Patheos

BuddhistCatholicContemplativeEvangelicalGeneral ChristianHinduJewishLatter-day SaintMuslimNew VisionsProgressive Christian

Beliefs

Topics

Columnists

Resource Library

Research Tools

Video

Podcasts

Thought Readers

Faith In Media Tracker

Newsletters

Ad-Free & Subscriber Log-In Subscription Support

Patheos

Ad-Free & Subscriber Log-In Subscription Support

Follow Patheos Patheos on Facebook Patheos on YouTube

criticalhistorianofreligionasdetective

Ayatollahs’ Secret Pedophilia Fatwah Exposed!

Last updated on: July 6, 2025 at 4:21 pm   by Dr. Micah Ben David Naziri

0 Comments

Ayatollahs’ Secret Pedophilia Fatwah Exposed! 2025-07-06T16:21:33-04:00 Dr. Micah Ben David Naziri

LOGO Patheos Explore the world's faith through different perspectives on religion and spirituality! Patheos has the views of the prevalent religions and spiritualities of the world.

Image from the Taliyah al-Mahdi. Used with permission.

Most of the Muslim world has never heard of such a fatwah. In fact, there is not one, but several versions of this disgusting fatwah. | Image from the Taliyah al-Mahdi. Used with permission.

Imagine that one day, someone passed a law that said, “As of last week, there can be no more laws passed!”

This act itself would have to be considered an act of law if it was followed, and in so doing, it would contradict its own ruling, since it came after the cut-off time for the passage of law. This is the sort of deficiency of commonsense that has gone relatively unchallenged in the Ummah until the modern age…

Perhaps it is not so much that it has gone unchallenged as it is something that would – in former times – provoke a death sentence from the dissidents who stepped up and challenged the illogical system.

Within the Shi`a Muslim (or more accurately, Mutaslim) world, there is a similar, yet slightly different, problem; this problem is the Usuli system of Marja`iyyah. In the Marja` system, a person attends a Hawza institution until they have learned to parrot their scholastic predecessors to such a point that these predecessors confer an ijazah – a diploma of sorts – upon them that says now they are able to pass fataawat on subjects as mujtaahidun.

The trouble is that in order to get this ijazah, they must tow the “party” lines. They are not going to get very far if they are challenging the status quo, or engaging their teachers, or the so-called `ulema’ about truly critical issues. They thus have two options: assimilate or get kicked out of the Hawza academy.

This zero-sum game may be conceptually challenged by proponents of this fairly newfangled ‘Usuli marja` system. Nevertheless, the reader is challenged to cite a single example of a dissident Hawza student who ever went on to be granted such a diploma.

By dissident, it should be noted that I do not mean “radical,” I mean challenging issues on everything from the infallibility of Muhammad’s progeny of the Ahl al-Bayt, to the permissibility of child molestation or “thighing” (mufakhathat), of nursing infants that a man has “married.”

The Pro-Pedophilia Fatwah the Mullacracy Doesn’t Want You To Know About

Most of the Muslim world has never heard of such a fatwah. In fact, there is not one, but several versions of this disgusting fatwah. Lest anyone think this is just an “Iranian” problem, two versions are presented below: one from the self-described Ayatollah Khomeini, and the other by the Iraqi “moderate” Ayatollah Sistani.

مسألة 12 : لا يجوز وطء الزوجة قبل إكمال تسع سنين ، دواما كان النكاح أو منقطعا ، و أما سائر الاستمتاعات كاللمس بشهوة و الضم و التفخيذ فلا بأس بها حتى فى الرضيعة ، و لو وطأها قبل التسع و لم يفضها لم يترتب عليه شىء غير الاثم على الاقوى ، و إن أفضاها بأن جعل مسلكى البول و الحيض واحدا أو مسلكى الحيض و الغائط واحدا حرم عليه وطؤها أبدا لكن على الاحوط فى الصورة الثانية ، و على أي حال لم تخرج عن زوجيته على الاقوى ، فيجري عليها أحكامها من التوارث و حرمة الخامسة و حرمة أختها معها و غيرها ، و يجب عليه نفقتها مادامت حية و إن طلقها بل و إن تزوجت بعد الطلاق على الاحوط ، بل لا يخلو من قوة ، و يجب عليه دية الافضاء ، و هى دية النفس ، فإذا كانت حرة فلها نصف دية الرجل مضافا إلى المهر الذي استحقته بالعقد و الدخول ، و لو دخل بزوجته بعد إكمال التسع فأفضاها لم تحرم عليه و لم تثبت الدية ، و لكن الاحوط الانفاق عليها مادامت حية و إن كان الاقوى عدم الوجوب .

