Buddhist Catholic Contemplative Evangelical General Christian Hindu Jewish Latter-day Saint Muslim New Visions Progressive Christian

Beliefs

Topics

Columnists

Resource Library

Research Tools

Video

Podcasts

Thought Readers

Faith In Media Tracker

Newsletters

Ad-Free & Subscriber Log-In Subscription Support

Follow Patheos

Companions on the Journey

Home
About
Contributors
Events
Publications
Websites
- CompanionsontheJourney.org
- SpiritsInSpacesuits.com
Archive Index
Contact

Home
New Visions
Secondary Reinforcement . . . or How to Destroy Society and Planet Without Really Trying

Secondary Reinforcement . . . or How to Destroy Society and Planet Without Really Trying

Last updated on: October 28, 2019 at 10:49 am by Bill Miller

Secondary Reinforcement . . . or How to Destroy Society and Planet Without Really Trying 2019-10-28T10:49:11-08:00 Bill Miller

LOGO Patheos Explore the world's faith through different perspectives on religion and spirituality! Patheos has the views of the prevalent religions and spiritualities of the world.

Who would have thought that a century ago, a couple of dogs, a buzzer, and a psychologist would uncover and demonstrate the means by which life as we know it can be destroyed?

In seminal experiments conducted around 1901, Russian researcher Ivan Pavlov formally identified and demonstrated a principle known as “classical conditioning” (… seminal to the degree that “Pavlovian” has become a cultural meme.) In behavioral psychology, this kind of conditioning refers to a scenario where a neural stimulus in the external environment is repeatedly associated with a “primary reinforcer” — something the subject naturally desires. In Pavlov’s studies, the subjects were dogs, and the neutral stimulus was the sound of a buzzer, which was repeatedly paired with the presentation of food.

Dogs will naturally salivate in the presence of food, however Pavlov found that after a number of such pairings, the tone itself was sufficient to induce salivation, even in the absence of food. In other words, the tone had become secondarily reinforcing.

While that might be an interesting finding, you may ask: “How do we go from drooling dogs to planetary destruction? Well, the factors are subtle, complex, and multilayered — which unfortunately is why a critical mass of understanding may not happen in time to avoid disaster. But in any case, here goes …

A Brief Primer on Behavioral Psychology

Primary Reinforcers

Along with all other living creatures, human life is filled with a great range of primary reinforcers —things we innately find pleasant and naturally desire. The most basic of these have to do with survival: food, sex, physical comfort, safety, and pleasure. Also fairly basic are social and psychological reinforcers like companionship, security, social acceptance, knowledge, talent, skill, and access to beauty and entertainment. In terms of Behavioral Psychology, we tend to focus attention upon and engage in activities that are rewarded by experiences of the above.

Secondary Reinforcement in Humans

Secondary reinforcers are those that in and of themselves satisfy no immediate desire nor otherwise confer a benefit. They are emotionally neutral (perhaps sometimes even a little aversive). Yet many of these, when regularly paired with a primary reinforcer will eventually evoke largely the same emotional response.

An easy example of this might be the scent of cooking food which provides no nutritional value or taste or tactile pleasure, yet virtually every creature will respond positively and be motivated toward seeking the primary reinforcer (i.e. in this case food).

Classical vs Operant Reinforcers

Behavioral psychologists make one further distinction to this dynamic — that between classical and operantly conditioned responses. Classically conditioned responses involve the autonomic nervous system – those over which one does not have much conscious control. In addition to the food example above, it might be the ring of a doorbell that signals the pleasure of an arriving guest. Or a stress response to a ringing telephone that might be a creditor or angry customer. Or the sight of a letter with the return address “I.R.S.”

In contrast, operantly-conditioned responses involve some sort of deliberate, voluntary behavior — something one does, that results in a positive, desirable outcome. Visiting friends, completing a task, preparing a meal, dining out, working for pay, playing a sport — even a dull life contains many of these.

Superstition

It is easy to understand secondarily-reinforced emotional and behavioral responses when they lead to satisfaction of obvious primary desires. Yet humans are subject to such a vast range of reinforcers, experienced through a vast range of behavior and context, that sometimes fairly remote or bizarre associations are made.

