Patheos

BuddhistCatholicContemplativeEvangelicalGeneral ChristianHinduJewishLatter-day SaintMuslimNew VisionsProgressive Christian

Beliefs

Topics

Columnists

Resource Library

Research Tools

Video

Podcasts

Thought Readers

Faith In Media Tracker

Newsletters

Ad-Free & Subscriber Log-In Subscription Support

Patheos

Ad-Free & Subscriber Log-In Subscription Support

Follow Patheos Patheos on Facebook Patheos on YouTube

Articles

Five-ish Books to Understand American Religion

July 02, 2026 by Ken Chitwood

American Religion Books

This month, the United States marks its 250th anniversary.

And as we've already seen, there's a temptation to tell some pretty tidy stories about national origins and shared ideals at such a time as a Semiquincentennial.

Religion usually pops in that narrative, either as a source of moral consensus built around a shared civil religion or as a part of our supposedly celebrated patchwork society. Both assumptions, however, obscure how religion has functioned less as a stable inheritance and more as a contested, creative and often disruptive force in American life.

For the past fifteen years, I have been reading and reviewing books on American religion while trying to make sense of how scholars, journalists, and practitioners narrate the nation's religious past. Since 2014, I have also been teaching courses on U.S. religion, sitting with students as they encounter, often for the first time, the complexity, contradiction and contingency of the nation's religious life.

I was asked to provide a list of five books to help orient those looking to understand the most significant stories in American religious history as the U.S. approaches its 250th anniversary.

These five books will not give you a single story. They will, however, sharpen your sense of what is at stake in telling one.

God is Red

When I'm teaching American religious history, I find it's best to start with a view east from "Indian country."

And from a religious perspective, Vine Deloria Jr.'s God Is Red — first published in 1973 — remains one of the most incisive challenges to how "religion" is typically framed in American history.

Deloria insists that for many Indigenous traditions, religion cannot be separated from land. Sacred power is embodied and geographically located. This perspective stands in tension with the dominant narrative of American religion as something portable, carried by migrants and missionaries across space and time, seas and borders.

If you want to go even further, read Thomas Tweed's Religion in the Lands that Became America, in which the author emphasizes that religious life in North America began long before 1776 and, echoing Deloria, emphasizes the importance of ecology, geography and the place that became the nation we now know.

Reading Deloria alongside Tweed shows how the expansion of the U.S. — first as a set of contested colonies established with the Doctrine of Discovery as justification and later as a nation driven by frontier fever and a sense of Manifest Destiny — depended on the displacement of peoples whose religious worlds were inseparable from the very land being claimed by settlers and colonizers.

The narrative of a country founded on "religious freedom," in this light, looks less like a universal principle and more like a contested and unevenly applied ideal.

The Autobiography of Malcolm X

The Autobiography of Malcolm X, as told to Alex Haley, shifts the story from land to liberation. Malcolm's life includes multiple trajectories, from the Nation of Islam to broader currents of Sunni tradition, each offering a different vocabulary for understanding race, power and belonging among Black Americans.

X's story further complicates the tendency to narrate American religion, and Black liberation, through the lens of Protestant pluralism, often embodied in figures like Martin Luther King Jr. Though they "advocated for Black freedom in different ways," they were not "polar opposites." Both Malcolm and Martin drew on deep religious traditions to articulate their respective visions of justice as they also created their own currents of Black religio-political thought.

What I appreciate about Malcolm's critique in particular is how it exposes the limits of a pluralism that celebrates diversity while leaving structural inequalities intact. His turn toward transnational solidarity with Muslims across the globe also unsettles the assumption that American religious life is primarily inward-looking or isolated from or exceptional in the wider world.

Instead, it reveals a set of global connections that have long shaped how Americans imagine freedom — spiritual, political or otherwise.

Borderlands/La Frontera

Gloria Anzaldúa's Borderlands/La Frontera has been one of the most influential books I've ever read — and one that spoke to something I'd long recognized but did not have the language for.

Through evocative, multi-lingual poetry and prose, Anzaldúa provokes readers to consider what happens when the very boundaries of nation, bodies, language, and religion are, and remain, unstable.

Writing from the U.S.-Mexico borderlands, her analysis extends far beyond it. She not only shows how religion in the borderlands is hybrid, layered and often improvised to fabulous creative effect — Catholic devotions entangled with Indigenous practices, feminist reinterpretations emerging from within inherited traditions — but how this reflects the rhythms of Latinx religious life in the U.S. as a whole, where migration, colonial histories, and cultural exchange produce forms of religiosity that resist neat classification.

