years later it is still being inflicted. A trillion years later it is still being inflicted. There is never a point at which that aspect of judgment is finished.

And maybe your answer would be that ‘justice simply consists in an everlasting process of punishment that never reaches completion’, but I feel like that would sit awkwardly with the biblical pattern I mentioned above.

The Bible speaks of death being destroyed for those who are saved. We don’t have to be subject to spiritual death any longer. You seem to be using death in the sense of annihilation [as expected] and that’s never what either sense of it in the Bible means. I already addressed the passage about no more crying and pain, etc. It applies only to the elect saved, not the damned: and that’s absolutely clear in context.

We don’t have to totally understand everything God does, and we should never for a moment expect that we could or would. Hell is one of those deep mysteries that many people find hard to accept. I don’t like the idea much, myself. I don’t think anyone does. But I accept the truthfulness and justice of it because I see strong and compelling evidence that it’s what the Bible teaches. And I trust that God has perfectly moral and just reasons for this thing that is so difficult for us to grasp.

#12 I appreciate that you gave a direct answer here. But I think your own answer to #16 removes that possibility. There you said the unbeliever already “lacks spiritual life,” is already “in a state of spiritual death,” and that if this is not remedied, “it ends in hell.” So by the time of final judgment, there should be no spiritual life—not even a “semblance” or “remnant” of it—left to die.

If by “semblance or remnant of life with God” you mean spiritual life, your #16 says they already lack it. If you mean some different category of “life with God,” then I think that category needs to be identified biblically, because Revelation itself never introduces it.

For such a remnant to exist at the time of the lake of fire, there would have to be some mechanism by which spiritual life is restored, at least partially, after earthly death or at resurrection and judgment. But Scripture describes no such restoration, and by then their opportunity for reconciliation is already over.

Hebrews 9:27 gives the sequence: a person dies once, and after that comes judgment. Revelation 20 then shows the dead raised, standing before God, being judged, and only afterward being cast into the lake of fire, which John calls “the second death.”

Conditionalists simply see this described sequence and conclude that the most obvious thing alive immediately beforehand is the resurrected person. That is what dies—which also keeps “the second death” consistent with the Bible’s repeated descriptions of the wicked finally dying, perishing, being destroyed, consumed, and becoming no more.

Sinners can always achieve spiritual life by yielding to God, repenting, getting baptized, and devoting themselves to Jesus as Christian disciples. That’s what universal atonement means, and makes possible. It seems like you are almost denying that, but I don’t see how you could, if so.

Yes, there is no second chance after death, and purgatory is not that. Everyone there is saved and heavenbound with certainty.

I see no “repeated descriptions of the wicked finally dying, perishing, being destroyed, consumed, and becoming no more” because the words involved don’t mean what you claim they mean, as I have been painstakingly showing with heavy use of lexicons. I wanna get to where you start dealing with the texts that I bring up, but I have seven more answers to go first. Pretty soon this will be among the most lengthy dialogues I have ever been in.

#13 I think the main force I was pointing out is being missed here. The phrase “they know God’s righteous decree” makes Romans 1:32 much more significant than merely another occurrence of the word “death.”

Paul’s whole argument throughout the chapter is that God has made certain truths known even to fallen humanity (Romans 1:19–20), and then he concludes that they know God’s righteous decree that those who practice such things are worthy of death. So this penalty is presented as part of a divinely revealed moral reality that human beings can actually recognize.

That makes it difficult to redefine “death” here as eternal conscious torment. ECT is not something humanity naturally knows from creation or conscience; it is a very specific eschatological doctrine. In fact, you have already appealed to progressive revelation to explain why that doctrine becomes clearer only later. But if “death” in Romans 1:32 really means everlasting conscious existence in punishment, Paul would effectively be saying that fallen humanity already knows by divine revelation the very thing that supposedly required later revelation to make clear.

The force of the verse seems much more straightforward: humanity knows that sin deserves death. If a different fate is ultimately intended—conscious existence forever under punishment—then I think that requires some clear biblical demonstration instead of being placed inside the word “death.”

And what makes your response somewhat interesting is that many of the texts you cite for “everlasting” judgment actually seem to reinforce the distinction I’ve been making (especially regarding my response to #4): Ai becomes “forever a heap of ruins”; The enemy has “vanished in everlasting ruins”; God will “break you down forever” and “uproot you from the land of the living”; Edom’s smoke rises forever while the land lies waste; Babylon becomes an “everlasting waste,” “peopled no more forever”; Moab becomes like Sodom and Gomorrah, “a waste forever”. These are everlasting judgments, but their everlasting quality lies in the permanence of the result; ruin, removal, destruction, desolation. The city is not undergoing an endless process of being destroyed. Revelation 19 is especially striking: Babylon is judged, and her smoke rises “forever and ever.” Yet Babylon is not a conscious city being perpetually burned. Much of the evidence you supplied for everlasting judgment depicts exactly that kind of irreversible destructive outcome that Romans 1:32 says people know that sinners deserve.

Paul in Romans 1:19-20 says that mankind knows very little in the scheme of things about God: “his eternal power and deity, has been clearly perceived in the things that have been made.” That’s it. It hardly even gets to theology. Knowledge about hell would be very very far from what he stated here. Paul is not addressing that, it seems clear to me, whether it be true or false. He argues that folks know there is a God, on the basis of a sort of primitive argument from design (or teleological argument).

There are many explicit texts, as I have brought forward many times by now: many more than we have for many doctrines that we all accept (the virgin birth and original sin come immediately to mind).

You have a certain self-consistent interpretation of all the passages I produced this time, and I have one as well. That’s how it goes. There is no such thing as a clean slate. So I tried to answer your question in depth and I totally failed, as always. You don’t see what I see in those passages. You see what fits into your pre-existing framework of belief, and I do the same thing from my perspective.

It takes a ton of effort and soul-searching and intellectual work for anyone to have a major change of mind. I’ve done it several times in my life, by the way; most notably, moving from Protestant evangelical to Catholic.

#14 On #14, I think that fairly answers the question as I actually worded it. Your distinction is that Christ can be present because He is omnipresent while the damned are not in union with Him. I can see the coherence of that answer.

There was a broader concern behind my question—why the final state would involve Christ eternally present alongside continuing sin, rebellion, suffering, and hatred of Him—but looking back, I don’t think I stated that clearly enough in the question to fault you for not addressing it. So on #14 as written, I’ll give you the point.

Glad you liked my answer to #14!

#15 On #15, I’ll admit this one was doing a little more than directly arguing against ECT. I slipped it in partly because it presses on the broader dualist framework that usually accompanies ECT.

I agree with you that believers can participate in God’s glory even now, and that the resurrection brings the final transformation of the body. But my question was really about what happens to the believer’s remaining impurity between death and resurrection if that person is already consciously in God’s immediate presence.

Hebrews 12:14 says that without holiness no one will see the Lord, and Revelation 21:27 says nothing unclean enters His presence. Yet believers ordinarily die before sanctification is complete, while 1 Corinthians 15 and Philippians 3 place the final transformation at the resurrection.

So saying glorification is “ongoing” doesn’t quite identify the missing step. If the deceased believer is already fully fit for God’s presence before the resurrection, what happened at death to make that so? If there is some post-death purification or transformation, then that is the mechanism that would need to be established biblically.

But my question was really about what happens to the believer’s remaining impurity between death and resurrection if that person is already consciously in God’s immediate presence.

Catholics and a few selected Protestants here and there (like C. S. Lewis) say it is purgatory.

Revelation 21:27, in light of the entire chapter, is talking specifically about entering into heaven. So purgatory is perfectly consistent with it. We are purged of remaining sins and attachments to sins (concupiscence) so that we are “fit” to enter heaven. Revelation 22:15 reiterates the same thing. I collected 110 passages in support of purgatory, and I recently co-wrote a book about it, with my video channel partner, Kenny Burchard. I happened to write the chapter with the 110 passages.

#16 On #16, I think you have the better of this one as I framed it. Looking back at the passages together, I overstated the case by treating them as though they explicitly teach that God’s anger toward the unrepentant wicked can never endure forever. Your contextual point is fair for each.

That said, I do think these passages reveal something meaningful about God’s character, particularly that judgment is not something He delights in for its own sake, but I can see they do not by themselves establish the universal claim I built into the force of the question. I also see that there is still a separate question about the positive biblical basis for everlasting conscious wrath against the wicked, but that would be a different question, and I don’t want to move the goalposts after seeing your answer. So on #16 as I actually asked it, another point to you.

Thanks for accepting my answer to #16 as well! You’ve been very classy in conceding points. It’s a rare quality these days.

#17 My response for #17 here will be a bit longer just because of the control this verse is allowed to have for much of Christendom, reinforced by you saying “this verse alone undeniably [teaches ECT]”, so the reasons below [and from #12] are why I disagree. I think your response mostly restates Revelation 20:10 rather than answering the hermeneutical issue I was raising.

