Patheos

BuddhistCatholicContemplativeEvangelicalGeneral ChristianHinduJewishLatter-day SaintMuslimNew VisionsProgressive Christian

Beliefs

Topics

Columnists

Resource Library

Research Tools

Video

Podcasts

Thought Readers

Faith In Media Tracker

Newsletters

Ad-Free & Subscriber Log-In Subscription Support

Patheos

Ad-Free & Subscriber Log-In Subscription Support

Follow Patheos Patheos on Facebook Patheos on YouTube

davearmstrong

Dialogue: Sharp Inquiring Protestant vs. Pope-Bashing Catholic

Last updated on: March 6, 2018 at 2:33 pm   by Dave Armstrong

Dialogue: Sharp Inquiring Protestant vs. Pope-Bashing Catholic 2018-03-06T14:33:56-04:00 Dave Armstrong

LOGO Patheos Explore the world's faith through different perspectives on religion and spirituality! Patheos has the views of the prevalent religions and spiritualities of the world.

[the following is a fictional dialogue, but carefully based on existing widespread opinions about the pope. The lifelong Catholic’s words will be in blue. The Protestant (ecumenical and highly educated) is seriously considering becoming a Catholic, after about six months of intensely studying the Catholic faith and Church history. The two men meet over donuts and coffee after Mass and strike up a conversation]

***

Hi. Are you new here?

Yes! I’ve been coming to Mass for about 6-7 weeks now.

You’re not a Catholic? Or are you just new to the area?

I’m an evangelical Protestant who has a lot of respect for the Catholic Church. I’m considering its truth claims and a possible conversion down the road.

That’s wonderful! Welcome to our parish!

Thank you.

If you don’t mind me asking: what is it that led you to consider becoming Catholic?

I don’t mind at all. The issue of authority is the main issue for me. Our principles of sola Scriptura and acceptance of rampant denominationalism in Protestantism (which I no longer find to be very biblical: all the sectarianism and in-fighting) have not exactly brought about much unity and doctrinal clarity. So I have thought a lot about these issues and related ones.

Those things are indeed troubling. We have our own share of problems, too, with bad bishops and theological liberalism and modernism that can creep into our teachings. And of course you have heard about the sex scandals . . . 

Any Christian group can have bad apples, and we’re all sinners, right? Original sin . . . Sexual sin is by no means confined to Catholics (or, for that matter, to men who take vows of celibacy). 

Sure. I agree.

But what impresses me so much about the Catholic Church is the way it has of resolving conflicts once and for all: sort of like “the buck stops here.”

We do have sacred tradition and the Catechism and ecumenical councils.

And you have the pope! The chair of Peter: passed down through succession. I’ve been studying about it and it’s incredible to me.

Well, yes, we do have a pope, too [he says reluctantly, with a half-grimace].

I’m not convinced yet, but the notion of the infallible pope, protected by the Holy Spirit from error, is intriguing and very appealing to me, and I’m close to accepting it as both biblical and verified by Church history. But I won’t accept it unless and until I am persuaded that it is true and God’s intention for His Church.

That’s good. Perhaps you should study other things, too. You don’t want to concentrate too much on the papacy.

Why?! It’s one of the most striking and appealing factors about the Catholic Church.

Well [pausing and wondering how to express himself in the right way] . . . it’s not the papacy itself that is the problem, but the current occupant of the office.

What?! I’m very surprised to hear that. Pope Francis is well-loved. All my friends have a lot of respect for him. What is it that you object to about him?

Well, to cut to the quick (I don’t have a lot of time), he is teaching falsehood: the idea that cohabiting couples having sexual relations outside of marriage are welcome to Holy Communion.

[shocked and wide-eyed] But you believe popes are infallible, right? 

Yes; under specific conditions.

And that they couldn’t lead the flock astray. As I have learned, the Catholic Church believes itself to be inde . . . what is the word?

“Indefectible.”

Yes, that’s it. I also understand that Catholics believe the pope couldn’t positively teach error that would bind Catholics to believe: that the Holy Spirit would prevent that.

I hope you’re right.

“Hope”? That is the teaching, isn’t it? I’m confused . . .  Why would you be worried about him teaching error? 

One must distinguish between things he says that aren’t infallible, and things that are.