Superstitious behavior occurs when the connection between a neutral object, behavior, circumstance, or ritual and the desired favorable outcome is illusory. The motivation may be to seek a benefit or to avoid a pain. Given the complexity of the modern world, we often have to work from incomplete information, and therefore must make our best guess as to why “X” happened or failed to happen. Sometimes we get it wrong. However, if one is too rigid about such associations, it can fall under a psychiatric category like Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder (OCD).

—————————

Although the above may seem like simple and somewhat obvious concepts, virtually all human activity is in some way motivated by such principles — an effort to seek a benefit or pleasure, or an effort to avoid pain or inconvenience.

Many times, such activity confers a general benefit and elevates the long-term prospects for people and planet. At other times, it may lead to injustice and social or ecological harm.

Money as an Ultimate Reinforcer

One of the most widespread and effective secondary reinforcers today is money. In and of itself, money is useless. It confers no direct benefit. Yet especially in Western societies, it is a gateway to almost any other benefit one might desire. As such, it is sometimes prized and sought over any other value — the health and well-being of others, of the planet, and sometimes even of life itself.

Money’s power is especially amplified because it contains both classically and operantly conditioned elements. Randomly stumbling upon a $100 dollar bill laying in the street would be sufficient to trigger an emotional response in most people. And the range of activity people will “operantly” engage in to acquire the same is vast.

In addition, the unique feature of money-as-reinforcer is the fact that it can be traded for an uncountably vast array of desired objects. Whereas laboratory dogs may eventually tire of hearing a buzzer, especially if the conditioned association is broken through the absence of food, with money, if one desired object becomes unavailable, thousands of alternatives exist.

The Dangerous Aspect of Secondary Reinforcement

Grim and gritty as life can be when primary survival resources are scarce, these generally have practical limits — objective indicators as to when such needs have been met. One seeks food, clothing, and shelter until one is fed, clothed, and housed. On the antisocial side, a burglar can steal only what goods can be carried off. In the societal realm, even the most despotic leader can hold only as much territory as armies can defend. Despite conditions of scarcity, there are physical limits to the deprivation suffered by some for the benefit of others before the overall system breaks down.

In other words, natural homeostatic mechanisms exist that indicate when one has had enough of a primary reinforcer.

Not so with secondary reinforcers. Because they satisfy no primary need, taking on their attractiveness only through association, there is no natural mechanism to indicate when one has accumulated enough of a secondary reinforcer. Again taking monetary wealth as an example, if one is cold, simply having one hundred or even one million dollars in an account does not improve the situation. It is not until some portion is traded for a primary good (clothing or shelter) that the need is satisfied.

However, once the conditioned association has been made, the acquisition and accumulation of a secondary reinforcer like money becomes attractive in itself — apart from any primary need. It becomes an end goal. Moreover, because there is no natural enough-ness mechanism with secondary reinforcers, “more” is always felt to be “better”. This, coupled with any vague insecurities about the future — or unnamed future desires — can lead to the runaway limitless hoarding that we more commonly know as “greed”.

Today we struggle with vast and growing levels of economic inequality, such that a mere handful of people now control more wealth than the bottom half of the planet’s population (https://time.com/5508393/global-wealth-inequality-widens-oxfam). Yet due to the general unawareness of the disconnect between a secondary reinforcer like money and primary (true) needs, the system that produced these inequitable conditions is likely to continue, being rationalized as “healthy competition’, ‘necessary for progress” — and ennobled with euphemisms like industriousness, innovation, entrepreneurialism, and finding the “best”.

The Implications for Life in Society

Most people who have not been damaged by life experience can understand that all people – in fact, all creatures – have evolved (or been created, if you prefer) through similar means, and thus have similar needs, desires, and motivations. And, all else being equal, have a similar right to survive and thrive.

The only real threat to such rights, in a word, is “scarcity”. When the perception exists that there are not enough resources to accommodate the survival and happiness of all, a competition commonly sets in to acquire and control such resources — benefiting some, to the detriment of others.

When in addition this is supported by social and economic institutions designed around principles of scarcity and competition, and further amplified by the runaway accumulative pressure of secondarily reinforced rewards, the result is the increasingly inequitable, threatened, destabilized, chaotic world that we seem to be entering.