Your response mostly restates Revelation 20:10 as literalized and self-evident rather than answering the hermeneutical issue I was raising.

Interpreted prophetic visions in Scripture are not presented like someone is watching a camcorder recording or a VR experience of future events exactly as they will literally happen. They are visionary representations, often highly symbolic and sometimes impossible on a literal level, and then their meaning is explained. More importantly, wherever Scripture gives us enough information to look back from the interpretation to the vision, the same principle holds: the interpretation controls the imagery. Pharaoh sees seven lean cows devour seven fat cows, but Joseph tells him they represent seven years of famine following seven years of abundance. Daniel sees beasts, but the beasts are kingdoms. Nebuchadnezzar sees a huge metallic statue, but its parts represent successive empires. Revelation itself does this constantly. Lampstands are churches, bowls of incense are prayers, the dragon is Satan, and waters are peoples and nations.

Once the interpretation is supplied, we do not keep forcing the literal properties of the symbol back into the reality. Seven years of famine are not skinny cows. They do not have horns, walk out of the Nile, or swallow prosperous years. Those details belong to the picture. The interpretation tells us what the picture means.

Of course John sees the devil “tormented day and night forever and ever”. John communicates what he was shown in extraordinarily forceful imagery. But four verses later he tells us what the lake signifies: “This is the second death” (20:14). Then he says it again in 21:8: “the lake that burns with fire and sulfur, which is the second death.” Your reading reverses the normal direction. It takes one feature of the image, torment “day and night forever and ever,” and uses that feature to redefine John’s interpretation so that “second death” becomes everlasting conscious life in torment. In the interpreted visions that we can check retrospectively elsewhere in Scripture, the consistent pattern is that the interpretation controls the image, not the image controlling the interpretation.

If not, that would be like Pharaoh hearing Joseph explain that the seven lean cows meant seven years of famine and then deciding Egypt needed cattle guards along the Nile. It was vital for the survival of many nations that Pharaoh took the INTERPRETATION itself seriously instead of expecting to be confronted with literal cattle or sheaves. But this is effectively how you are treating Revelation 20:10.

“Second death” also needs to be allowed to actually mean something that makes sense. The wicked die once, are raised, stand before God alive again, are judged, and then undergo what John calls the second death. The sequence is straightforward: first death, resurrection, judgment, second death. I am not saying the two deaths have to be identical in every detail, but the word “second” plainly establishes some meaningful continuity with the first. The first death ends the embodied life that resurrection restores. On the ECT reading, to preserve the doctrine, the second death never ends that restored life at all. It becomes everlasting conscious life under different conditions, with second death forced to be referring to spiritual death, even though it isn’t an available category of death for wicked human subjects. That is precisely the interpretive move that needs to be demonstrated from the text.

I also do not think it works to say that I fail to understand this because I supposedly define physical death wrongly and already believe annihilationism. Annihilationism is the very conclusion under dispute. My holding that conclusion cannot itself be evidence that I am unable to understand yours. The same applies to what you’re calling soul sleep. Even if I granted for the sake of argument that people remain consciously alive between ordinary death and resurrection, that would not establish anything about what happens in the second death. Revelation 20 has the wicked raised, standing before God alive, judged, and only afterward entering the lake. Whatever happened during the intermediate state tells us nothing about what the second death does to the resurrected person.

Calling it “[spiritual] second death” does not establish that identification either. John only calls it the second death. If the claim is that this means an already spiritually dead person continues consciously forever in hell, that interpretation has to come from the text. In fact, by your own earlier definition, unbelievers already lack spiritual life and abide in spiritual death before final judgment. Revelation never describes spiritual life being restored at resurrection so that they can then become spiritually dead a second time. So identifying the second death as simply spiritual death is already not supported by Scripture, but it creates another problem rather than solving one.

Likewise, saying that the second death “IS hell” does not settle the dispute. If by “hell” you simply mean the lake of fire, then of course we agree that the second death is the lake of fire. The disagreement is over what the lake ultimately does. If “hell” is already defined as everlasting conscious torment, then saying “the second death is hell” simply puts ECT into the definition and gives the conclusion back as the argument. Each step of your chain of “second death = spiritual death = eternal conscious torment” is exactly what still needs to be demonstrated from Scripture, not assumed as the reason I supposedly cannot comprehend the passage.

Is it of no concern to you at all that hell has always been the mainstream view for 2000 years, and is held by Catholics, Orthodox, and the vast majority of Church fathers and Protestants? Doesn’t that give you the slightest doubt or pause that your view might be mistaken? This gets into the role of apostolic succession and an authoritative tradition and Church, in addition to the Bible.

When the Church fathers defended a position, they appealed to the Bible first and foremost. Then they ALSO noted the fact that “this is what has always been believed and passed down and what has been authoritatively declared by the Church [in council or by a pope]”. It was the three things together, not just the Bible. All of the folks who followed sola Scriptura were the heretics who denied the divinity of Christ, etc. The Arians were Bible Alone folks because they didn’t have a history they could appeal to.

The “second death” (Rev 2:11; 20:6, 14; 21:8) is defined twice in the last two passages as the lake of fire, which is hell. You seem to agree with that, but then go on to say that this lake simply annihilates human beings. But this doesn’t take into account the “torment” passages:

Revelation 14:10-11 he also shall drink the wine of God’s wrath, poured unmixed into the cup of his anger, and he shall be tormented with fire and sulphur in the presence of the holy angels and in the presence of the Lamb. [11] And the smoke of their torment goes up for ever and ever; and they have no rest, day or night, . . .

Revelation 20:10 and the devil who had deceived them was thrown into the lake of fire and sulphur where the beast and the false prophet were, and they will be tormented day and night for ever and ever. (cf. human beings added to it in 20:15)

The use of “no rest” and “day and night” accentuates the endless duration, along with “for ever and ever.” I donp;t see how it could be any more plain than it is. The element of “torment” and “anguish” and “flame” in hell is also anticipated by the rich man’s experience in the “bad” and unpleasant part of Hades:

Luke 16:22-24, 28 . . . The rich man also died and was buried; [23] and in Hades, being in torment, he lifted up his eyes, and saw Abraham far off and Laz’arus in his bosom. [24] And he called out, `. . . I am in anguish in this flame.’ . . . [28] ‘. . . this place of torment.’

Each step of your chain of “second death = spiritual death = eternal conscious torment” is exactly what still needs to be demonstrated from Scripture, . . .

I think I just did that above and I’m pretty sure that I had already done this.

The other things thrown into the lake reinforce the conditionalist’s point. Death and Hades themselves are thrown into it. Neither is a conscious creature capable of torment. Paul says the last enemy to be destroyed is death, and Revelation shortly afterward says “death shall be no more.” So the lake clearly can represent abolition rather than conscious preservation.

The wider biblical language fits that interpretation very naturally too. The beast “goes to destruction” in Revelation 17, and Daniel’s corresponding beast is killed, its body destroyed, and given to the fire. Hebrews 2:14 speaks of Christ defeating or rendering powerless the devil who held the power of death, and Romans 16:20 says God will “crush Satan.” Human beings are described as having both soul and body destroyed in Gehenna, suffering “eternal destruction,” having destruction as their end, and facing fire that “will consume the adversaries.” Even immediately before the lake of fire scene, fire comes down from heaven and devours God’s enemies in Revelation 20:9.

None of those verses has to carry the whole case by itself. The point is that when John calls the lake “the second death,” he is speaking in a way that fits the Bible’s wider language of destruction, consumption, defeat, and abolition very naturally. Eternal conscious preservation is the additional interpretive step.

Whatever force every feature of the visionary imagery carries, the imagery is still subordinate to its inspired interpretation. But that said, even the strongest expressions in the vision have biblical roots that emphasize the enormity and permanence of judgment without forcing an endless process. Babylon’s smoke rises “forever and ever,” yet Babylon has been decisively overthrown and “will be found no more.” That echoes Isaiah 34, where Edom’s smoke rises forever even though Edom is not literally still burning. Likewise, “day and night” is language of unrelenting activity. Revelation can describe service to God “day and night” and later say that in the final creation “night will be no more.” These expressions make the vision severe, total, and irreversible, but they are still features of the visionary representation. They do not override the interpretation John supplies.

Permanence is not the issue here. Conditionalism fully affirms an eternal and irreversible punishment. The issue is what is permanent. John names the result as the second death. We do not need to explain every visual feature before accepting the interpretation Scripture itself provides. Daniel was troubled by visions he did not fully understand. Zechariah repeatedly asked what the things he saw meant. Revelation itself repeatedly interprets symbols for us. The symbol does not get to overrule the interpretation simply because one feature of the symbol is especially vivid.