When I first published these fatwatayn, over two decades ago, the Iranian Government quickly made sure to try to scrub this from the Internet… unfortunately, for them they didn’t scrub hard enough. As it turns out, this filth will not come out no matter how hard you try to scrub. The Internet means “forever.” Here is the pedophilia fatwah that they don’t want you to know about – preserved by WayBack Machine.

The same fatwah could formerly be found here as well, but has since been removed because of the Taliyah al-Mahdi. As well, today, the related offshoot – the Jam`at al-Fitrah anti-Hamas mujahidin in Gaza – have been working together for years, in the effort to shine a light upon the darkness of this fatwah.

In truth, the Islamicate Ummah is largely unaware of such disgusting rulings. If you asked most Muslims about them, almost no one would have heard of them, and even fewer still would believe that they were penned by their religious leaders – who demand emulation or taqlid.

Here’s the cached page they tried to keep you from seeing, preserved by Wayback Machine here:

مسألة 8 : لا يجوز وطء الزوجة قبل إكمال تسع سنين، دواماً كان النكاح أو منقطعاً، واما سائر الاستمتاعات كاللمس بشهوة والتقبيل والضم والتفخيذ فلا بأس بها، ولو وطئها قبل اكمال التسع ولم يفضها لم يترتب عليه شيء غير الاثم على الاقوى، ـ والافضاء هو التمزق الموجب لاتحاد مسلكي البول والحيض أو مسلكي الحيض والغائط أو اتحاد الجميع ـ ولو افضاها لم تخرج عن زوجيته، فتجري عليها احكامها من التوارث وحرمة الخامسة وحرمة اختها معها وغيرها، ولكن قيل: يحرم عليه وطؤها ابداً. إلاّ أن الاقوى خلافه، ولا سيما إذا اندمل الجرح ـ بعلاج أو بغيره ـ نعم تجب عليه دية الافضاء، وهي دية النفس ان طلقها، بل وإن لم يطلقها على المشهور، ولا يخلو عن وجه، وتجب عليه نفقتها ما دامت مفضاة وإن نشزت أو طلقها، بل وإن تزوجت بعد الطلاق على الاحوط.

The following is the translation of the first fatwah, the second is pretty much the same:

“It is not permissible to have sexual intercourse with one’s wife that hasn’t reached nine years of age, be it permanent or temporary marriage. But there is no problem with all other pleasures such as lustful touch, embracing, and rubbing again the thighs, even with a suckling infant. If he does have sexual intercourse before nine years of age and does not penetrate, there is no penalty, but he has committed a sin. If he does penetrate causing the vagina and urethra openings to be one, she will become forever haraam for him. Although this is as a precautionary measure. And it is more probable that her status as his wife is not removed. And the rulings of inheritance, and the prohibition of a fifth wife or marriage to her sister applies. He is also responsible for her maintenance as long as she is alive, even if he divorces her and even if she marries someone else after his divorcing her as a precautionary measure. And he is liable for blood money for the penetration and the amount is equivalent to that of an individual. If she is a free-woman, the amount is half that of a man, plus the dowry that she became entitled to through the `aqd and penetration. If he penetrates his wife after the age of nine (causing the same damage as quoted above) , she does not become haraam to him and there is no evidence that blood money is liable, but as a precautionary measure, he should maintain her as long as she is alive, although it is more probable that this is not obligatory.”

The nearly identical wording of both fatwatayn – from both scholars’ rulings – leaves us with two rather bleak possibilities.