A Shift in Eras

When particular philosophies of life, industry, and social organization have served for centuries, there is a general momentum to proceed as though tomorrow will unfold like yesterday, and that “staying the course” is the best strategy. Any disruption to the status quo that is less severe than an asteroid impact can generally be rationalized away through confirmation bias (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Confirmation_bias).

Yet, like the frog-in-the-pan-of-water analogy, will we fail to see that phenomena like war, greed, haves and have-nots, ecological destruction, climate disruption, mass extinctions are not merely bumps on the road to an inevitable shining future but rather are collective indicators that a fundamental shift in Eras is underway? Can we recognize that the time has come for a basic reconsideration of our social institutions and philosophies?

In view of the knowledge, resources, and technology available today, our collective compulsion to cling to prehistoric motivations like scarcity, competition, control, and exclusion is puzzling. Today, no one need be left behind. We could do so much more together.

Can we make this paradigm-shift in time to avoid world war or ecological collapse? I don’t know, but one critical step lies in awakening from the illusory value of arbitrary secondary reinforcers and once again put primary living systems at the center of our concern.

awakening

behavioral psychology

classical conditioning

primary reinforcement

psychological conditioning

Previous Post

October 15, 2019

Bath Time

Next Post

November 5, 2019 Pythagoras and Eithne

Browse Our Archives

Select a Category "All Lives Matter" "Anatomy of Human Destructiveness" "belonging systems" "bite-sized pieces of God" "Black Lives Matter" "block universe" "butterfly effect" "call to prayer" "counting to 10" "dog-whistle" language "I Am" statements "late term abortion" "lefties" "Nature Nazis" "Nephilim" "opium of the masses" "othering" "personal" God "personal/sensible" God "private" property "punctuated equilibria" "Silent Night" "Sky Gods" "Super Archetypes" "symbolic"experience "TaNaKh" "the difficult passages" "The Prophet" "the seamless garment approach' "virtualized" money "waking Life" 'creatio ex nihilo' 'dissipative structures' 'emanatio ab Deo' 'God the creator' 'God the Redeemer' 'God the Sanctifier' 'in potentia' 'The End Times' 1% abandonment Abortion abortion debate Abraham abstract rationality abundance Adam and Eve advanced beings/civilizations Advent adventure afterlife agape akasha Akashic record Alabaster jar Alan Watts alchemy aleinu alignment alive allegory altered states of consciousness alternate state of consciousness Alzheimer's disease America 2019 America 2020 America 2021 amnesia Anam Chara anatma (no soul) angels animasphere anitya (impermanence) Annuciation apathy apocalypse apophatic language apostles archetype art artists ASC - altered states of consciousness ascension asceticism ashram astral form astral travel astrology atheism Atman attention attention/observation autism avatar awake awakener awakening awareness awareness/imagination Axial Age Babel Baltimore catechism Baptism bardo state Bealtaine Beatitudes beauty behavioral psychology Being-Knowing-Loving belief systems beliefs Benediction Bernard Haisch Bethlehem Bhagavad Gita biblical literalism biblical revelation Big Bang biophilic biosphere birth canal birthright bite-size piece of God black holes blame Blessed Trinity bodhisattva bodhisattva vow body bonding Book of Job Book of Kells Book of Psalms Book of Revelation border wall Brahma Brahma-Vishnu-Shiva Brahman brain brotherhood/sisterhood Buddha Buddha nature Buddhahood Buddhas Buddhism burning bush Cain and Abel camán (hurley) cancer Canon Law canonical gospels Caol Áit caol áiteanna capital punishment capitalism Carl Jung cataphatic language Catherine of Siena Catholics causal void cause and effect cell mates Celtic Christianity Celtic Feast of Bealtaine Celtic spirituality Chalmers channel of healing chaos consciousness chaos theory charism children chreode Christ archetype Christ consciousness Christ/Christa consciousness Christa Consciousness Christian Christian cosmology Christian Trinity Christianity Christmas Christmas club ciotogs civilization classical conditioning climate change climate disruption co-create co-creating reality co-creative power and responsibility co-creative power of attention codependency cognitive flexibility coherence collaboration collective attention collective consciousness collective imagination collective intelligence/effort collective prayer collective unconscious collective/universal consciousness