And I think something else gets badly overlooked in these discussions. Conditionalism does not make judgment painless, trivial, or somehow allow the wicked to escape accountability. It can affirm real anguish under God’s wrath and an unimaginably severe final loss. Being destroyed “both soul and body” in Gehenna is not a soft punishment. More importantly, what is lost is eternal life itself. Scripture presents eternal life as an extraordinary gift given through Christ, not as something every human possesses automatically. The condemned lose the kingdom, resurrection glory, communion with God, access to the tree of life, and an everlasting future. Treating that loss as though it were somehow not serious enough risks taking the preciousness of Christ’s gift for granted.

So I do not think Revelation 20:10 can simply be quoted as “undeniable” proof of ECT. That assumes the very interpretive move I was challenging. It treats the surface imagery almost like literal footage, then allows that imagery to redefine the inspired interpretation John gives four verses later. The consistent biblical method is to read the vision as a vision, let the inspired interpretation control the imagery, even after that we can recognize that its strongest expressions still communicate total and irreversible judgment, notice how naturally “second death” fits Scripture’s wider language of destruction and abolition, and then let “the second death” actually remain coherent and mean that it says.

Once that method is followed, I do not see an exegetical basis for turning John’s explicit interpretation, death, into what looks like its opposite. If Revelation 20:10 is going to carry as much doctrinal weight as ECT places on it, that multi-interpretive step to literalize the imagery of an interpreted vision + use that imagery against a different category of beings not mentioned with the imagery, needs to be demonstrated from Scripture. Simply quoting the vision itself does not demonstrate it.

The other things thrown into the lake reinforce the conditionalist’s point. Death and Hades themselves are thrown into it. Neither is a conscious creature capable of torment.

Barnes’ Notes on the Bible comments on Revelation 20:14:

The idea is, that death, considered as the separation of soul and body, with all the attendant woes, will exist no more. The righteous will live forever, and the wicked will linger on in a state never to be terminated by death. The reign of Death and Hades, as such, would come to an end, and a new order of things would commence where this would be unknown. There might be what would be properly called death, but it would not be death in this form; the soul would live forever, but it would not be in that condition represented by the word ᾅδης hadēs – “hades.” There would be “death” still, but a “second death differs from the first, in the fact that it is not a separation of the soul and body, but a state of “continual agony” like what the first death inflicts – like that in intensity, but not in kind” (Prof. Stuart).

This is the second death – That is, this whole process here described – the condemnation, and the final death and ruin of those whose names are “not found written in the book of life” – properly constitutes the second death. This proves that when it is said that “death and hell were cast into the lake of fire,” it cannot be meant that all punishment will cease forever, and that all will be saved, for the writer goes on to describe what he calls “the second death” as still existing. See Revelation 20:15. John describes this as the second death, not because it in all respects resembles the first death, but because it has so many points of resemblance that it may be properly called “death.” Death, in any form, is the penalty of law; it is attended with pain; it cuts off from hope, from friends, from enjoyment; it subjects him who dies to a much-dreaded condition, and in all these respects it was proper to call the final condition of the wicked “death” – though it would still be true that the soul would live. There is no evidence that John meant to affirm that the second death would imply an extinction of “existence.” Death never does that; the word does not naturally and properly convey that idea.

Paul says the last enemy to be destroyed is death, and Revelation shortly afterward says “death shall be no more.”

Yes, the first (bodily) death will be no more.

So the lake clearly can represent abolition rather than conscious preservation.

I don’t see how, since it’s called the “second death” and it entails torment “day and night” and “forever” etc. It amazes me how anyone could take such a view in light of the explicit nature of the descriptions.

The beast “goes to destruction” in Revelation 17, and Daniel’s corresponding beast is killed, its body destroyed, and given to the fire.

Daniel was at an early stage of development. You have conceded the aspect of progressive revelation. So he just has the beast go into the fire. Revelation expands and develops what happens after he enters it:

Revelation 19:20 the beast was . . . thrown alive into the lake of fire that burns with sulphur.

Revelation 20:10 . . . the beast . . . will be tormented day and night for ever and ever.

Romans 16:20 says God will “crush Satan.”

Being tormented forever and ever is certainly crushing him.

Human beings are described as having both soul and body destroyed in Gehenna, suffering “eternal destruction,” having destruction as their end

The word for “destroy” is apollumi, which means, according to W. E. Vine’s Expository Dictionary of New Testament Words, “not extinction, but ruin, loss, not of being, but of well-being.” The other verses in which it appears make this meaning clear (Mt 10:6; Lk 15:6, 9, 24; Jn 18:9). In Thayer’s Greek-English Lexicon, apollumi (ἀπόλλυμι) in the context of Matthew 10:28 (which I think you are alluding to) is defined metaphorically as “to devote or give over to eternal misery”.

Babylon’s smoke rises “forever and ever,” yet Babylon has been decisively overthrown and “will be found no more.” That echoes Isaiah 34, where Edom’s smoke rises forever even though Edom is not literally still burning.

Cities can end forever, but that’s not sufficient to help us understand the eternal destinies of human beings, who are eternal. I can’t keep repeating myself over and over. I’ve made my arguments from the Bible. So you can have the “last word” as to many of your statements in this section.

I have no problem with an important doctrine resting heavily on one verse. If one verse actually supports the claim being made, one verse is enough. And I understand that in systematic theology, one passage can legitimately become increasingly important as other passages are interpreted in light of it.

That is effectively what happened with Revelation 20:10 throughout our discussion. More and more of the specifically conscious-and-endless component of ECT was ultimately being supplied by, or anchored to, that verse. That is not unusual in itself, but it does mean the verse has to be strong enough to bear the weight being placed on it.

That is why #17 became so important. I spent more time there because I think there is a serious hermeneutical problem with the standard reading of this interpreted prophetic vision, and I tried to make that issue as clear as possible with the biblical examples and the Pharaoh analogy. I don’t want to repeat the argument a third time; it is already above.

What I’m still looking for is direct engagement with that specific point. If the hermeneutical principle I laid out is wrong, show me where. If Revelation 20 should be handled differently from the other interpreted visions I cited, explain why.

Quoting Barnes doesn’t answer the point, because Barnes simply reads “second death” through the traditional ECT framework and tells us what it must mean within that framework. That may show how an ECT interpreter harmonizes the passage, but it does not answer the prior question I was raising about whether the imagery should be allowed to control and redefine John’s supplied interpretation in the first place.

Likewise, pointing again to “tormented day and night forever and ever” does not yet answer the objection, because the interpretive role of that very imagery is what I was questioning.

Since so much of the discussion has progressively converged on Revelation 20:10, I think this is probably the most important unresolved point between us. I’m very open to the possibility that you have a strong answer to how this verse is a special case; I just haven’t seen that particular argument addressed yet.

***

Interpreted prophetic visions in Scripture are not presented like someone is watching a camcorder recording or a VR experience of future events exactly as they will literally happen. They are visionary representations, often highly symbolic and sometimes impossible on a literal level, and then their meaning is explained.

Pharaoh sees seven lean cows devour seven fat cows, but Joseph tells him they represent seven years of famine following seven years of abundance. Daniel sees beasts, but the beasts are kingdoms. Nebuchadnezzar sees a huge metallic statue, but its parts represent successive empires. Revelation itself does this constantly. Lampstands are churches, bowls of incense are prayers, the dragon is Satan, and waters are peoples and nations.

I don’t see how Revelation 20:10 (“the beast . . . will be tormented day and night for ever and ever”) and similar passages can be regarded as “highly symbolic and sometimes impossible on a literal level” because — as I have been contending — there are too many relevant cross-references that don’t allow it to become non-literal (else the Bible would contradict itself). Hell is presented as a very real place in Scripture, and the lake of fire is obviously the same thing as hell with a different title (very common in Scripture, as you know).

But you will reject all that. Very well, then, the surrounding context also suggests a literal meaning, because the next five verses are devoted to the great white throne judgment. Will you claim that that is merely symbolic, too? God’s judgment? If you take 20:11-12 literally, then it seems to me that you also have to do the same with 20:13-15, which refer to death and Hades being thrown into the lake of fire, and anyone whose name wasn’t in the book of life. That’s all judgment, and it’s quite literal. Therefore, going back to 20:10, in context, and seeing that it is the same subject matter and theme, the devil being tossed into the lake of fire is the literal event of his judgment, and being “tormented day and night for ever and ever” is as well.

Moreover, I asked AI: “do Adventists think the great white throne judgment in revelation is a literal event?” It answered, using SDA sources:

Yes, Seventh-day Adventists believe the Great White Throne Judgment is a literal, future event that will take place at the end of the 1,000-year millennium.

While Adventists acknowledge that the Book of Revelation uses highly symbolic language—such as the “books” representing God’s flawless memory and omniscience—they teach that the timeline and physical occurrence of this judgment are concrete realities.