Okay; I’ve read about that. So you are concerned about things he has said in plane interviews and some such (off-the-cuff stuff), but not in official documents?

Not just that . . . he has taught error in one of his encyclicals, called Amoris Laetitia.

I don’t see how you could think that. Wouldn’t it be contrary to indefectibility? What did he say? Where is it in the document?

I can’t give you a quote. I think it’s in a footnote somewhere. But it is destroying the traditional teaching on who can receive Holy Communion and on the indissolubility of marriage.

If you are convinced of such a serious matter taking place, wouldn’t it be of the first importance to have a direct quote from the pope, and to show how it is heretical or erroneous (whatever the proper term is)?

I suppose. But so many people are saying this. I didn’t think it was necessary to look it up.

Numbers of people believing in something doesn’t make it true. That’s called the ad populum fallacy (I took logic in college). Believe me, we know the inadequacy of counting heads (especially theologians’ heads) in Protestantism. We do that all the time. I don’t see how such a strong claim can be made against the pope without absolutely rock-solid, undeniable evidence. Have you even read defenses of the pope against such extraordinary charges. Surely they exist.

No. I couldn’t find any.

[shocked again] They must be out there somewhere, and it’s so easy to search with Google. I’ve always sought to read both sides of a dispute. You never get the whole truth reading only one side. But how ironic, now that I come to think of it. I am defending the pope and you are accusing him of heresy!

I didn’t say “heresy.” I used the words “error” and “falsehood.” 

But wouldn’t it amount to the same thing?

The problem is that we can’t figure out what Pope Francis believes because he contradicts himself. He seems to talk out of both sides of his mouth. He’s being deliberately ambiguous.

How would you prove such a charge? I’ve heard certain Catholics make the claim about Vatican II as well. That amounts to saying that he is lying through his teeth, and is a deliberate deceiver, and would be logically absurd any way you look at it, because if the pope teaches something orthodox, then the critics simply say he is deceiving and not giving his true opinions.  Therefore, he can never prove that he is orthodox, because it is discounted from the outset. No evidence or proof can ever be sufficient. The outcome of the “investigation” is determined before it begins. That’s what we call circular reasoning, and it’s a form of the fallacy of “poisoning the well” too.

It’s not irrational. A long, sad accumulation of evidences for over four years has led many of us to this sad conclusion.

Wasn’t Jesus constantly falsely accused, too? They said He had a demon and so forth . . . 

Yes.

So how do you know that the pope is not also being falsely accused? Jesus said we’d all be hated for His name’s sake. The devil’s big success is to divide and conquer. We’re in an age of polarization. People don’t talk to each other when they disagree. Wouldn’t it be possible to simply “tune in” to all the charges and perhaps some gossip and innuendo, and if one never heard anything else (like watching TV talk shows that only have one political point of view), to simply uncritically accept everything one hears?

I suppose.

It sounds like this is going on in the Catholic Church. But it would amount to mere propaganda, right? 

No! The evidence is too strong, and too varied.

But you yourself said that you couldn’t even give me a single quotation from this document that proves that he is teaching falsehood.

I don’t have to. It’s what he does!

Don’t the theological liberals (or dissidents) try to change and redefine doctrines all the time: things always held that they no longer believe? We know about that in Protestantism, too!

Yes they do.

And so you have decided that Pope Francis is such a liberal?

Yes.

But not based on anything he has actually taught? How is that not merely a subjective argument from silence: not to mention a form of conspiratorialism?

It’s not just laypeople like me and Raymond Arroyo. Four bishops protested and asked him questions that he hasn’t answered.

How many bishops are there altogether?

I think maybe 3,000? [the actual number is 5,100]

3,000, and only four have questioned the pope directly? That’s a miniscule number . . . why would that impress you? If things were so dire, wouldn’t the bishops speak up en masse?

Well . . . [stumbles around for a cogent reply, but can’t come up with one].

Again, I’m struck by the irony. I’m the Protestant, who is looking and longing for strong authority. You have that in the Catholic Church, yet you say that so many people are questioning Pope Francis’ authority, and some believe he is even a heretic: and has asserted non-traditional falsehood in one of his official documents: which is close — at least in spirit — to defectibility (if not technically so)! 