communication Communion of Saints community Companions on the Journey (COJ) compassion compassionate caregiver competition complacency complex/interdependent society Complexity/Chaos Theory complexity/entropy conceptual thought concurrency Confucius connectedness conscience conscious conscious evolution conscious observation conscious observer consciousness consciousness examen consciousness-primary cosmos consciousness-primary reality conservatism consumerism consumption continuous creation conversations conversion cooperation Coronavirus corrupt politics cosmic consciousness Cosmic Mind cosmic patterns cosmic whole cosmology cosmos Council of Constantinople Council of Nicaea countable infinity courage court prophets covenant Covid-19 creating creation creation by subtraction creative intelligence creativity creativity/paradox creator crucifixion culpability cultural identity cultural trance culture cynicism dark night of the soul Darwin daughter of Sion death debate and detachment deconstructionism deity déjá vu dementia demi-urge democracy democratization of Spirit Descartes desert fathers/mothers destiny detachment determinism devil's advocate Dia de Los Muertos dialogue dignity of all sentient beings direct experience disassociation disciple discovery disease disillusionment diversity divination divine brain Divine Feminine divine inspiration Divine Masculine Divine nature divine realm of perfection divinity DNA Donald Hoffman donkeys Down syndrome drama dream dream state dream time dreamers dreams dualism duality dysfunctional family earth Easter Eastern mystics ecology ecumenism ego ego identity ego-soul dialectic Einstein Einstein's "Block Universe" elementals Elijah Elohim eloquence EM field emergence emergent phenomenon emotional heart empathy en mesoi en-souled human person encounters end times endangered species enemies energy enlightenment entanglement entrainment entropy-complexity environmental degradation epigenetics epiphenomena epistemology equality/democracy equanimity equation of enlightenment Erich Fromm esoteric eternal eternal/mortal eternity etheric body ethics Eucharist Eucharistic Prayer of the Cosmos evaluation evil evolution evolution into enlightenment evolution of consciousness evolution of purpose evolution of society evolution of virtues evolution/devolution evolutionary inflection point evolutionary programming evolutionary shift evolutionary trajectory existence existential inflection point exit strategy experiential knowing experiential symbols extending rights/curtailing rights extra-terrestrial societies extra-terrestrials faery folk faith fake news families family Family of Man fate Father God fear Feast of All Souls feedback feminine face of God Ferdinand de Saussure fetus fifth dimension filioque fire flora and fauna Flora Spiritualis flow foreign policy forgiveness fractals fractals of divinity free will freedom friendship fundamentalism Gaia galaxy Gandhi Garden of Eden Garden of Gethsemane Gautama Siddhartha gemilut hasadim generosity Genesis geometry global crises Global Game Plan global narcissism global transformation global warming gnosis Gnostic intermediaries God God as Father God the Father God's Dream God's heart God's immanence God's will God-conscious Godhead gods Golgotha good and evil Good Samaritan goodness Gospel of John Gospel of Luke Gospel of Thomas grace gratitude greed Greek 'prosopon' ground of being guns habituation hate haves and have nots healing heart heaven Hebrew scriptures hell higher consciousness Hindu Hindu stages of human life Hindu trinity Hinduism Hippocrates Hitler holocene extinction Holocene/Anthropocene holy human Holy Spirit Holy Trinity Homo Narcississimus homo sapiens homo sapiens sapiens Homo Sociopathicus homo spiritualis hope hospitality Huang Po human agency human conditioning human evolution human flourishing (eudaimonia) human history human life human nature human nature/divine nature human needs human psyche human species humans as a social species humility hunger/yearning hypnagogic hypnopompic I AM idealism identity identity theft ideology idolatry illusion illusion of scarcity illusion of separation Ilya Prigogine image of God imaginal cells imagination immanence of God immanent aspect of God immanent experience impermanence improvisation impulse of spirit incarnation incarnational experience incarnational phase inclusivity individual subjectivity individuality indulgences industrial revolution Ineffable Source ineffable transcendence inequality inerrancy of the scriptures infallibility inferior mortal realm infinite inflation/deflation information revolution inner tranquility innocence inspiration instinct instinctual responses integration