According to Seventh-day Adventist eschatology, the event unfolds through the following literal stages:

• The Timing: It takes place at the conclusion of the millennium. At this time, Christ and the redeemed descend to Earth inside the New Jerusalem, and the “wicked dead” (unbelievers from all human history) are raised in the second resurrection.

• The Gathering: Satan rallies this resurrected global host to make a final, desperate assault on the Holy City. As they surround the city, the Great White Throne appears visibly in the heavens above.

Note that the last item is considered to be a literal event, and this is referring to Revelation 20:8-9, right before the passage under consideration. So the immediate context, both before and after 20:10, is completely literal, according to SDA theology. Yet you would have us believe that 20:10 becomes symbolic in the middle of all of these literal events? It makes no sense.

So that’s two replies for you: one from systematic theology and the other from exegesis and context. You would more or less be forced, in a reductio ad absurdum, to symbolize the literal final judgment. There are many real events in Revelation, too. It’s not all symbolic. Judgment Day is one of them, and the scenes of worship in heaven are, I submit, another example. There will be a new Jerusalem, too: heaven.

#18 On just #18: I’ve already granted that Scripture can metaphorically describe living sinners as “dead”; what I have never granted is that this establishes a separate category of death whose literal meaning is everlasting conscious existence separated from God.

Because your answer, and whole ECT doctrine really, seems to require exactly that category. If the wicked are resurrected and then consciously exist forever, the “second death” cannot mean the loss of the life restored at resurrection. It has to mean something entirely different: a state in which a person remains conscious and alive forever, yet is still called “dead” because he is separated from God.

But the passages you cited do not establish that creation of a new category. They simply show that Scripture can speak of sinners as “dead” while physically alive. Which isn’t the same thing as teaching that death itself is an everlasting conscious state. I’d even say that several of your own texts read much more naturally as describing death as the consequence toward which sin leads:

Romans 6:16 says sin “leads to death.”

Romans 6:21 says “the end of those things is death.”

Romans 6:23 says “the wages of sin is death.” James 1:15 says sin “brings forth death.”

James 5:20 says turning a sinner back will “save his soul from death.”

That is a remarkebly consistent pattern– sin leads to death, ends in death, earns death, produces death, and the sinner can be saved from death. There is no need to create another species of death in which the sinner remains consciously alive forever.

John 5:24 fits this naturally too. Jesus says the believer has already “passed from death to life,” yet only a few verses later He still speaks of the future resurrection when those in the graves will come forth (5:28–29). So the final resurrection from death has not already happened. The future reality is being spoken of as present because the believer’s destiny has changed.

John does the same with judgment. John 3:18 says the unbeliever is “condemned already,” yet a future judgment still remains. Present condemnation anticipates the final execution of judgment. In the same way, a sinner can presently “abide in death” because he remains under the power and destiny of death, without “death” being redefined as everlasting conscious existence.

That reading is also so much simpler. On ECT, the wicked die, are resurrected back to life, stand before God alive, are judged, undergo the second death, and yet never actually lose the life resurrection restored. To preserve that interpretation, “death” has to become a new category meaning everlasting conscious alienation. But this really is never actually demonstrated.

So back to the question #18 itself that points out life for one group and no life for the other. ECT instead gives both groups endless conscious existence, then qualifies the everlasting existence of one group as “spiritual death” so they can live forever while still being said not to have life.

So I grant the metaphorical use of “dead” for living sinners. What I do not grant is the further move from that metaphor to a separate category of death in which someone consciously lives forever. The simpler reading is that sinners are presently under death and heading toward the consequence Scripture repeatedly says lies at the end of sin, actual death.

**

There is no need to create another species of death in which the sinner remains consciously alive forever.

What I do not grant is the further move from that metaphor to a separate category of death in which someone consciously lives forever.

Whether there is a “need” or not according to you, the Bible itself does “move” and do this, in its terminology of “second death”: four times (Rev 2:11; 20:6; 20:14 and 21:8 = lake of fire). If we’re gonna argue what the Bible teaches, and abide by its inspired authority, we have to accept it when it clearly teaches a category, as in this case. I’ve already painstakingly made the case for “spiritual death” too, as a biblical concept.

#19 On #19: Before getting into these passages, I think there is a recurring misunderstanding worth clearing up. I have never argued in this exchange that apollumi lexically means “annihilate” or “cease to exist.” When you interpreted my earlier use of “cessation” that way, I explicitly clarified that I meant the cessation/loss of life, not metaphysical nonexistence.

So substituting “annihilated” into every occurrence of apollumi and showing that it sounds absurd with lost sheep, wineskins, etc. rebuts a claim I have never made, because of course apollumi has a semantic range. Pointing that out isn’t a point for your side. The range is only relevant to help in determining which sense fits the particular context.

As an illustration of my point, take the English word run. It can mean to jog, operate a business, flow, etc. If I say, “He ran five miles around the track,” and someone replies, “Run doesn’t have to mean jog, because ‘she runs a company’ would become ‘she jogs a company,’ and ‘the river runs through town’ would become ‘the river jogs through town,’” that would prove nothing.

Worse, if the context is explicitly about a man moving around a track for five miles, appealing to “run a business” or “a river runs” actually distracts from the lexical question. The fact that run can mean something else elsewhere does not weaken the obvious sense selected by this context.

That is essentially what happens when lost sheep and ruined wineskins are brought in to answer Matthew 10:28. Those examples establish that apollumi does not have one rigid English equivalent in every occurrence. I think all of Christendom agrees here. They do not tell us what Jesus means when He contrasts human beings who can kill the body but cannot kill the soul with God, who can destroy both soul and body in Gehenna. That judgment context has to be interpreted on its own escalation terms.

So my argument will never be that “apollumi means annihilate”, no informed conditionalist ever says this. My argument is about what destruction means here (especially with the supplied perfect side-by-side illustration of the first and second deaths), together with the cumulative biblical picture formed by death, destruction, perishing, consuming, devouring, burning up, becoming no more, and finally the second death.

Briefly on some of the other passages mentioned:

Psalm 37:20: You say abad “simply means to die,” and then define death through your anthropology as separation of soul and body. But the Psalm itself gives us its own imagery: “the wicked perish,” the enemies of the Lord are like the glory of the pastures, and “like smoke they vanish away.” The context sounds much more like disappearance/destruction than everlasting conscious preservation.

2 Thessalonians 1:9: I affirm “eternal destruction.” Further, the word olethros does not have to lexically mean “annihilation” for the verse to support my argument. The question is whether the destruction is an eternally ongoing process of ruination or a destruction with an eternal result. As we already discussed with “eternal salvation” and “eternal redemption,” the adjective by itself does not decide that. Saying “ruin, not extinction” simply imports the disputed conclusion into the gloss. And including “eternal” to modify destruction here does some real work in removing universalism from possibility.

Hebrews 10:27: This one is especially straightforward: the author describes “a fury of fire which will consume the adversaries.” That is the actual image he chose. Then in v.39 he contrasts shrinking back “to destruction” with faith resulting in the preservation of the soul. Destruction versus preservation is a very natural contrast. Explaining the destruction as the eternal preservation of the person in misery seems to reverse the force of that contrast rather than explain it.

Philippians 3:18–19: Paul calls them “enemies of the cross of Christ” and says “their end is destruction.” “Their end” is particularly significant. Whatever semantic range apōleia has, Paul chooses destruction as the endpoint of Christ’s enemies, then immediately contrasts them with believers whose bodies Christ will transform in glory.

And that brings me back to the passage your answer did not really address–1 Corinthians 15:24–28. Paul is describing the final consummation, not merely using one destruction word in isolation. Christ reigns until all His enemies are placed beneath His feet; “the last enemy to be destroyed is death”; then comes the end, and finally God is “all in all.”

That is the larger argument behind #19. Scripture repeatedly says the wicked perish, are destroyed, consumed, have destruction as their end, and undergo the second death. Then Paul portrays the consummation as Christ bringing every enemy under His feet and finally destroying death itself.

Under ECT, however, God’s human enemies remain consciously existing forever, and the condition you call “spiritual death” also remains forever. So I still do not see how the final victory described by Paul has actually eliminated either the enemies or death. They have both been made everlasting.

At this point I’m increasingly just repeating myself. I made most of the arguments I can make, especially involving word meanings. We keep disagreeing on the fundamental premises and definitions of words, which makes it hard to move forward and gives the dialogue more of a “spinning car wheels in the mud” feeling. But I’ll include all of your words in my three-part blog paper (not to worry).

But (to at least address one thing) 1 Corinthians 15 is also exclusively about believers, not the reprobate (or all men). This is massively indicated:

15:1 . . . brethren, . . . the gospel, which you received, in which you stand,

15:2 . . . you are saved, if you hold it fast . . .

15:11 . . . so we preach and so you believed.

15:19 . . . we have hoped in Christ . . .

15:53 For this perishable nature must put on the imperishable, and this mortal nature must put on immortality.

