Patheos

BuddhistCatholicContemplativeEvangelicalGeneral ChristianHinduJewishLatter-day SaintMuslimNew VisionsProgressive Christian

Beliefs

Topics

Columnists

Resource Library

Research Tools

Video

Podcasts

Thought Readers

Faith In Media Tracker

Newsletters

Ad-Free & Subscriber Log-In Subscription Support

Patheos

Ad-Free & Subscriber Log-In Subscription Support

Follow Patheos Patheos on Facebook Patheos on YouTube

Christianity is Changing

Penal Substitution is Dying, Thank God!

Last updated on: January 6, 2015 at 12:23 pm   by Michael Hardin

Penal Substitution is Dying, Thank God! 2015-01-06T12:23:55-04:00 Michael Hardin

LOGO Patheos Explore the world's faith through different perspectives on religion and spirituality! Patheos has the views of the prevalent religions and spiritualities of the world.

I am sometimes asked why the penal substitution theory of the atonement is so popular. Advocates of this position are justly proud of the fact that it is the default position in Protestantism (although as of late that is being challenged). The answer is simple really. Penal substitution is popular because it is a theory of how the gods are placated that is and has been part of social-theological DNA from the dawn of time.

Rene Girard and advocates of the mimetic theory have proposed that in the beginning there was the scapegoat. Humans form their identity on that which they exclude. This goes against the grain of the standard Platonic reading of the Genesis story which starts with some perfect Eden into which the human is inserted, and then ‘falls’ from perfection. Almost all of the early church fathers read the Genesis story through this lens. And it worked for them although they did not then find the solution in a penal theory of atonement. They preferred a vision of atonement whereby Jesus, as the Second Adam, conquered sin, death and the devil. However, modern anthropology is beginning to see the heuristic value of this mimetic reading of our ancestral past which does not begin in Eden but in Death. This reading of our ancestral past takes its cue both from the evidence of the historical and archeological record and in Christian theology reckons with the key text that interprets all of this data: the Passion of Jesus of Nazareth.

Since the influence of John Calvin on the West, penal substitution has become the default position. In one sense it is the new kid on the block when it comes to understanding the death of Jesus and the work of God in reconciling humanity. In this view, God is angry at sinners who have broken covenant with God by disobeying the Law of God. God needs to have his anger propitiated and so sends Jesus to be the perfect sacrifice for our sin. Jesus pays the price on our behalf.

In the past thirty years this view has been challenged head on from a number of different directions. Feminist theologians have called this view ‘divine child abuse.’ They have been criticized on this score, particularly by those who, influenced by Karl Barth, want to understand this propitiation as an inner Trinitarian work: God takes upon God’s self our punishment. However, penal substitutionists cannot evade the fact the Father does not suffer punishment for our sin, only Jesus does. The Father is actively pouring out wrath on the Son; the Son passively accepts this wrath and dies.

This view is not really new with Calvin though, he just gives an ancient view a ‘Christian’ slant. This view of the gods being wrathful and in need of propitiation is as old as the hills. It stems from our earliest human ancestors going back before Homo sapiens. When anthropologists unpack the concept of sacrifice what they discover is the basic building block of all religion and culture: the concept of an economy of exchange. We give in order to receive. Girard and mimetic theorists posit this structuring principle as the foundation of religion oriented by the scapegoat, who is our gift to the gods to displace their wrath.

Some feel they can dismiss this anthropological theory by appealing to the Bible or the Early Church Fathers. The fact is that this theory can be found in the Bible. But it is this very way of thinking that the Bible is arguing against. A major burden of my work has been to demonstrate that such is the case and that we need a new view of the Bible as a book which contains two trajectories: that of myth, which justifies scapegoating practice and that of Gospel which exposes it and overcomes it, and offers an alternative way of being human and forming human community in forgiveness and love.

Those who say that we need to retain penal substitution alongside Christus Victor and other theories of the atonement because all of these can be found in the Bible fail to rightly divide the word of truth. They fail to see that both trajectories are contained in the Bible and that these opposing viewpoints are set against one another. They would prefer to have their cake and eat it too, mixing sacrificial and non or anti-sacrificial interpretations together as though both were saying the same thing rather than recognizing that they are antithetical opposites.

The world has rightly rejected the Janus-faced god, the deity whose arbitrariness, capriciousness and anger has been the justification for all manner of social exclusion including but not limited to discrimination and warfare. Modern atheism rightly rejects this god. The new groups of those disaffected with Christianity, the ‘Nones’ and the ‘Dones’ are tired of this god. They have an intuition that God is better than that. They sense that somehow the church is missing the point of the Gospel. And all of these groups are right! As long as Christianity remains mired in a sacrificial interpretation of the Bible, as long as the life and teachings of Jesus are marginalized or dispensationalized or ignored, the Gospel of Peace is not being proclaimed.

We live in an apocalyptic time, a time where the human species is on the verge of a great conversion. Christianity has helped bring us to this moment and it is Christianity that also faces this apocalyptic moment. Will we convert to the message of grace and peace? Or will Christianity just continue to be nothing other than archaic religion, cannibalizing others in order to build a Christian Empire.

Time will tell. And so we watch and wait and continue to do theology in hopes that our work will expose the satanic lie of scapegoating and bring about the conversion of Christians….to Jesus.

Uncategorized

Previous Post



January 5, 2015

Practicing Our Spirituality

Next Post



January 9, 2015 Where is God to Be Found?: A Query to the Empire of Consumer Christianity


Browse Our Archives

Select a Category Uncategorized

Select a Month May 2017 April 2017 March 2017 February 2017 January 2017 July 2015 June 2015 May 2015 April 2015 March 2015 February 2015 January 2015 December 2014 November 2014 October 2014 September 2014


Follow Us!

Follow Us on Facebook



TAKE THE

Religious Wisdom Quiz

Look to the LORD and his strength; seek his face, ____________.

Select your answer to see how you score.

Every Time Forever Eternally Always

Related posts from Christianity is Changing

Progressive Christian

God breaks mirrors.

Christianity is Changing

Progressive Christian

Anabaptism: The Gospel Reformation, Part 2 of 2

Christianity is Changing

Progressive Christian

Anabaptism: The Gospel Reformation, Part 1 of 2

Christianity is Changing

Progressive Christian

Peace of the Gospel Conference

Christianity is Changing

TRENDING AT PATHEOS Progressive Christian

Religion and Politics: How Should We Then Live?

Two cultural axioms get repeated in polite company. Don't mix religion and...

Seven Things We Get Wrong About Giving Thanks

It's a time of year when many of us turn to the...

Christ the King? Maybe We've Misunderstood the Crown

What do we mean when we say that Jesus is King? What...

Counter “Christ Is King” Nationalism with Christ THE...

Christ the King Sunday is an ideal time to address the heresy...

Advent: Making Room for Earth’s Renewal: Isaiah 61,...

Advent provides a vision of Jubilee-restoration urging us to repair and restore...

There's Room for You When Your Situation Isn't...

There's a specific story I recall that reminded me my situation isn't...

view all Progressive Christian blogs

Patheos on Facebook Patheos on YouTube

Ad-Free & Subscriber Log-In Subscription Support

Copyright 2008-2026, Patheos. All rights reserved.

Subscription Support Ad-Free & Subscriber Log-In

Follow Patheos Patheos on Facebook Patheos on YouTube