intellect intelligence intention intentional community interconnectedness interdimensional interpersonal relationships intuition Iománaíocht Ireland irrationality Isaiah Islam Issac Issac Newton Jacob Jacob's ladder of Genesis Jane Goodall Jansenism Jean-Paul Sartre Jeremiah Jesus Jesus as Divine Word John the apostle Joseph Campbell Joseph Cardinal Bernadin joy Judaism Judeo-Christian bible judgment justice Kahlil Gibran karma karma gobbler kindness Kingdom of God knowing knowledge and wisdom kosmic laws Kosmos Krishnamurti lack language Lao Tzu Latin "purgare" Latin 'persona' laughter Law of Impermanence Law of Love lay-away living learning legalism Lent letting go liberal/progressive liberation lies life life journey life purpose life-time commitment light likeness of God Lila limbo liminality lineage living systems living water logos longing love loving God loving without knowing lucid dreaming lucid living Ludwig Wittgenstein Luke and John Magi Mahavira mainstream media male/female faces of God manifest realm mantra Mariology Martin Buber Mary and Joseph Mary Magdalene Mary Oliver Mary the mother of Jesus mass media material world materialism materialistic science materialists mathematics matrix matter Maya mea culpa meaning of life media meditation Meister Eckhart meme memory message metanoia metaphor metaphysical universe metaphysics metaverse metta (Buddhism) Middle America Middle Way migrating Milesians military-industrial complex military-industrial demons Mind mind-body problem mindfulness mini-mystics miracles miraculous/mundane mission missionary mitzvah modularity moksha monasticism money Monoimus monotheism moral laws moral values morality morality/applied ethics morality/legality Moses Mother Earth Mother God mother-love motherhood Mount Shasta Mount Thabor multidimensional creatures multiverse music mystery mystic mystical body of Christ mystical impulse mystical poetry mystical self-empowerment mystical spirituality mystical union with Source mystical void mysticism mysticists mystics myth myth of the given mythic realm mythology naivete Namasté narcissism national security state nationalism Nativity natural disasters Natural Order Nature nautral selection NDE near death experience nebula necessity necrophilic neighbor Neils Bohr neural pathways neurotheology New Age philosophers New Age speak New Year resolutions newborn nirvana no-thing-ness Noah's Ark non-conceptual prayer noosphere nuclear nuclear weapons observer effect Old Testament oligarchy omniscience of God one-ness only-begotten ontology operant reinforcers oral language origin of laws Original Blessing original sin orthodoxy othering out-of-body experience overpopulation Pacha Mama pain pair-bonding Palm Sunday pandemic shutdown panspermia parable parallel lives parallel realities parallel universes parapsychological conduits pareidolia past-present-future Pater Noster Pavlov peace Peggy Lee Pena Creek Pentateuch Pentecost pepo perception perceptual state perfection persona personal cosmology personal enlightenment personal evolution personal responsibility personal transformation personality personhood personhood and ensoulment Peter and John Pharisees philosophy physical universe physical water physiosphere pilgrim Planet Earth planetary ascension Plato Plato's ideal realm pleasure principle Plotinus (d. 270 CE) Plutarch pneuma Pneuma Floriensis pneuma spiritualis pneumasphere poets politics post-incarnational phase power of love practice of prayer prana prayer prayer of petition Pre-Conception contract pre-incarnational phase predetermination prejudice priesthood priesthood of women primary reinforcement prime directive prison-industrial complex pro-choice pro-life profit propaganda prophets proverbs psyche psychodrama psychological conditioning psychological evolution psychology punctuated equilibrium pure awareness purgatory purpose pyramid of power Pythagoras Quakers Quakers "Sense of the Meeting" quantum field theory quantum foam quantum mechanics quantum physics quantum physics/mechanics quantum shift quarantined race radah radical love rainbow body raison d'etre Ram Dass Ramana Maharshi rationality/reason re-birth re-gifting intelligence re-incarnation re-incarnational phase re-magining reality reality gestalt reason recession reconciliation recycling reductionism reincarntion reintegration relationships relativism religion religionists religious systems remembering remembering/imagining renewal repetition resource wars response-ability Resurrection revelation revolution Richard Rohr Rig Veda rights/responsibilities Rilke ritual river of life Role-self root causes/social issues ruach Rumi Rupert Sheldrake sacrament sacraments sacrifice Sadducees