[I’ve already addressed how “immortality” is different from “eternity” and applies only to believers]

15:58 Therefore, my beloved brethren, be steadfast, immovable, always abounding in the work of the Lord, knowing that in the Lord your labor is not in vain.

#20 Because of the “cross-reference” implications you’ve repeatedly placed on this verse, this one is especially important. I don’t think this answers the main force of #20. I’m not assuming Revelation is strictly chronological. I’m asking what judgment John is describing in 14:9–11, and the immediate literary evidence points strongly to chapters 15–16.

The subjects are the same: 14:9 identifies those who worship the beast and receive his mark; 16:2 identifies those “who bore the mark of the beast and worshiped its image.” The wrath is the same: 14:10 announces the wine of God’s wrath poured from His cup; 15:1 says the seven last plagues complete God’s wrath, 15:7 gives the angels bowls full of that wrath, and 16:1 commands them to pour it out. The fire-based suffering is then actually depicted in 16:8–9, where these people are scorched, consciously suffer, blaspheme God, and refuse to repent.

Those details have an obvious REASON for being introduced in 14:9–11 if John is announcing what he is about to depict in 15–16. By contrast, Revelation 20:10 does not mention the beast-worshiping humans, their mark, a cup/bowl of wrath, or its being poured out. It shares broader imagery like fire/sulfur and torment, but 15–16 shares the actual identifying details.

Even “in the presence of the Lamb” does not uniquely locate 14:10 in the lake of fire. Revelation 6:15–17 already depicts earthly judgment as the “wrath of the Lamb.” So that is not a marker pointing specifically to Revelation 20 either.

This is why I think the standard ECT reading of 14:9–11 requires several assumptions that the text itself does not state:

1. The specifically identified beast-worshipers represent all the wicked. The passage itself repeatedly limits its subjects to those who worship the beast and receive his mark.

I didn’t do that. I stated the same thing you said: “anyone who ‘worships’ the beast and receives a mark indicating so.”

2. This scene is the final lake-of-fire judgment. The passage never mentions the lake of fire, second death, resurrection, white-throne judgment, or final state. That identification has to be supplied from elsewhere.

Okay, but there are several elements in common, too, making it not implausible to hold that the two passages are describing the same thing. The name is no more necessary for equation than “Trinity” is for that doctrine (it never appears in the Bible), or “virgin birth” and “original sin” for those two beliefs. What matters is the concept and actuality expressed. But here are four comparisons:

Revelation 14:9-11 And another angel, a third, followed them, saying with a loud voice, “If any one worships the beast and its image, and receives a mark on his forehead or on his hand, [10] he also shall drink the wine of God’s wrath, poured unmixed into the cup of his anger, and he shall be tormented with fire and sulphur in the presence of the holy angels and in the presence of the Lamb. [11] And the smoke of their torment goes up for ever and ever; and they have no rest, day or night, these worshipers of the beast and its image, and whoever receives the mark of its name.”

14:10 tormented with fire and sulphur

20:10 the lake of fire and sulphur

19:20 the lake of fire that burns with sulphur

21:8 the lake that burns with fire and sulphur

Three times in Revelation we read about this lake that has both fire and sulphur. A fourth time the same words appear, but it happens not to use the word “lake.” That doesn’t disprove that they are the same thing. There are still four major elements in common, as I am presently showing. It’s like three accounts in the synoptic gospels where they are describing the same incident, but one of three doesn’t mention a word that the other two do, and another one doesn’t include a different word that the other two have. This is the same thing. By considering all the passages together, one can arrive at, I submit, a very likely equation

14:11 the smoke of their torment goes up for ever and ever

20:10 they will be tormented . . . for ever and ever.

14:11 they have no rest, day or night

20:10 tormented day and night

Also, we know that the beast ends up in the lake of fire, from 20:10 and 19:20, so it stands to reason (a plausibility or common sense argument) that his followers who made him their idol would end up in the same place and be “tormented with fire and sulphur.”

3. “The smoke of their torment goes up forever” means the people themselves remain consciously tormented forever. But Revelation 19:3 uses the same everlasting-smoke language of Babylon, which 18:21 says will be “found no more,” echoing Isaiah 34’s everlasting smoke from destroyed Edom. Permanent smoke imagery does not automatically equal permanently conscious sufferers.

This is the same failed analogy to ancient judged cities again. Cities are not people. They don’t live eternally, and a judgment of a city is not at all essentially the same as a judgment of an individual.

4. The immediate continuation into chapters 15–16 is not what the warning is primarily describing. Yet that continuation gives us the same people, same mark, same wrath, same pouring imagery, same angelic administration, and fire-based suffering. That seems like a very large amount of textual evidence to set aside before jumping six chapters and over 1000 years forward.

Maybe; or maybe I’m right. It’s not a matter of absolute certainty, and neither view stands or falls on it. If “lake of fire” isn’t present here, it certainly is in other passages, and its equation with hell is based on lots of direct comparisons.

Your answer effectively handles assumption #2 by appealing to Revelation 20:10. Even more, throughout this discussion Revelation 14 and 20 have repeatedly supplied the element other passages do not themselves state. But if Revelation 14 itself gets that meaning from Revelation 20:10, then an extraordinary amount of the positive ECT case you have presented ultimately hangs on one verse.

Many important doctrines “hang on” just a few verses, or maybe even sometimes one, or no explicit ones or only indirect deductions based on many taken together. But one or two are more than enough if they are clear and “perspicuous” enough. It’s not always quantity, but what is expressed.

And that verse is itself inside a prophetic vision explicitly interpreted as the second death. That is why #17 becomes so important. If Revelation 20:10 is being mishandled by allowing one feature of an interpreted prophetic image to redefine John’s interpretation, “the second death,” then Revelation 14 loses its supposed independent support too.

I like what Barnes’ Notes on the Bible states about 14:11:

For ever and ever – See the notes on Jde 1:7. This does not indeed affirm that their individual sufferings would be eternal, since it is only a declaration that “the smoke of their torment ascends,” but it is such language as would be used on the supposition that they would suffer forever, and as can be explained only on that supposition. It implies that their torments continued, and were the cause of that ascending smoke; that is, that they were tormented while it ascended; and, as this is declared to be “forever and ever,” it implies that the sufferings of the wicked will be eternal: and this is such language as would not, and could not have been used in a revelation from God, unless the punishment of the wicked is eternal. Compare the notes on Matthew 25:46.

I like what he says about Jude 1:7 too. He compares to Sodom and Gomorrah, but in a way consistent with the eternal hellfire and punishment view:

Jude 1:7 just as Sodom and Gomor’rah and the surrounding cities, which likewise acted immorally and indulged in unnatural lust, serve as an example by undergoing a punishment of eternal fire.

Suffering the vengeance of eternal fire – The word rendered “suffering” (ὑπέχουσαι hupechousai) means, properly, “holding under” – as, for example, the hand; then to hold toward any one, as the ear – to give attention; then it is used as denoting to hold a discourse toward or with any one, or to hold satisfaction to any one, to make atonement; and then as “undergoing, paying, or suffering punishment,” when united, as it is here, with the word δίκην dikēn (punishment, or vengeance). . . . Here it expresses the idea of undergoing punishment. The word properly agrees in the construction with “cities,” (πόλεις poleis,) referring to Sodom and Gomorrah, and the cities around them; but the things affirmed relate to the “inhabitants” of those cities. The word “vengeance” means punishment; that is, such vengeance as the Lord takes on the guilty; not vengeance for the gratification of private and personal feeling, but like that which a magistrate appoints for the maintenance of the laws; such as justice demands. The phrase “eternal fire” is one that is often used to denote future punishment – as expressing the severity and intensity of the suffering. See the notes, Matthew 25:41. As here used, it cannot mean that the fires which consumed Sodom and Gomorrah were literally eternal, or were kept always burning, for that was not true. The expression seems to denote, in this connection, two things:

(1) That the destruction of the cities of the plain, with their inhabitants, was as entire and perpetual as if the fires had been always burning – the consumption was absolute and enduring – the sinners were wholly cut off, and the cities forever rendered desolate; and,

(2) that, in its nature and duration, this was a striking emblem of the destruction which will come upon the ungodly. I do not see that the apostle here means to affirm that those particular sinners who dwelt in Sodom would be punished forever, for his expressions do not directly affirm that, and his argument does not demand it; but still the “image” in his mind, in the destruction of those cities, was clearly that of the utter desolation and ruin of which this was the emblem; of the perpetual destruction of the wicked, like that of the cities of the plain. If this had not been the case, there was no reason why he should have used the word “eternal” – meaning here “perpetual” – since, if in his mind there was no image of future punishment, all that the argument would have demanded was the simple statement that they were cut off by fire.