The first is that both agree on the permissibility or hillah of raping children as young as two-years-old. In fact, they agree so closely that their wording in writing a fatwah permitting such abuses naturally ended up being worded almost identically, perhaps due to emanating from the rulings of a grand teacher which both have in common.

The second possibility evidences that many rulings are not individually handled with the critical thinking of Reason or Al-`Aql, as they claim and are religiously required to be. Instead merely “copied and pasted” – so to speak – from one scholar to the next.

It is difficult to determine which of these possibilities puts the muqalidun emulators of these “experts” or fuqahah in a worse position. Remember that the so-called Islamic Republic of Iran purports to have claims to rule because they are religious fuqahah. That is, the Wilyah or Guardianship of the government is of the Faqih. This is what their concept of Wilyat al-Faqih or Vilyat-i Faqih literally means.

But Muhammad himself is reported to have warned us against the very scholars representing Islam in this age.

“There will come a time for my people when there will remain nothing of the Qur’an except its outward from and nothing of Islam except its name and they will call themselves by this name even though they are the people furthest from it. Their mosques will be full of people but they will be empty of right guidance. The religious leaders, the fuqaha of that day will be the most evil religious leaders under the heavens; sedition and dissension will go out from them and to them will it return.” (Ibn Babuya, Thaqab al-Amal, quoted in Allamah Majlisi, Bihar al-Anwar Vol. 13. p. 152)

If the fuqaha are not in fact morally-legitimate*,* then what claim do they have to lead, teach, rule, enact laws, collect taxes, fund terror groups build nuclear bombs, threaten to go to war with other nations – all on behalf of a people who they demand not dare engage in critical thinking?

Whatever answer religious Iranian Muslims come to conclude, the logical takeaway here is that the person of reason must always remain critical of any and all fatawat as well as the process by which they are set to pen.

The existence of such rulings in the collections of scholars does not necessarily indicate that these are truly their positions – just that they have no engaged in new, independent critical thinking with respect to copied rulings. If they are thus “phoning it in” and plagiarizing work of pedophiles-past within the `ulema, then this too means that they are scholars-in-name-only, or Scholars For Dollars.

Again, all of this is tragic evidence of just how little critical thinking is encouraged in the Islamicate world. This should be a warning to all critical thinkers who are approached by the Da`wah Industry, with manipulative missionary brainwashing tracts that always seem to leave out inconvenient little details like those presented here.

It is little wonder then why the Judeo-Sufi rabbi, a grandson of the Rambam (1138 – 1204), `Ovadyah Maimuni (1228-1265), of the Maimonidean Dynasty “As for he who accepts taqlid, it is as if he were never born. ‘An untimely birth is better than he'” (Qohelet/ Ecclesiastes 6:3).

Nevertheless, we are told from a Cairo Genizah document that the public assessment of Rabbi `Ovadyah Maimuni was that “all is revealed to him” whenever he withdraws to meditate upon a subject or question.

“Rabbi `Ovadyah, the eminent Sage to whom mysteries are revealed, in whom ‘light, understanding and wisdom like the wisdom of the angels are to be found’ (Daniel 5:11), ‘no secret mystifies him, he lies down and all is revealed to him'” (6:6).

The Judeo-Sufi answer, like all Jewish answers, is that there are no shortcuts to get around using reason to critically deduce. You have to employ the faculties of reason. Indeed, it has been this insistence upon critical thinking that has irritated the nations to no end with us over the centuries. While they were content to emulate their religious leaders and check critical thought at the door, we were always there with a logical response whenever they demanded we uncritically adopt their beliefs and practices as our own.

Ultimately, this was the greatest crime of the Jewish people in the eyes of the nations: refusing to just accept the authority of someone because they claimed to have been a religious leader, or even had a nice piece of paper that said they were. Regardless of titles, if they could not reason, they were no more an “expert” than a black belt who has never sparred. When he gets in the ring with an experienced fighter with no formal rank at all, he will be in for a rude awakening… in a hospital bed.