From this (your) perspective, why would you say I should become a Catholic? It seems to me that if I were in your shoes, I’d be even more confused and unsure than I am now!

Maybe you shouldn’t.

I shouldn’t?! But at the beginning of our conversation you thought it was “wonderful” that I was considering conversion to the Catholic faith. I’m beginning to believe more and more that the Catholic Church is the fullness of the faith, and you seem to believe that less and less. But if you can’t even trust the pope, then it seems to me that you need to seriously ponder the implications of your opinions.

Maybe so. I don’t feel very joyous or at peace as a Catholic.

You should! You have such treasures in the Catholic Church (like the pearl of great price). You don’t know how blessed you are. In fact, in dialoguing with you, I have virtually convinced myself that I need to become a Catholic. I shall talk to Father about it at the earliest opportunity.

[increasingly agitated and animated] And maybe I should become a Protestant or “do a Rod Dreher” and become Orthodox. That way I won’t have to deal with this pope whom I despise, and all the nonsense going on now. I’m sick and tired of it. When all else fails: there is always Anglicanism.

[the Protestant stares at him for a very long moment with a look and thoughts of equal parts befuddlement and compassionate pity. He realizes he is late meeting someone and must leave, and walks off dazed and utterly astonished at what he has heard. Yet, oddly enough, he is more convinced than ever that the Catholic Church is the fullness of faith, and that God is leading Him to it. He knows enough to know (having read Galatians and 1 and 2 Corinthians) that individual Catholics and their level of faith and consistency (or lack thereof) do not determine the truth or falsity of ecclesiological claims.]

***

Photo credit: Image by Muhammad Rafizeldi (11-3-13) [Wikimedia Commons / Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 Unported license]

***

Papacy & Infallibility

Catholic dissidents

communion for divorced & remarried

dissenters

Heterodoxy

Indefectibility of the Church

infallibility of the Church

Lost Shepherd: How Pope Francis is Misleading His Flock

modernism

Phil Lawler

progressives

quasi-defectibility

Radical Catholic Reactionaries

sacred tradition

Theological Liberalism

Previous Post



March 5, 2018

Sinning Christians: Catholic vs. Protestant Approaches

Next Post



March 6, 2018 Dialogues w Critics & Disparagers of Pope Francis


Browse Our Archives

Select a Category & Last Things About Me Anti-Catholicism Atheism & Agnosticism Baptism and Sacramentalism Bible and Tradition Blessed Virgin Mary Books by Dave Armstrong C. S. Lewis Calvinism & General Protestantism Catholic Apologetics Catholic Apologists Catholic conversion Catholic converts Christmas Church (Ecclesiology) Church History Conversion and Converts Development of Doctrine Eastern Orthodoxy Ecumenism & Christian Unity Eucharist & Liturgy Fathers of the Church French Translations G. K. Chesterton Hell Hell & Satan Hell & Satan & Last Things Heresies & Comparative Religion Holistic Health Inquisition & Crusades & Scandals James White Jews & Judaism & Old Testament John Calvin John Henry Newman Liberal / Modernist Theology Life Issues Literary Resume Lutheranism Mariology Martin Luther Music Orthodoxy Papacy & Infallibility Personal Page Philosophy & Science Political & Ethical & Moral Issues Protestant Persecution & Intolerance Protestantism Purgatory Purgatory & Penance Romantic & Imaginative Theology Saints & Purgatory & Penance Salvation Salvation & Justification Satan & Last Things Sexuality and Gender Issues Spanish Translations Traditionalism vs. Radical Catholic Reactionaries Traducciones al español / tradução para português Trinitarianism & Christology Uncategorized Videos