The passage, then, cannot be used to prove that the particular dwellers in Sodom will be punished forever – whatever may be the truth on that point; but that there is a place of eternal punishment, of which that was a striking emblem. The meaning is, that the case was one which furnished a demonstration of the fact that God will punish sin; that this was an example of the punishment which God sometimes inflicts on sinners in this world, and a type of that eternal punishment which will be inflicted in the next.

And let’s check out his comment on Matthew 25:41 too:

Matthew 25:41 Then he will say to those at his left hand, `Depart from me, you cursed, into the eternal fire prepared for the devil and his angels; (cf. 25:46: “eternal punishment”)

Ye cursed – That is, you who are devoted to destruction, whose characters deserve everlasting punishment, and who are about to enter into it. “To curse” is the opposite of “to bless.” It implies a negation of all the blessings of heaven, and a positive infliction of eternal sufferings.

Everlasting fire – “Fire,” here, is used to denote punishment. The image is employed to express extreme suffering, as a death by burning is one of the most horrible that can be conceived. The image was taken, probably, from the fires burning in the Valley of Hinnom. See the notes at Matthew 5:22. It has been asked whether the wicked will be burned in literal fire, and the common impression has been that they will be. Respecting that, however, it is to be observed:

  1. that the main truth intended to be taught refers not to the manner of suffering, but to the certainty and intensity of it.

  2. that the design, therefore, was to present an image of terrific and appalling suffering – an image well represented by fire

  3. that this image was well known to the Jews Isaiah 66:24, and therefore expressed the idea in a very strong manner.

  4. that all the truth that Christ intended to convey appears to be expressed in the certainty, intensity, and eternity of future torment.

  5. that there is no distinct affirmation respecting the mode of that punishment, where the mode was the subject of discourse.

  6. that to us it is a subject of comparatively little consequence what will be the mode of punishment.

#21 On #21: The central issue (and point this question is making) is that your reading needs “death” in Romans 6 and “perish” in John 3 to mean something like everlasting “spiritual death,” while the immediate contexts strongly point toward the ordinary death-versus-life contrast.

You say Paul mentions “spiritual death many times,” but I think that strongly assumes the framework being argued for. I agree that Scripture can metaphorically describe living sinners as “dead.” What I do not see is Paul repeatedly identifying a distinct final category called spiritual death, defined as conscious existence forever separated from God. In many of the texts you list, Paul simply says sin leads to death, produces death, or has death as its end. Calling all of those “spiritual death” first and then citing them as evidence that Paul teaches spiritual death risks becoming circular.

Once again, you demand that certain terms have to be present in a way that the Bible doesn’t. The concept can be there without the word. I already gave several examples, which are not circular reasoning. They are reasonable prooftexts for the view I am defending, which is Christian orthodoxy. I asked AI, “where is the notion of ‘spiritual death’ found in Scripture?” Here’s what it gave me:

While the exact phrase “spiritual death” does not appear in most English translations, the theological concept is explicitly found throughout Scripture. In biblical terms, death is framed primarily as separation rather than a cessation of consciousness. Spiritual death is defined as humanity’s separation and alienation from God due to sin.

The primary scriptural foundations for this concept span across both the Old and New Testaments.

  1. The Genesis Narrative (The Origin)

The concept originates in the Garden of Eden:

Genesis 2:17: God warns Adam, “for in the day that you eat of it you shall surely die.”

Genesis 3:7-8: When Adam and Eve disobeyed, they did not drop dead physically that day. Instead, they immediately hid from God’s presence and were cast out of Eden. This instant severing of communion represents the entry of spiritual death into human history.

  1. The Pauline Epistles and Gospels

The concept is further detailed in Paul’s letters and the teachings of Jesus, where individuals who are physically alive are described as spiritually unresponsive or dead to God. Key passages include Ephesians 2:1 and 5 (“dead in trespasses and sins”), Colossians 2:13, Romans 6:23 (the wages of sin), and Ephesians 4:18 (alienated from the life of God). Jesus similarly references this state in statements like “leave the dead to bury their own dead” (Luke 9:60), transitioning “from death to life” (John 5:24), and the Prodigal Son being “dead, and is alive again” (Luke 15:24). Additional New Testament references appear in 1 Timothy 5:6 and 1 John 3:14.

Summary Contrast

Scripture outlines a progression of death:

Spiritual Death: Separation of the human soul/spirit from God in this life (e.g., Ephesians 2:1).

Physical Death: Separation of the soul/spirit from the physical body.

The Second Death: Eternal, permanent separation from God (e.g., Revelation 20:14).

Romans 6:21–23 is especially difficult for that reading because Paul gives two final outcomes: “the end of those things is death,” versus sanctification whose end is eternal life. The fact that believers also undergo the first death does not answer this; Christians can die and subsequently receive eternal life through resurrection. The issue is the ultimate outcome Paul is contrasting.

I asked AI: “how does BDAG define “death” in Romans 6:21 and 6:23?” The reply:

In the BDAG (Bauer-Danker Greek-English Lexicon of the New Testament), the Greek word for death (θάνατος / thanatos) in Romans 6:21 and Romans 6:23 is categorized under its second main definition.

Specifically, BDAG defines it as:

Definition 2: “Death viewed transcendently in contrast to a living relationship with God.”

Sub-category (b): “Eternal death.”

BDAG explicitly cites both Romans 6:21 and Romans 6:23 under this sub-category, grouping them along with other passages that speak to the ultimate destiny or consequence of sin (such as Romans 1:32, Romans 6:16, and the “second death” in Revelation). This stands in direct contrast to sub-category (a), which BDAG uses for “spiritual death” experienced while still biologically alive (e.g., John 5:24, Romans 8:6).

Thayer’s Greek-English Lexicon defines thanatos in this passage:

In the widest sense, death comprises all the miseries arising from sin, as well physical death as the loss of a life consecrated to God and blessed in him on earth (Philo, alleg. legg. i. § 33 ὁ ψυχῆς θάνατος ἀρετῆς μέν φθορά ἐστι, κακίας δέ ἀνάληψις (de profug. § 21 θάνατος ψυχῆς ὁ μετά κακίας ἐστι βίος, especially §§ 10, 11; qued det. pot. insid. §§ 14, 15; de poster. Cain. § 21, and de praem. et poen. as in 2 above)), to be followed by wretchedness in the lower world (opposed to ζωή αἰώνιος): θάνατος seems to be so used in Romans 5:12; Romans 6:16, 21 (Romans 6:23; . . .

Then, immediately after “the wages of sin is death,” Romans 7:1–3 uses ordinary biological death in the continuing argument: the husband dies, and death ends the former relationship. That does not prove conditionalism by itself, but it is strong contextual evidence against simply assigning 6:23 to a specialized category of everlasting conscious “spiritual death.” ”

Yes, but there are contextual references to spiritual death, too:

6:13 . . . yield yourselves to God as men who have been brought from death to life . . .

7:9-11 I was once alive apart from the law, but when the commandment came, sin revived and I died; [10] the very commandment which promised life proved to be death to me. [11] For sin, finding opportunity in the commandment, deceived me and by it killed me.

7:13 Did that which is good, then, bring death to me? By no means! It was sin, working death in me through what is good,

7:24Wretched man that I am! Who will deliver me from this body of death?

8:6 To set the mind on the flesh is death, but to set the mind on the Spirit is life and peace.

John 3 is even clearer contextually. Jesus first invokes the bronze serpent in Numbers 21. The Israelites were dying; those who looked lived, and those who did not died. He then says that in the SAME WAY (“even so” in KJV) He will be lifted up so that believers have eternal life, immediately followed by the contrast between perishing and having eternal life. This is a controlling analogy Jesus Himself is using.

So in both passages, the immediate context gives us strong reasons to understand the contrast as death/loss of life versus life. Quoting Vine afterward that apollumi means “loss of well-being” does not answer Jesus’ analogy; it supplies the theological interpretation that still needs to be established.

And I’ll say it again, I am not claiming that “death” or apollumi lexically means “cease to exist.”

John 3:14-15 And as Moses lifted up the serpent in the wilderness, so must the Son of man be lifted up, [15] that whoever believes in him may have eternal life.

This is a classic instance of Jesus making a comparison to a physical event in the OT (people were dying physically and the serpent helped them live) and expanding it to a more spiritual, expansive application. Because He was to be “lifted up” men would also have eternal life. The converse holds, too, I think, by simple deductive logic. Those who didn’t have recourse to the serpent died physically; those who reject the “solution” of Jesus die spiritually and eternally.

Spiritual death (or “darkness”) appears again in context:

John 3:19-20 And this is the judgment, that the light has come into the world, and men loved darkness rather than light, because their deeds were evil. [20] For every one who does evil hates the light, and does not come to the light, lest his deeds should be exposed.