Muslim

Politics and Religion

Uncategorized

Ayatollah

Iran

Iranian

Shia

Shiite

War on Iran

About Dr. Micah Ben David Naziri

Dr. Naziri is a prolific author who has penned numerous academic articles. He has served as an editor for works on Martial Arts and Eastern Medicine, transcribing and creating numerous titles for some of his teachers and authoring several martial treatises of his own. The son of a multitude of peoples – Ashkenazi, Sefardic, Native American and others – Micah has often said he has “one foot in the masjid and the other in shul.” He considers his understanding of Judaism to be “Judeo-Sufi,” or “Istislam” as described by Rabbeinu Bachya ibn Paqudah, in his Judeo-Arabic work “Guide to the Duties of the Hearts” (Al-Hidayat ila Faraid al-Qulub), which quoted the Historical Muhammad and Ali profusely, while fully embracing the Torah as the framework of religious practice for the Jewish people. As the founder of the Hashlamah Project, Micah uses his education in Near Eastern Languages, Religions, and historical models of building bridges between Jewish and Muslim communities, to help reconcile and unite Jews and Palestinian Muslims in face-to-face study and dialogue groups. You can read more about the author here.

Previous Post



April 22, 2025

Why the Torah Really Says "God Gave Us the Land" of Israel

Next Post



May 15, 2025 An Essene Midrash on the Wisdom and Compassion of King David

Recent Comments

0 | Leave a Comment

"Beautiful ❤️ 🙏🙏 This is so perfectly and accurately explained and articulated, it is a ..."

LScott


The Messiah’s Mirror: Good Micah, Bad ..."

"Many will regret destroying their skin with so many tattoos. It looks disgusting in my ..."

KarolD


Are Tattoos Really Forbidden by the ..."

"Religion has become broken and corrupt. Our current belief systems only cause division and strife. ..."

EarthGrowl


The Jewish Origins of Ḥajj and ..."

"Excellent article! Nice to finally see the truth being exposed! Thank you again for the ..."

spirit study


The Jewish Origins of Ḥajj and ..."


Browse Our Archives

Select a Category Uncategorized

Select a Month September 2026 August 2026 May 2026 February 2026 January 2026 December 2025 October 2025 September 2025 August 2025 June 2025 May 2025 April 2025 March 2025 October 2024


Follow Us!

Follow Us on Facebook Follow Us on Twitter



TAKE THE

Religious Wisdom Quiz

Which tribe first accepted David as king after Saul's death?

Select your answer to see how you score.

Judah Dan Ephraim Benjamin

Related posts from The Critical Historian of Religion As Detective

Jewish

Circumcision, Indigeneity and Judeophobic Cultural Hypocrisy

The Critical Historian of Religion As Detective

Jewish

Out-Crowleying Crowley: The Emptiness of the O9A

The Critical Historian of Religion As Detective

Jewish

Does the Talmud Support Pedophilia? Debunking the Viral...

The Critical Historian of Religion As Detective

Jewish

BAMBOOZLED: No People Rise by Blaming Another People

The Critical Historian of Religion As Detective

TRENDING AT PATHEOS Jewish

Building a Little Ark in a Frightening World

This past Shabbat, we read about Noah. I love this story. The...

Yom Kippur : Is There Always Room for...

Making Room for Forgiveness  Every year as Yom Kippur approaches, I find...

This Rosh Hashanah: Can I Find New Meaning?

A Sunrise, a New Year, and a Question On our way to...

Killing Amalek: The Torah’s Most Misunderstood Commandment

Few passages of the Torah have provoked more confusion, polemic, and misuse...

The Art of Beginning Again

  I have never trusted a first draft. I don’t mean that...

Back to School, Back to Reality—and a New...

A New School Year Begins… Back to Reality A new school year...

view all Jewish blogs

What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment

Patheos on Facebook Patheos on YouTube

Ad-Free & Subscriber Log-In Subscription Support

Copyright 2008-2026, Patheos. All rights reserved.

Subscription Support Ad-Free & Subscriber Log-In

Follow Patheos Patheos on Facebook Patheos on YouTube