Select a Month November 2026 October 2026 September 2026 August 2026 July 2026 June 2026 May 2026 April 2026 March 2026 February 2026 January 2026 December 2025 November 2025 October 2025 September 2025 August 2025 July 2025 June 2025 May 2025 April 2025 March 2025 February 2025 January 2025 December 2024 November 2024 October 2024 September 2024 August 2024 July 2024 June 2024 May 2024 April 2024 March 2024 February 2024 January 2024 December 2023 November 2023 October 2023 September 2023 August 2023 July 2023 June 2023 May 2023 April 2023 March 2023 February 2023 January 2023 December 2022 November 2022 October 2022 September 2022 August 2022 July 2022 June 2022 May 2022 April 2022 March 2022 February 2022 January 2022 December 2021 November 2021 October 2021 September 2021 August 2021 July 2021 June 2021 May 2021 April 2021 March 2021 February 2021 January 2021 December 2020 November 2020 October 2020 September 2020 August 2020 July 2020 June 2020 May 2020 April 2020 March 2020 February 2020 January 2020 December 2019 November 2019 October 2019 September 2019 August 2019 July 2019 June 2019 May 2019 April 2019 March 2019 February 2019 January 2019 December 2018 November 2018 October 2018 September 2018 August 2018 July 2018 June 2018 May 2018 April 2018 March 2018 February 2018 January 2018 December 2017 November 2017 October 2017 September 2017 August 2017 July 2017 June 2017 May 2017 April 2017 March 2017 February 2017 January 2017 December 2016 November 2016 October 2016 September 2016 August 2016 July 2016 June 2016 May 2016 April 2016 March 2016 February 2016 January 2016 December 2015 November 2015 October 2015 September 2015 August 2015 July 2015 June 2015 May 2015 April 2015 March 2015 February 2015 January 2015 December 2014 November 2014 October 2014 September 2014 August 2014 July 2014 June 2014 April 2014 March 2014 February 2014 January 2014 December 2013 November 2013 October 2013 September 2013 August 2013 July 2013 June 2013 April 2013 March 2013 February 2013 January 2013 December 2012 November 2012 October 2012 September 2012 August 2012 July 2012 June 2012 May 2012 April 2012 March 2012 February 2012 January 2012 December 2011 November 2011 October 2011 September 2011 August 2011 July 2011 June 2011 April 2011 March 2011 February 2011 October 2010 September 2010 August 2010 July 2010 April 2010 March 2010 December 2009 October 2009 August 2009 July 2009 June 2009 May 2009 March 2009 February 2009 October 2008 September 2008 April 2008 March 2008 February 2008 January 2008 December 2007 November 2007 October 2007 May 2007 March 2007 February 2007 January 2007 November 2006 October 2006 September 2006 August 2006 July 2006 June 2006 May 2006 April 2006 March 2006 February 2006 October 2005 June 2005 April 2005 February 2005 July 2004 May 2004 April 2004


Follow Us!

Follow Us on Facebook Follow Us on Twitter



TAKE THE

Religious Wisdom Quiz

Which Christian tradition celebrates "Holy Week," including Maundy Thursday and Good Friday?

Select your answer to see how you score.

Many (Catholic, Orthodox, Anglican) Only Quakers Only Baptists Only Pentecostals

Books by This Author Books by Dave Armstrong

See All Titles »

Related posts from Biblical Evidence for Catholicism

Family

Was Peter "Any Old" Apostle? 10 Anti-Papal Arguments

Biblical Evidence for Catholicism

Family

11 Protestant Objections to Papal Authority Debunked

Biblical Evidence for Catholicism

Family

Matthew 16 & the Papacy (vs. Patrick O'Brien)

Biblical Evidence for Catholicism

Family

Inspired Prophets: An Analogy to Infallible Popes

Biblical Evidence for Catholicism

TRENDING AT PATHEOS Catholic

Spirituality without Supernaturalism

Spirituality does NOT require supernaturalism. Many of us experience awe, gratitude, responsibility...

Finding Gratitude in the Growth You Didn't Choose

I Wouldn't Have Chosen This My life has had many twists and...

  I'm lately seeing a remarkable amount of online fear-mongering and sensationalized...

Salisbury Cathedral (outside)-- Part Four

There is a relatively new statue outside the cathedral of the 'walking...

I Was in Prison ... On Matthew 25:35-36

I Was in Prison...and You Came to Me "for I was hungry...

'Ebenezer': Johnny Depp in a Dickens That Gets...

November, the Catholic month of memento mori, is a perfect time for...

view all Catholic blogs

Patheos on Facebook Patheos on YouTube

Ad-Free & Subscriber Log-In Subscription Support

Copyright 2008-2026, Patheos. All rights reserved.

Subscription Support Ad-Free & Subscriber Log-In

Follow Patheos Patheos on Facebook Patheos on YouTube