Jesus often spoke of spiritual death in this life as “darkness” (Mt 6:23; Lk 11:34-35; Jn 8:12; 12:35, 46), as do also the Gospel writers (Mt 4:16; Lk 1:79; Jn 3:19) and Paul (Acts 26:18; Rom 2:19; 13:12; 2 Cor 6:14; Eph 5:8, 11; 6:12; Col 1:13; 1 Thess 5:5), and Peter (1 Pet 2:9) and John in his First Epistle (2:8-9, 11). This is but one description of spiritual death.

Jesus expanded upon this “darkness” in the present life and extended it to the afterlife with the phrase, “outer darkness” (Mt 8:12; 22:13; 25:30).

Peter did the same sort of typically Hebraic comparison as Jesus’ serpent analogy:

1 Peter 3:20-21 who formerly did not obey, when God’s patience waited in the days of Noah, during the building of the ark, in which a few, that is, eight persons, were saved through water. [21] Baptism, which corresponds to this, now saves you, not as a removal of dirt from the body but as an appeal to God for a clear conscience, through the resurrection of Jesus Christ,

Just as Jesus did, he refers to being saved from physical death through water (the Flood) and moves to an assertion that the waters of baptism save us by regenerating and setting us on the path to eternal life in heaven.

My narrower point is that your framework repeatedly takes language that naturally describes death as the consequence and endpoint of sin, places it into a separate category you (and many others) call “spiritual death,” and then uses that category to make the same passages compatible with everlasting conscious existence.

Yes, because the content of the Bible and the necessity of harmonizing it, require this. It’s systematic theology, and can’ be avoided. I just did a little illustration of it in my survey of the use of the word “darkness” for spiritual death.

That is the step I still need to see established from the texts themselves.

It looks like you’re not gonna see it because I’ve given you plenty of proofs. But the fact remains that the vast majority of Christians through history and today do see what I see in these texts — indeed consider it fairly obvious — , which is why it has always been the mainstream and orthodox view.

But if definitions of key words like “death” are changed and the premises are different, a whole view can be built on top of them. But it’s no better than the strength of the initial premises and definitions, and that’s where the greatest weakness of your position lies, in my opinion. It’s why I keep citing the lexicons against you (the Greek experts on what these words mean, in each instance) and you either blow that off or try to give more counter-examples without addressing squarely what the Greek (or Hebrew) experts tell us about the definitions and meanings.

Everyone, it’s true, does interpret in accordance with their existing worldview or belief-system. It’s unavoidable. But we have to still try to be as objective as we can when doing exegesis. I believe we’re both making our best effort to do that. But the existing framework will always strongly influence our conclusion in any given case.

I see you and others of the same view in this combox making remarks about how I can’t change my mind because Catholicism won’t allow it. But that’s not that different from any religious belief-system; all require adherence to various tenets. Calvinists must believe in TULIP; Baptists in non-sacramental adult, believer’s baptism, Lutherans in baptismal regeneration, Pentecostals in speaking in tongues and the continuance of all the spiritual gifts, etc. It’s only a matter of degree. Likewise, even your conditional immortality view already has very definite “lines” that its adherents basically cannot cross in exegesis, lest they cease to hold the view and be part of the “club.” It’s true of any belief-system (atheists, Marxists, radical feminists, etc.). I see it all the time in my work.

So basically, you can’t change very much at all unless you radically modify your premises and presuppositions; not all that different from where I sit within Catholic (and larger Christian) orthodoxy. No verse is “good enough” to prove ECT to you, just as none is good enough for me to adopt the view of annihilationism. We both give our reasons why, but never the twain shall meet, so it seems.

It’s still fun dialoguing, at any rate . . .

#22 I think your answer actually grants the point of #22. You say Jeremiah’s “perpetual sleep” is poetic language for Babylon’s irreversible destruction, “never to rise again.” Exactly. So perpetual-duration language does not necessarily describe an activity consciously continuing forever; it can describe the permanence and irreversibility of the resulting state.

That’s how you see it in your framework because you insist on it being a direct analogy. I now assert for, I think, the fourth time, that it’s not: destruction of cities is not the same thing as judgment of individual persons. So the fact that Babylon, Edom et al are destroyed forever and no longer exist is not an argument for annihilationism. It’s apples and oranges, as I think I described it way back when . . . But E for effort . . .

That was the whole point of the comparison with Revelation. I was not claiming Jeremiah 51 and Revelation 20 are identical passages. I was challenging the rule that “forever” attached to judgment imagery must mean the subject is consciously experiencing the depicted action forever.

Fair enough. I already conceded some examples of your sense, but they by no means wipe out the other sense.

There is also a very interesting Jewish interpretive connection here. The Targum of Jeremiah paraphrases both Jeremiah 51:39 and 51:57 — “sleep a perpetual sleep and not wake” — as essentially “they shall die the second death and shall not live in the world to come.

I would not use the Targum to prove that John necessarily borrowed its interpretation, especially since the Targum’s final form is later. But it is striking evidence that Jewish interpreters could connect this exact “perpetual sleep / never wake” language with the second death and exclusion from the life of the age to come, rather than with an endless conscious process.

They could simply be wrong (not being inspired).

So I think #22 has actually been conceded: the word “perpetual” can describe an irreversible judgment whose effect never ends, even though the activity represented by the image is not consciously occurring forever. And rather remarkably, the later Jewish interpretation of this very passage actually calls that irreversible fate “the second death.” 

I haven’t conceded it, and made a robust counter-reply, I think, but if it make you feel better to think that I did, feel free! :-) :-)

#23 This misses the force of #23. I am not asking whether the lake is called “the second death.” I am asking why “second death” should mean a condition Genesis explicitly calls “living forever.”

As plainly as I can show it… God Himself in Genesis 3:22: fallen human + endless conscious embodied existence = live forever. ECT doctrine: fallen human + endless conscious embodied existence = second death.

The problem is that ECT asks me to call “death” a condition God Himself calls “living forever.” That is the conflict this particular question points out.

I already replied and have nothing to add.

#24 On #24, I think you have a fair point about the immediate context. Revelation 21:4 is talking about the redeemed (v3 makes that clear), so I think I pushed that verse farther than I should have in the way I worded the question. I do still think there is a bigger problem for the idea that death ultimately means separation from God, because Revelation has Death itself being thrown into the lake of fire, and Paul calls death the last enemy to be destroyed. If the wicked remain forever in a condition that is itself called “death,” then in what sense is death actually gone? But I’ll leave that as the broader issue rather than pretend #24 by itself is a point for me.

And since that gets us through all 24, I really do want to thank you for actually doing this. I threw 24 questions at you that you weren’t expecting, and you answered every one of them. You put a lot of time into this, kept coming back, answered counterpoints, and were willing to keep the discussion going even when it got ridiculously long. I wish there were more like you that felt like being a strong apologist of what you believe in any sense was important enough to dedicate the time into it.

I also appreciate that you mostly stayed on the biblical argument I was actually asking about. There were places where I thought you missed the force of a question, and obviously a lot of places where I still think your answer depends on assumptions I don’t grant, but there were also places where you gave a good answer and I was happy to say so. I think that is how this stuff should work. If I ask 24 questions and come away thinking I won all 24, I probably wasn’t listening very well.

I also appreciated what you said about the way I’ve handled the discussion. That was generous, and I can return a lot of that feelling. You have been willing to spend an absurd amount of time interacting with someone who strongly disagrees with you, and you’ve clearly put real thought into defending your position.

If anything, I think this whole exchange has helped me see more clearly where the main disagreement actually is. You think the immortal-soul / spiritual-death framework is already established well enough that all the death, destruction, perishing, second-death language has to be understood inside that framework. I keep coming back to whether the texts actually establish that framework in the first place, rather than just being made compatible with it after the fact. I suspect that is probably the biggest reason we keep talking past each other in some places. I will certainly spend some extra time looking into that.

I also hope, even if none of this changed your mind, that it at least helped you understand the conditionalist case a little better and why we read some of these passages the way we do. A lot of the time conditionalism gets reduced to “they just don’t like the idea of hell” or “they redefine the obvious texts,” and hopefully this discussion showed there is a lot more biblical argument behind it than that.

Anyway, I definitely did not expect this to turn into whatever this has become when I posted those 24 questions. But I’m glad it did. Thanks again for taking them seriously and putting this much effort into the discussion.

Thanks for the very kind words. It’s been a real pleasure. I do indeed understand your perspective a lot better and have as much respect for it as I can for anything that I believe to be dead-wrong. You do have lots of biblical arguments and I can see how they might be persuasive if one grants the premises that are behind them (which I don’t). And I return a compliment you gave me: you’ve put tons of thought into defending your position, and that’s commendable. We disagree, but I appreciate anyone who seriously grapples with the biblical texts, and who thinks.