Sai Baba saints salvation Samhain Samsara Sat-Chit-Ananda Satya Sai Baba scapegoat scarcity science science as revelation scientific fundamentalism scientific revolution scientism scientists Second Coming secondary reinforcement secular power secular/sacred secularization seeker seers Self self-acceptance self-alienation self-awareness self-compassion self-conscious life self-forgiveness self-identification self-identity self-interest/tribal interest self-liberation self-realization self-serving pathology self-understanding sense of self sense of separate self sensorium sentience separate self separation service to self/service to other sexual harrassment shadow shadow pod Shalom Shared Death Experience (SDE) sheep/shepherds Shiva Shiva energy Shroud of Turin signifiers silence simulated reality sin sin of separation sinner skin-encapsulated ego society socio-political division Socrates Son of Man Song of Amhergín soul soul group soul mates soul pod soul service Soul-self sound Source space-time special and general relativity spirit spiritual choices spiritual dis-integration spiritual DNA spiritual evolution spiritual garden spiritual healing spiritual heart spiritual heredity spiritual journey spiritual monoculture spiritual path spiritual power spiritual question/mystical question spiritual seeker spiritual water spirituality St. Augustine St. Francis St. Gregory of Palamas St. Ignatius of Loyola St. John of the Cross St. Patrick St. Paul St. Thomas Aquinas states of consciousness staying asleep staying awake Steven Pinker stillness stochastic terrorism Stockholm Syndrome stories story storytellers storytelling stream stress subconscious subjective consciousness subliminal perception submission suffering Sufi super-consciousness Supernatural Supernatural reality surrender survival survival of the fittest sustaining intelligence symbiosis symbols synchronicity taoism Tarot technology Teilhard de Chardin telepathy telos/teleology temptation tension terrorism the "Magnificat" the abortion process the Art of Dying the Bible the Big Other The Centering Prayer the cross the dead the Fall The Great Schism The Hero's Journey the human experiment the living The Lord's Prayer the Mother the Old Order the Other The Sign of Peace the Veil the World theology theory of entanglement Theory of Everything (TOE) theory of General Relativity Third Heaven "Shehaqim" thirst Thomas Aquinas thought patterns thoughts/tulpas Tikkun Olam time time travel time-space-mind tomb Tonglen Torah trans-lingual trans-rational trans-spatial trans-temporal transcendence transcendence of God transcendent aspect of God transcendent God transcendental experience transcendental realm transcendental/transpersonal Transcendentals Transfiguration transformation transpersonal Tree of Life Tree of the Knowledge of Good and Evil tribalism Trinity true Self trust truth truths tselem Tuatha Dé Danann tulpa ultimate reality Uncategorized unconditional love unconscious unconscious psychological modules uncountable infinity understanding unity Unity Consciousness universal basic income (UBI) universal consciousness universe universe as a living system universe itself as a living system Upanishads values Vatican II Veil of Veronica victimhood Virgin Mary virtues vision visionary experiences visions Vivekananda void of self-consciousness waking consciousness Watson and Crick wave-particle duality wealth wealth and privilege wealth gap Wilder Penfield will to survive William James wisdom witnessing consciousness women's spiritual group Word Word-of-God-Made-Flesh world view wu-wei Yahweh yin and yang Yogananda Zen Zen buddhist monk zero-sum game Zoroaster

Select a Month June 2024 May 2024 February 2024 January 2024 December 2023 September 2023 August 2023 July 2023 June 2023 April 2023 December 2022 November 2022 October 2022 June 2022 December 2021 November 2021 August 2021 July 2021 June 2021 May 2021 April 2021 March 2021 February 2021 January 2021 December 2020 October 2020 August 2020 July 2020 May 2020 April 2020 March 2020 February 2020 January 2020 December 2019 November 2019 October 2019 September 2019 August 2019 July 2019 June 2019 May 2019 April 2019 March 2019 February 2019 January 2019 December 2018 November 2018 October 2018 September 2018 August 2018 July 2018 June 2018 May 2018 April 2018 March 2018 February 2018 January 2018 December 2017 November 2017 October 2017 September 2017 August 2017 July 2017 June 2017 May 2017 April 2017 March 2017 February 2017 January 2017 December 2016 November 2016 October 2016 September 2016 August 2016 July 2016 June 2016 May 2016 April 2016 March 2016 February 2016 January 2016 December 2015

TAKE THE

Religious Wisdom Quiz