Beyond Anzaldúa, scholars of Latinx religion have shown how popular Catholicism, Pentecostalism, curanderismo, devotion to La Virgen and other practices coexist and interact, creating a dynamic religious field shaped by both continuity and change. Anzaldúa gives vivid language to that dynamism and makes clear that the border is not only a geographic herida (wound), but a site where power is negotiated, where identifications are policed and remade, and where what it means to be American is constantly contested and (re)created.

Women and American Religion

Ann Braude's essay "Women's History Is American Religious History" has been a revelation since it was first published in 1997. Later morphing into a monumental survey called Women and American Religion, Braude retells the lives of Margaret Winthrop, Jarena Lee, Mary Baker Eddy, Henrietta Szold, Aimee Semple McPherson and Mary Daly, demonstrating how women have been central to American religious life across the span of its last 250 years (and before).

In various periods, Braude shows, they constituted the majority of participants and were key drivers of innovation, from emergent spiritualism to revivals and reform movements. The significance of Braude's contributions lies not only in recovering overlooked figures but in rethinking how religion operates in the U.S. (and beyond).

If women have been so central, we can start to see how religious spaces have often served as arenas for negotiating gender roles, sometimes reinforcing them, sometimes subverting them.

Whatever the outcome, Braude's work encourages a more careful reading of how authority is constructed in American religion and who gets to exercise it.

The Light We Give

Finally, my friend Simran Jeet Singh's The Light We Give offers yet another vantage point on American religion, this time rooted in contemporary experience — if still deeply connected to longer histories of pluralism and exclusion.

Framed as a series of reflections on Sikh teachings and his own lived realities, Singh's book speaks to the possibilities of an inclusive, multireligious society while refusing to ignore its limits. He recounts moments of joy growing up playing basketball in Texas alongside encounters with suspicion and violence, incidents that intensified for Sikh Americans in the years after 9/11 but were not confined to that period.

His narrative underscores how certain communities are still marked as outsiders, even as the language of religious freedom and diversity is widely celebrated.

Singh is also sure to show that Sikhs are not alone in navigating these dynamics. As a scholar of religion, Singh widens the scope to speak to how Muslims, Hindus, Jews (the sixth book that would have made this list would have been Jonathan Sarna's American Judaism: A History) and other minoritized communities encounter similar hate, albeit in different forms.

The Light We Give thus serves as both testimony and critique, illustrating how American pluralism can thrive and where it falls short.

To go even deeper, check out Simran's new edited volume Modeling Religious Pluralism: Cultivating Religious Equity in Today's World, an anthology that brings together global experts to explore practical, research-backed strategies for fostering interfaith equity and justice.

Where to from here?

Taken as a group, these five books make any attempt to tell a seamless national story stumble at the starting line. They instead foreground conflict, creativity and open contradictions. They show that American religion has been shaped by struggles over land, race, gender and borders — and that these struggles are ongoing.

For readers who want to get a sweep of this story, Brook Wilensky-Lanford's A God-Shaped Nation: Five Hundred Years of Religion in America provides the kind of expansive overview that traces such interactions of Indigenous, African, European, and other religious traditions over half a millennium. In the vein of Peter Manseau's One Nation, Under Gods, Wilensky-Lanford captures the multiplicity that emerges from this history and hints at the tensions that come with it.

Together, this little library of American religious history shows how pluralism has never been an achievement in the States. It has been, and remains, a project marked by negotiation and contestation.

As we mark the Semiquincentennial, I challenge us all to not only remember but remember well.

And that requires attending to the voices and experiences that have often been sidelined, acknowledging that the story of American religion is neither singular nor settled.

Though these books may not neatly resolve those narratives, they make damn sure we cannot ignore them.

7/13/2026 6:47:07 PM

featured writer

more at patheos

1

Wyndam Clark Wins BMW Championship

Kermit Zarley

2

The Post-Millennial Age

Gene Veith

3

Death Makes a Mistake?

Rebecca Wallace Keene

4

The Biblist: The Top 20 Words Jesus Said Most in the Bible

Shawn Paul Wood

Ken Chitwood

About Ken Chitwood

Ken Chitwood is a religion nerd, writer and scholar of global Islam and American religion based in Germany. His work has appeared in Newsweek, Salon, The Los Angeles Times, The Washington Post, The Chicago Tribune, Religion News Service, Christianity Today, and numerous other publications. He is the author of The Muslims of Latin America and the Caribbean. Follow Ken on Twitter @kchitwood.

Patheos Logo Patheos Explore the world's faith through different perspectives on religion and spirituality! Patheos has the views of the prevalent religions and spiritualities of the world.

Patheos on Facebook Patheos on YouTube

Ad-Free & Subscriber Log-In Subscription Support

Copyright 2008-2026, Patheos. All rights reserved.

Subscription Support Ad-Free & Subscriber Log-In

Follow Patheos Patheos on Facebook Patheos on YouTube