*

I complimented you in a reply to someone else here, too:

It’s a fabulous and super-substantive dialogue. . . . I had also done a 17-part reply on the same issues about four years ago, which we linked to in the description for the video. That person (Lucas Banzoli, a Brazilian Protestant apologist with SDA-type beliefs), fled for the hills — after lobbing innumerable insults and claiming that he would refute all my arguments point-by-point — and was never heard from again. My present dialogue opponent is infinitely more classy and has won my respect, for his meticulous argumentation, having the courage of his convictions, and his never-failing gentlemanly demeanor. It’s a great pleasure to dialogue with him.

Much appreciated :)

*

[writing to a fellow conditional immortalist on the thread] To Dave’s credit, I do think he is engaging me in good faith. He has taken the questions seriously, came at this on my biblical perspective, and spent an enormous amount of time responding to them. . . . I’m very grateful Dave has been willing to engage this deeply (such a rare thing for respectful civility on topics this polarizing). It has forced me to sharpen a lot of my own arguments. And if this discussion causes even one person to recognize how biblically robust the case for Conditional Immortality actually is — even if they do not become a conditionalist, but simply stop treating the position as some obvious heresy that can be dismissed without serious engagement — I’ll be very pleased with that.

See Part 1 and Part 2

***

Photo credit: copyright 2026 by Catholic Bible Highlights.

*

Summary: 2nd round in a dialogue with an Adventist on 24 mostly biblical arguments in favor of annihilationism or conditional immortality, which denies the existence of an eternal hell.

*
***
*

Practical Matters:  This is the most comprehensive and multi-faceted Catholic apologetics blog: rated #1 for Christian sites by leading AI tool, ChatGPT. I offer more than 5,000 free online articles, fifty-nine books, and many scores of videos at the Catholic Bible Highlights YouTube channel (please subscribe!). If you believe my full-time apostolate is worth supporting, please seriously consider financially supporting it. PayPal donations are the easiest: just send to my email address: [email protected]. You’ll see the term “Dave Armstrong Bookstore”. To learn about the different methods of contributing (including Zelle and 100% tax-deductible donations if desired), see my page: About Catholic Apologist Dave Armstrong / Donation Information. Thanks a million!

*

***

*

Hell & Satan & Last Things

annihilationism

conditional immortality

eternal punishment

Gehenna

Hell

lake of fire

Previous Post



September 30, 2026

No Hell? Dialogue on Conditional Immortality, Pt. 2

Next Post



October 2, 2026 Top Ten Anti-Catholic Lies (#10-7)

Recent Comments

0 | Leave a Comment

"Special pleading, and not a serious response to my arguments . . ."

Dave Armstrong


Is Venerating Men & Angels Worship? ..."

""no man needs to teach us."Didn't you just teach us?"

Dave Armstrong


Is Venerating Men & Angels Worship? ..."

""Catholics say they are the only church that can lead people into heaven."In fact, we ..."

Dave Armstrong


Is Venerating Men & Angels Worship? ..."

"And lastly, I belong to no denomination and am free to serve God as He ..."

Mariah


Is Venerating Men & Angels Worship? ..."


Browse Our Archives

Select a Category & Last Things About Me Anti-Catholicism Atheism & Agnosticism Baptism and Sacramentalism Bible and Tradition Blessed Virgin Mary Books by Dave Armstrong C. S. Lewis Calvinism & General Protestantism Catholic Apologetics Catholic Apologists Catholic conversion Catholic converts Christmas Church (Ecclesiology) Church History Conversion and Converts Development of Doctrine Eastern Orthodoxy Ecumenism & Christian Unity Eucharist & Liturgy Fathers of the Church French Translations G. K. Chesterton Hell Hell & Satan Hell & Satan & Last Things Heresies & Comparative Religion Holistic Health Inquisition & Crusades & Scandals James White Jews & Judaism & Old Testament John Calvin John Henry Newman Liberal / Modernist Theology Life Issues Literary Resume Lutheranism Mariology Martin Luther Music Orthodoxy Papacy & Infallibility Personal Page Philosophy & Science Political & Ethical & Moral Issues Protestant Persecution & Intolerance Protestantism Purgatory Purgatory & Penance Romantic & Imaginative Theology Saints & Purgatory & Penance Salvation Salvation & Justification Satan & Last Things Sexuality and Gender Issues Spanish Translations Traditionalism vs. Radical Catholic Reactionaries Traducciones al español / tradução para português Trinitarianism & Christology Uncategorized Videos

Select a Month November 2026 October 2026 September 2026 August 2026 July 2026 June 2026 May 2026 April 2026 March 2026 February 2026 January 2026 December 2025 November 2025 October 2025 September 2025 August 2025 July 2025 June 2025 May 2025 April 2025 March 2025 February 2025 January 2025 December 2024 November 2024 October 2024 September 2024 August 2024 July 2024 June 2024 May 2024 April 2024 March 2024 February 2024 January 2024 December 2023 November 2023 October 2023 September 2023 August 2023 July 2023 June 2023 May 2023 April 2023 March 2023 February 2023 January 2023 December 2022 November 2022 October 2022 September 2022 August 2022 July 2022 June 2022 May 2022 April 2022 March 2022 February 2022 January 2022 December 2021 November 2021 October 2021 September 2021 August 2021 July 2021 June 2021 May 2021 April 2021 March 2021 February 2021 January 2021 December 2020 November 2020 October 2020 September 2020 August 2020 July 2020 June 2020 May 2020 April 2020 March 2020 February 2020 January 2020 December 2019 November 2019 October 2019 September 2019 August 2019 July 2019 June 2019 May 2019 April 2019 March 2019 February 2019 January 2019 December 2018 November 2018 October 2018 September 2018 August 2018 July 2018 June 2018 May 2018 April 2018 March 2018 February 2018 January 2018 December 2017 November 2017 October 2017 September 2017 August 2017 July 2017 June 2017 May 2017 April 2017 March 2017 February 2017 January 2017 December 2016 November 2016 October 2016 September 2016 August 2016 July 2016 June 2016 May 2016 April 2016 March 2016 February 2016 January 2016 December 2015 November 2015 October 2015 September 2015 August 2015 July 2015 June 2015 May 2015 April 2015 March 2015 February 2015 January 2015 December 2014 November 2014 October 2014 September 2014 August 2014 July 2014 June 2014 April 2014 March 2014 February 2014 January 2014 December 2013 November 2013 October 2013 September 2013 August 2013 July 2013 June 2013 April 2013 March 2013 February 2013 January 2013 December 2012 November 2012 October 2012 September 2012 August 2012 July 2012 June 2012 May 2012 April 2012 March 2012 February 2012 January 2012 December 2011 November 2011 October 2011 September 2011 August 2011 July 2011 June 2011 April 2011 March 2011 February 2011 October 2010 September 2010 August 2010 July 2010 April 2010 March 2010 December 2009 October 2009 August 2009 July 2009 June 2009 May 2009 March 2009 February 2009 October 2008 September 2008 April 2008 March 2008 February 2008 January 2008 December 2007 November 2007 October 2007 May 2007 March 2007 February 2007 January 2007 November 2006 October 2006 September 2006 August 2006 July 2006 June 2006 May 2006 April 2006 March 2006 February 2006 October 2005 June 2005 April 2005 February 2005 July 2004 May 2004 April 2004


Follow Us!

Follow Us on Facebook Follow Us on Twitter



TAKE THE

Religious Wisdom Quiz

What did God rest from on the seventh day?

Select your answer to see how you score.

Creating light Creating the world Creating the animals Creating the sea

Books by This Author Books by Dave Armstrong

See All Titles »

Related posts from Biblical Evidence for Catholicism

Family

No Hell? Dialogue on Conditional Immortality, Pt. 2

Biblical Evidence for Catholicism

Family

No Hell? Dialogue on Conditional Immortality

Biblical Evidence for Catholicism

Family

Eternal Hell: Biblical? 25 Verses Say So

Biblical Evidence for Catholicism

Family

1 Thessalonians 4 = Rapture? (vs. Patrick O'Brien)

Biblical Evidence for Catholicism

TRENDING AT PATHEOS Catholic

Will Trump & the Democrats Moderate or Double...

The big political question now after the midterm elections is what will...

Lincoln City and Cathedral-- Part Two

This cathedral is in many ways like Yorkminster in its size, scope,...

Wilford Woodruff (1807-1898), returned for a visit in...

  This article, written by Maurine Proctor and no doubt inspired by...

We Are Discipled Into What We Can See

Earlier this week I had the joy of sitting down with Vanessa...

What Keeps Sinners From Changing Their Lives?

What could possibly keep sinners from changing their lives? Could it be...

Long strings of words, ready-made

"It consists in gumming together long strips of words which have already...

view all Catholic blogs

What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment

Patheos on Facebook Patheos on YouTube

Ad-Free & Subscriber Log-In Subscription Support

Copyright 2008-2026, Patheos. All rights reserved.

Subscription Support Ad-Free & Subscriber Log-In

Follow Patheos Patheos on Facebook Patheos on YouTube